3 ms·
> their mentality is defined by what they're in opposition to A lot of the Irish define themselves, historically, in terms of opposition to the British.
by Chris2048 10y ago
> their mentality is defined by what they're in opposition to
A lot of the Irish define themselves, historically, in terms of opposition to the British.
- barking 10y agoThe irish are more secure in their identity than the welsh or scots in my experience
- radiorental 10y agoApart from being untrue, there is an affinity with the Welsh & Scots... What does this even mean? "define themselves, historically". The nation, certainly but you are conflating disparate notions to project a stereotype. Explain why the Irish are the largest naturalised community inside the UK?
- Chris2048 10y agoconflating disparate notions? If you put away the thesaurus, maybe it'd be easier to figure out what you're saying. Of what relevance is Wales and Scotland, when the comparison was specifically between NI and ROI? Or indeed, what naturalisation has to do with with it?
- radiorental 10y agoop stated "A lot of the Irish define themselves, historically, in terms of opposition to the British." Maybe you should read the thread before injecting your opinion. What do you think "British" (/Britain) means? What do you think 'defining oneself historically' means, if anything? Are you Irish?
- Chris2048 10y agoby op, do you mean my post? I'm accusing you of using unnecessarily obscure wording. There are many ways to define oneself as an individual. I'm talking about how many Irish see their own country from a historical perspective. If you doubted that even meant anything, then how could you conclude that I was "project[ing] a stereotype"?
- radiorental 10y agoso, you're not Irish then? There are many ways to define oneself. "Defining oneself historically" is something Americans in South Boston do. I'm not sure what you find confusing about "op stated "A lot of the Irish define themselves, historically, in terms of opposition to the British."" The Irish aren't, never have been, opposed to Britain, Great Britain & North Ireland nor the United Kingdom.
- Chris2048 10y agoWhy do you care to know if I'm Irish? An ad-hom in the making? I've clarified above what I mean by "historically" - Do you have anything to add to this in the context of the post I was replying to? > I'm not sure what you find confusing about "op stated" I'm confused because by 'op' you seem to be referring to me... > The Irish aren't, never have been, opposed to Britain, Great Britain & North Ireland nor the United Kingdom "The Easter Rising (Irish: Éirí Amach na Cásca),[2] also known as the Easter Rebellion, was an armed insurrection in Ireland during Easter Week, April 1916. The Rising was launched by Irish republicans to end British rule in Ireland and establish an independent Irish Republic while the United Kingdom was heavily engaged in World War I. It was the most significant uprising in Ireland since the rebellion of 1798, and the first armed action of the Irish revolutionary period." -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Easter_Rising https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Easter_Rising
- frabbit 10y ago> A lot of the Irish define themselves, historically, in terms of opposition to the British. I think any opposition that existed was to British military _occupation_ and economic exploitation of Ireland, not opposition to the British per se. In addition Irish identity is much richer and deeper than simply opposing something or someone. I recommend a brief dip into the rich literature and music of the island so that you don't make this embarrassing error again.
- Chris2048 10y ago> Irish identity is much richer and deeper In context of why I made such a comparison: Is NI history not deep? > so that you don't make this embarrassing error again You missed the point, so please don't pile smugness on top of it.
- teh_klev 10y ago> so that you don't make this embarrassing error again. I really don't think that condescending tone was needed, regardless of parent's knowledge of the subject matter at hand, we're above that here.
- frabbit 10y agoWhen the OP's assertion was that Irish identity is: 1) nothing more than being opposition 2) inherently racist (focussed on being anti another ethnicity) then I will take your rebuke and downvote as evidence of either a lack of thought or a deliberate attempt to insult. Stick to Scotland friend. You may actually know something about it.
- Chris2048 10y ago> inherently racist You're just throwing around that accusation to justify bad behavior. It's easy to attach any label when you have such loose definitions ("anti" "ethnicity"). > nothing more than being opposition You added "nothing more", which plays the same role as the "just" in "just a theory" - turning a statement in context into a straw-man. > then I will take your rebuke and downvote as evidence of either a lack of thought or a deliberate attempt to insult Isn't that convenient. I take the lack of content in your post as evidence of the same. > Stick to Scotland friend. You may actually know something about it. Sticking with the condescension, eh? If you know something about this topic, why not show us?