4 ms·
It's not as simple, for example ISP's or "interactive computer service" providers do have to comply with DMCA, and probably quite a few other legislations, mean
by dogma1138 10y ago
It's not as simple, for example ISP's or "interactive computer service" providers do have to comply with DMCA, and probably quite a few other legislations, meaning that the protection from liability is not absolute.
Facebook also isn't just a bulletin board, or an aggregate since they do construct your feed, hence one could potentially argue that they are not a service provider but are the "information content provider" as defined by the Communications Decency Act.
That argument could potentially be even made stronger by the fact that facebook does employ selective moderation, they do remove certain content that goes against their TOS including "extremist" content they have deleted groups/pages of ISIS and other organizations in the past, so one could argue that they might be "unwilling" to act in this case (if that indeed is the case).
ANAL but It could quite likely not be a case that would be dismissed in a summary judgement, and considering that quite a bit of internal information about what and how facebook moderates, and more importantly how it chooses which information to show to you would potentially be revealed in the lawsuit there's a good chance that Facebook would likely go into a settlement, probably not a billion dollars but also probably not a small penny either.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> It's not as simple, for example ISP's or "interactive computer service" providers do have to comply with DMCA No, they don't. The DMCA gives them an optional procedure, which, if followed, provides a "safe harbor" exemption from liability they might have under other laws. To the extent that the CDA has already extinguished liability, there is no benefit from complying with the DMCA.