4 ms·
Encryption is completely orthogonal to discovery. Using non-written, non-permanent, non-recorded means of communication is something you don't have to submit i
by pas 10y ago
Encryption is completely orthogonal to discovery.
Using non-written, non-permanent, non-recorded means of communication is something you don't have to submit in discovery. (Because it cannot be.)
That said, yes, it's just trivial to assume that Uber wanted more, however, it's also quite standard operating procedure that in these cases all the legal responsibility is on the contractor, unless someone can somehow produce evidence that points to someone at Uber expressly requesting this "extralegal" investigation. (Though that does not mean the contractor is off the hook, unless they cut a deal with the DA, yaddayadda.)
- peterbonney 10y ago"Using non-written, non-permanent, non-recorded means of communication is something you don't have to submit in discovery. (Because it cannot be.)" Yes. But taking action to evade discovery after litigation has become active is quite a bit different from choosing not to retain information that may or may not ever become subject to litigation. I guess I should have said "the chat app ate my homework" is a valid excuse if you always use the homework-eating chat app. But if you start using the homework-eating chat app because you're intending to discuss active litigation, that's just getting too cute. Let's be clear here: you don't have to delete or encrypt communications to protect it from discovery. Privileged attorney-client work product is always protected from discovery, whether it's in plain text, encrypted, written on paper, or whatever. But for some reason (I speculated on one) they chose not to do this work as attorney-client work product.