3 ms·
I hope people don't flag this because of its admittedly millennial-sounding headline...I'm not a huge astronomy geek but was surprised at this particular juxtap
by danso 10y ago
I hope people don't flag this because of its admittedly millennial-sounding headline...I'm not a huge astronomy geek but was surprised at this particular juxtaposition of two familiar entities. It almost looked Photoshopped. I was also surprised that this kind of visual arrangement is unusual enough to warrant an article, but that's because I'm clueless to where our satellites are usually positioned in relation to the Earth and moon.
- foota 10y agoI believe the photo shopped look is due to the visual artifacts caused by the delay between light frequency shots mentioned in the article
- gonvaled 10y agoYep, three colors, 30 seconds apart.
- logfromblammo 10y agoEach exposure is 40 ms. The EPIC camera images at 317, 325, 340, 388, 443, 552, 680, 688, 764, and 779 nm. It transmits one photo of each spectral slice every hour. I would guess that channels used for a composite color photo for human-eye viewing would be 443nm (blue), 552nm (green), and 688nm (red), but 680nm is also a visible color (red). The NASA article also implies that one red or the other is imaged first, and green is last, so they are not taken in ascending or descending wavelength order. It is also ambiguous as to whether each spectral slice is 30s apart, or whether it is 30s total timespan between the red and green slices.
- sunseb 10y agoI agree. I'm not a crazy conspiracy theorist, but this looks photoshopped. The clouds are not moving and the moon is not rotating at all : http://imgur.com/prywsJq http://imgur.com/prywsJq
- waterphone 10y agoThe clouds absolutely are moving.
- sunseb 10y agoYes maybe and the distance between the Earth and the Moon could explain why we don't see the Moon rotation : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_distance_(astronomy)#/media/File:Earth-Moon.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_distance_(astronomy)#/me...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- chrismcb 10y agoThe clouds are moving. But you have to remember HUGE cloud formations move fairly slowly. Consider this shot is only about four hours. If you don't believe me, look at the clouds about 1/3 of the way down, over Mongolia I believe, they finish up near the center... As they move across the screen they get thinner. As far as the moon rotating, it takes about 28 days for it to rotate, this was 4 hours. So it will rotate about 2 degrees?
- mathiasrw 10y agoHow come the moon does not rotate?
- a3n 10y agoThe moon is tidally locked to the Earth. It does rotate, in the same amount of time that it orbits the Earth. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tidal_locking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tidal_locking
- moptar 10y agoYou can't say the clouds aren't moving because no instrument is sensitive enough to be sure there's exactly zero movement. All you can say is they're moving slower than some maximum speed. You could estimate that maximum speed from the pixel size and duration of the animation. Then your statement would be "the clouds are moving slower than X m/s which is too slow for real clouds.". That's then quite a sensible criticism of a suspected faked video. But "they're not moving" is nearly meaningless.
- ngoldbaum 10y agoBasically the only way to get a view like this is to be in a lissajous orbit at the Earth-Sun L1 point and happen to get a lucky alignment between the satellite, earth, and Moon sometime near a full moon.
- mhandley 10y agoIf the moon is on the sunny side of the earth, it's going to be a new moon (as viewed from Earth), not a full moon.
- ngoldbaum 10y agoOf course you're right.
- Retric 10y agoEarth sees the other side, so it's a new moon from earth and a full Moon from the satiate. However, due to location closer to the sun (L1) the satellite always sees the sunny side of the Moon.
- jcmoscon 10y agoWhat I can't understand in this animation is how come the clouds does not change during the 4 hours span?
- brazzledazzle 10y agoJust a guess but I suspect it's because the clouds are in fact moving, just not quickly enough to be noticeable from that distance.