3 ms·
«This fork, if it happens, will be proof that Ethereum is far behind bitcoin in terms of decentralization.» Wouldn't a fork imply more decentralization? Multip
by WorldMaker 10y ago
«This fork, if it happens, will be proof that Ethereum is far behind bitcoin in terms of decentralization.»
Wouldn't a fork imply more decentralization? Multiple active forks would imply multiple actors working to their own agendas towards different objectives/goals and no central fiat to realign their interests. That would certainly sound more decentralized to me. (The block size tangle and the inability for Bitcoin to fork recently to deal with that almost certainly sounded like a power/political centralization problem to this lay observer from what I was reading, but I've managed to stay somewhat unfamiliar with much of the technical nuance.)
It seems to me like a truly decentralized system would likely be prone to forking. The issue should likely not be whether the system can fork (and how difficult it might be), but how the system handles forks when it does fork.
(This is the "DVCS criteria": a DVCS must realize that merges must be common and handle sometimes heavily divergent forks well and with grace, otherwise it is a bad DVCS that users will hate.)
- mhluongo 10y agoNot really, if the fork is orchestrated and primarily by one group (the Ethereum Foundation).