4 ms·
A single wagon probably has an even number of axles, so 255 and 257 is probably impossible. But yes, those axle counters are extremely reliable, a miscount prod
by adrianN 10y ago
A single wagon probably has an even number of axles, so 255 and 257 is probably impossible. But yes, those axle counters are extremely reliable, a miscount produces quite a bit of work because then a human has to confirm that the train left the track protected by the counters.
- masklinn 10y ago> A single wagon probably has an even number of axles Do bogies with uneven number of axles even exist?
- rocky1138 10y ago> A single wagon probably has an even number of axles, so 255 and 257 is probably impossible. Voilà.
- tlrobinson 10y agoThat doesn't seem like a safe assumption: http://d2ydh70d4b5xgv.cloudfront.net/images/a/e/fleischmann-3-axle-baggage-coach-5894-ho-scale-train-car-model-mib-dba8cb993304cdd963b7f2d9df8ebe48.jpg http://d2ydh70d4b5xgv.cloudfront.net/images/a/e/fleischmann-... (Not Swiss, just the first train car I could find with 3 axels)
- rmoriz 10y agoThis German car is like 100 years old and was scraped years before they managed to implement axle counters.
- rob74 10y agoThat car may be 100 years old, but the last German three-axle cars were build in 1959 (https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Umbau-Wagen_(DB)#Dreiachsige_Umbauwagen.2C_Gattung_3yg https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Umbau-Wagen_(DB)#Dreiachsige_U...), and some of them were still in use in 2014 (https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Datei:Umbauwagen_der_DB_Bahnbau.jpg. https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Datei:Umbauwagen_der_DB_Bahnba...)
- rmoriz 10y agoNone of them are in regular use anymore and also you can't build a long enough train to exceed the limit.
- masklinn 10y ago> you can't build a long enough train to exceed the limit. You can definitely build long enough trains to blow past the limit several times, coal and ore trains are routinely 100+ cars long (with each car having at least 4 axles), the record is a BHP Billiton Iron Ore train of 682 cars and 8 locomotives.
- pfortuny 10y agoTalgo trains have just one axle per wagon... See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talgo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talgo
- camiller 10y ago257 would be impossible regardless 1,2,3,...,254,255,0,1,2,3... 1 byte. Although it is mentioned in the comments to the linked article that it is probably an electro-mechanical counter, so I am imagining a four wheel encoder with each wheel having 4 positions (although could be 8 wheels with 2 positions per wheel), electrically readable, and reset-able.
- jacquesm 10y agoTrains can be composed of all kinds of cars.
- camiller 10y agoyeah, but my point was that a mechanical counter of this nature would overflow counting 0-255 then wrapping around. So it would never get to 257. And the wheels I was referring would be in the counting mechanisim, I didn't say anything to suggest type of cars / axles etc.
- jacquesm 10y agoNo, that it won't get to 257 is the whole point here. So 257 axles with a single axle missed would end up as 256, resetting the counter -> no train present. Ditto for 255 with a single 'bounce'.
- camiller 10y agoI don't think that the article was about miscounts, otherwise it would equally be a problem for a 258 axle train that missed 2 axles. Since the article is describing a problem that occurs for multiples of 256 it is almost certainly a counter overflow issue, so a 256 axle train resets to zero and a 257 axle train would appear to the counter as 1, which is still sufficient to mark the block of track as occupied.
- jcranmer 10y agoThe standard locomotive arrangement in the US is 2 bogies of 3 axles each; 4-6-0 and 0-6-0 wheel arrangements (5 and 3 axles, resp.) on steam locomotives were also common. While the modern locomotives do have an even number of axles, it's not a multiple of 4 (like standard wagons usually are), so it's not possible to have 256 axles exactly if you have an odd number of locomotives (e.g., 2 forward/1 reverse arrangement).
- innocenat 10y agoDon't forget multiple units. Those usually have axles in multiple of 4