5 ms·
> There are organizations that proclaim support for free software or the GNU Project, and teach classes in use of nonfree software. It's possible that they do s
by danso 10y ago
> There are organizations that proclaim support for free software or the GNU Project, and teach classes in use of nonfree software. It's possible that they do some other things that really support free software, but those classes certainly don't. On the contrary, they work directly against the free software movement by promoting the use of the nonfree software. That increases the magnitude of the practical problem it is our mission to correct.
Just to throw out an extreme example for discussion: the Mozilla Foundation would seem to be one of the free-software organizations that RMS critiques.
One initiative they've supported is Software Carpentry: http://software-carpentry.org/scf/partners/ http://software-carpentry.org/scf/partners/
One of Software Carpentry's packaged lessons is for MATLAB: http://software-carpentry.org/lessons/ http://software-carpentry.org/lessons/
To be fair, the current MATLAB lesson plan includes asides for how GNU Octave can be used...but the fact that the curriculum is titled "Programming with MATLAB" certainly counts as promotion of non-free software.
Edit: by "extreme", I mean that Mozilla is in most people's minds a passionate advocate for free software, and the number of their affiliations with proprietary software lessons is extremely small as far as I can tell.
Edit 2: FWIW, RMS's definition of non-free software may be much more expansive than most people's:
https://stallman.org/airbnb.html https://stallman.org/airbnb.html
> Airbnb requires you to run nonfree software (an app, or Javascript). It puts you in a data base easily available to Big Brother (just like a hotel).
JavaScript is many things, but nonfree isn't one of them.
- Svip 10y agoMaybe he means the JavaScript code executed on Airbnb's website is not licenced under a free licence and thus nonfree?
- danso 10y agoYeah that's probably right: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/javascript-trap.en.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/javascript-trap.en.html Ignore my tangent.
- icen 10y agoHere is RMS' piece on nonfree javascript: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/javascript-trap https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/javascript-trap
- hobos_delight 10y ago> JavaScript is many things, but nonfree isn't one of them. I believe he is referring to the license to use/modify the JS being delivered by Airbnb specifically in this case, not the language itself.
- MichaelBurge 10y ago> JavaScript is many things, but nonfree isn't one of them. Javascript is often minified, and it's generally important to the Free Software movement that you get the original source. Otherwise, a company could comply with an open source license by providing you with a compiled binary, which does have all the functionality the source code describes. The other issue might be that you get to view the Javascript source, but might not be able to redistribute it or modify it.
- emp_zealoth 10y agoI've tried to use Octave, I really did. Passed few classes with projects made in Octave. Then I nearly failed some classes because of simple, reproductible bugs no one gave a flying fuck about. None of PCs I've installed the thing on could produce a fully working figure with subplots. For example in 5 subplots number 3 would not render at all. Or the plot would not export to png if you had too many data points. Octave bug reports were shrugged off as "not our problem - it's GhostScript" (or whatever does the png conversion, I don't remember now) GhostScript didn't bother to answer. All I can tell you the whole modularity concept is broken in practice because it promotes playing pingpong with issues. "It's not module A! It's how module B uses module A!" Unless people get off their high horses and actually fix broken shit the whole cult of free software is just delusional. And let's not forget that apart from riddiculous bugs Octave is really missing A LOT of functionality, even without going to Simulink
- anc84 10y agoCould you link me to the bug tickets? I would like to take a look.
- emp_zealoth 10y agohttp://savannah.gnu.org/bugs/?44050 http://savannah.gnu.org/bugs/?44050 Thats the one I could find, sorry.
- teekert 10y agoWhy not Python?
- minipci1321 10y ago> Unless people get off their high horses and actually fix broken shit the whole cult of free software is just delusional. I understand your frustration, but the cult of free software initially was about being able to fix the issue by oneself in any case involving software -- lots of us still value that aspect.
- emp_zealoth 10y ago
- hyperpallium 10y agoHe's thinking of it like a brand or certification. An analog could be claiming to support vegetarianism, but running a minor course on butchery.
- lokedhs 10y agoRMS isn't talking about how easy it is to access the source and modify it. What he's saying that even though the source is there, it's covered by copyright and using that source code for any purpose other than running it unchanged in your browser is a violation of that copyright. Whether or not you choose to obey that rule is besides the point. I certainly don't agree with RMS on many points, but the fact that most Javascript code on websites are "non-free" according to FSF's definition is pretty clear.
- yarrel 10y agoSoftware written in JavaScript may be free or non-free, like software in any other programming language. In this particular case the code is not freely licensed and so (by rms' definition) is not free.