4 ms·
The health care bill would seem to increase demand for healthcare services without actually increasing supply for healthcare. Doctors takes years to train, dru
by kiba 17y ago
The health care bill would seem to increase demand for healthcare services without actually increasing supply for healthcare.
Doctors takes years to train, drug trial are still expensive, amongst other thing.
All what we're doing is adding million of individuals into the healthcare system without balancing the supply side equation.
It would also seem to treat health care insurance as a sugar daddy of healthcare, instead of being treated as a mechanism that reduce risks through incentive and such. This make insurance companies big juicy targets for healthcare providers. If people were to spend their money on the daily cost of healthcare, they would be more conscious of the cost, thus use it only as neccesary. Insurances would only be used in high cost emergency measures such as cancer and other diseases, which are preventable and can be reduced by individuals.
This reduce the demand for healthcare and give people incentives to lower their cost their healthcare cost through insurance's discounts, thus less strain on the supply of healthcare.
The taxation scheme also rob people incentive of saving for emergency measures, an alternative or complement to insurance spending, which may have the side effect of impacting long run productive growth or simply maintenance of current productive capacity(Capitals need to be maintained or replaced), as saving are in effect fund the production of capitals, which eventually lead to consumer goods and services.
- tptacek 17y agoThose millions of individuals are already in the health care system. The primary impact of the bill seems to be whether their contact with the system bankrupts them or not. Either way, the hospital isn't getting $3,500 for the MRI they just ran. Your concerns all seem very reasonable. In particular, the distortion of the concept of "insurance". But, two things. First, that distortion already took place. Providers and insurers have spent the last two decades colluding on pricing and process in ways that transformed Blue Cross from an insurer to a poorly-regulated utility. Second, your concerns are orthogonal to the debate. We should train more doctors, and we should create more tiers of service (nurse practitioner clinics in particular). That has little to do with whether we should allow de facto monopolies to lock consumers out of the healthcare market.
- mattchew 17y agoFirst, that distortion already took place. Providers and insurers have spent the last two decades colluding on pricing and process in ways that transformed Blue Cross from an insurer to a poorly-regulated utility. The health care bill takes this to a whole new level, and then sets it in stone. Insurance and health care delivery was already a mess in the U.S. But prior to this bill, we might have evolved or legislated some solution that was not a stupendous giveaway to Blue Cross and Aetna. Too late now. They will never give up the privileges they get today. They get to be toll collectors on our outrageously overpriced health care system forever. Meanwhile, I read articles with people celebrating because they think this bill protects them from the health insurance industry. It's all just too depressing.
- tptacek 17y agoI agree with your sentiment. But from what I can tell, the likelihood that we were ever going to disentangle the insurers from the system was nil. It would have taken a climactic reshaping of health care, like single-payer. When I look at the well-intentioned reform ideas coming from the opposition, I see things like "deregulate and sell across state lines". These ideas don't weaken the grip of BCBS and Aetna; they encourage consolidation and push us further in the direction of the Citigroup-izing of health insurance. What's on the table will, on paper at least, ensure that startup entrepreneurs like me can actually buy insurance on the private market. We didn't have that ability before, at all. That's a win, from what I can see. Would I prefer not to have BCBS and United be the vehicles for that win? Of course. But what does that have to do with anything?
- mattchew 17y agoYou're right, we probably weren't going to disentangle the insurers. That is not an argument for handing them the keys to the nation for the sake of "doing something". Doing nothing would have been better. At a guess, doing nothing would have resulted in attempts to reform at the state level, like Massachusetts. I'd have preferred that outcome by a long way. What's on the table will, on paper at least, ensure that startup entrepreneurs like me can actually buy insurance on the private market. We didn't have that ability before, at all. That's a win, from what I can see. I do not have employer provided insurance. I buy private insurance on the market today. It costs me about $6000 a year to insure my family of four. I expect the cost of insurance, post-reform, to converge on the national average, which is around $13000. That's a loss of $7000 a year for us. Maybe somewhat less because of subsidies (we won't get much there). Maybe more, if the cost of insurance rises post-reform as it did in Massachusetts under their similar reform. It is not out of the question that we will actually give up health insurance altogether and pay the penalty instead. This would not be a win for us. If you aren't able to get individual coverage for around $6000/year now (national average), and would like to, then this bill will indeed be a win for you. Of course, if you don't like the coverage you get at that price, pay it anyway or get fined. This is getting too long, but does it seem thinkable to you that this reform might accelerate the increase in health care costs? I think it quite likely myself. If it does, too bad for everyone. We're locked in now.
- jraines 17y agoI have deliberately not followed this debate because I feel like it would take a lot of reading to really form a nuanced and correct opinion on it, which would then be useless because in most arguments you'd be facing a talking-points opinion (from either side). With that being said, it seems to me that it's not increasing demand, but helping meet unmet demand. I'm a really high risk for skin cancer. If getting insured incentivizes me to get more regualar checks at a dermatologist, that's likely to save the system money over the long run. This isn't me falling to moral hazard. The moral hazard in the system is for doctors and hospitals. My dad is a doctor (opposed to the bill, btw) but his main complaint is always about other doctors coding things like nasal congestion up to an unscrupulous level to pad their take from insurance companies. And don't get him started on hospitals. Maybe that's something opponents of the bill are aware of and opposing. Maybe the bill does nothing to fix that. But don't blame patients for making rational choices regarding healthcare based on whatever system they find themselves in. Anyway, there's my uninformed opinion without much of a point :-P
- kiba 17y agoWith that being said, it seems to me that it's not increasing demand, but helping meet unmet demand. I'm a really high risk for skin cancer. If getting insured incentivizes me to get more regualar checks at a dermatologist, that's likely to save the system money over the long run. This isn't me falling to moral hazard. Insurance companies, when not treated as healthcare sugardaddies, do not like paying for high healthcare as they want to make more money. They may give you discounts for going to more check up more, to reduce demand for their service later. If you can detect cancer earlier, than you may able to avoid higher cost cancer treatment later as well continue to be a source of revenues to the insurance company. Insurance companies don't make money off dead people, I think.
- tptacek 17y agoAgain: you use this word "sugar daddies" as if the role was foisted onto the insurers. It wasn't. The insurers colluded with the providers to set artificial, market-oblivious standard prices for procedures on a region by region, hospital by hospital basis. From what I understand, prices were often set by allocation schemes negotiated between the payers and the providers, with no apparent regard to the actual cost, supply, or demand for the procedures. At the same time, even as they managed to drastically distort the pricing of health care, insurers apparently negotiated special payment processes directly with providers, thus creating not one but two artificial tiers of pricing. It's meaningful to talk of "sugar daddies" and "insurance" only when there's a real market for health insurance. But no such market exists. For mainstream medical procedures, for the standard of care that Americans expect (a visit to a doctor, completion of the lab work the doctor requests, some form of radiology, and then a procedure or perscription to resolve whatever comes out of that diagnostic work), unless you are either willing to play chicken with the providers and say "no" when they try to collect debts, or willing to pay incredibly, drastically inflated prices for basic procedures, there is no way to get care without involving your insurer.