3 ms·
That's just not true; it's a variant of thinking that "Janitors at a $10B market cap company should make 10x more than those at a $1B company". Just because th
by SilasX 10y ago
That's just not true; it's a variant of thinking that "Janitors at a $10B market cap company should make 10x more than those at a $1B company".
Just because they were attached to a more valuable project doesn't mean that their specific value contribution was greater.
In the case of the janitor, we can clearly see why it's wrong: if you pay 10x much, your applicant pool will be flooded, and you will not be able to sell the resultant product[1] for more than you paid.
Likewise, when a $10 million property is sold, more value is created than with a $1M. But it doesn't mean the 10x difference was due to the agent; usually, the same price can be achieved without paying 10x as much, but various factors keep the market out of equilibrium.
[1] You have to be careful in defining the relevant market here. In this case, the "buyer" is the worker, who pays in the size of the "compensating differential" they accept. (You will have to pay a lot to get employees at disgusting, unmaintained office.) You know that you're paying too much for the janitor when their cost is higher than the induced reduction in compensating differential.
Edit: To be sure, REAs for big properties do legitimately contribute more value because of all the other ways that they can eke out a higher sales price, and janitors at prestigious offices can contribute more value than those at Walmart stores; it's just that the value contribution is not, as you implied, and was being contested by the GP, proportional to the value of the attached capital.
- rayiner 10y ago> But it doesn't mean the 10x difference was due to the agent The value added by the real estate agent is not selling the property, but selling it quickly at the highest possible price. The opportunity cost to the seller of a $10 million property sitting on the market an extra month is 10x higher than for a $1 million property. So it's not unreasonable to pay the agent more. It's certainly not "shady." Of course, if you think you can sell the property in the same time frame with a less-qualified agent, nothing is stopping you from negotiating a lower percentage fee. > usually, the same price can be achieved without paying 10x as much, but various factors keep the market out of equilibrium. Those being? The real estate industry is incredibly competitive, especially now with Redfin, etc.
- SilasX 10y ago>The value added by the real estate agent is not selling the property, but selling it quickly at the highest possible price. No one's disputing that they added more value, only that it shouldn't be directly proportional to the property. (See the "edit" remark.) >Those being? The real estate industry is incredibly competitive, especially now with Redfin, etc. I don't have insider knowledge, but "inertia" is a big one in real estate -- no one wants to be the one that starts doing things differently. And I don't think that counts as "competitive"; in a competitive industry, you can't rest on your laurels, but the top home REAs basically live off the monopoly returns from having already sold properties, whether or not they actually pass rigorous tests of their value contribution. >Of course, if you think you can sell the property in the same time frame with a less-qualified agent, nothing is stopping you from negotiating a lower percentage fee. It's not like everyone wanted to invest in every venture that ever proposed a better way of doing things, or that all value opportunities are immediately obvious to everyone and they come beating down your door to take advantage of them, even and especially when there are numerous st(ake|ock)holders with veto power. Edit: Toned down.
- rayiner 10y ago> That's not responsive; I already explained how that doesn't mean their value contribution accounted for the full difference, even as it accounted for some of the difference. (See the "edit" remark.) Your edit doesn't change my point. The primary value the real estate agent adds versus say an ad in the paper is selling now versus selling later. The value of that time-saving is directly proportional to the value of the property. > but "inertia" is a big one in real estate "Inertia" is not something that "keep[s] the market out of equilibrium." At least I've never seen it in any economics textbook as an example of market failure. > but the top home REAs basically live off the monopoly returns from having already sold properties Your argument stretches the word "monopoly" to absurdity. It takes a high school degree, a 60-hour online course, and passing an incredibly basic exam to become an REA. > Right, just like everyone wanted to invest in every venture that ever proposed a better way of doing things, because all value opportunities are immediately obvious to everyone and they come beating down your door to take advantage of them, even and especially when there are numerous st(ake|ock)holders with veto power? What stakeholders with veto power are stopping you from negotiating a lower fee with the most desperate REA you can find? If all you need is an REA so you can put up an MLS listing they're a dime a dozen.