5 ms·
Correct me if I'm wrong, but Nintendo is not the creator of the Pokemon Go game. Niantic (spelling?) licenses the Pokemon brand from Nintendo. So in this case
by chatmasta 10y ago
Correct me if I'm wrong, but Nintendo is not the creator of the Pokemon Go game. Niantic (spelling?) licenses the Pokemon brand from Nintendo.
So in this case the comparison is not between selling in-app coins vs games. It's between licensing IP to the company that sells coins, vs selling games.
- Sephiroth87 10y agoTechnically Nintendo is not even the full owner of Pokemon, that would be The Pokemon Company [1], which is only partially owned by Nintendo [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Pokémon_Company https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Pokémon_Company
- donkeyd 10y agoYet Nintendo market cap gained 7 billion on Pokemon Go alone. I wonder if these investors really have no idea that the tech behind the game is Niantic and that Pokemon isn't even completely owned by Nintendo, or that there's something I'm missing here.
- intoverflow2 10y agoThe tech is the least important part of this whole thing. It's not successful because it's particularly innovative or a fancy piece of tech, it's a success because it's pokemon.
- donkeyd 10y agoYet I've seen a lot of comments of people who really enjoy the augmented reality part of it, which was inherited largely from Ingress. Sure, the Pokemon IP is a huge part of the reason it took off. But the reason people actually like it is much bigger than that.
- jolux 10y agoYes except almost nobody plays Ingress and this game hasn't been out a month and it's about to pass Twitter in popularity...
- wmccullough 10y agoPokemon popularity != Twitter popularity. You wouldn't go around comparing the popularity of Doom to Facebook right? This comparison needs to disappear.
- Larrikin 10y agoFacebook is obviously more popular than Doom, but the article is comparing two Android apps which is a fair comparison
- treehau5 10y agoWe are comparing popularity of things people waste time on. In my eyes, they are all the same. It's the past-time market.
- Spivak 10y agoBecause of how people, including myself, are using the game I think comparison to social networks is more than fair. I have never seen more people out downtown wandering around and talking to strangers.
- distantsounds 10y agoI'd love to see where you get your numbers from considering Niantic doesn't publish active player stats for Ingress.
- jolux 10y agowell it's purely anecdotal I'll say but everyone I know is playing Pokémon Go right now and before only my really really "nerdy" friends played Ingress.
- 10y ago
- ajkjk 10y agoWhy is that weird? Investors just got proof that there's a lot of new untapped potential in the Pokemon brand.
- avree 10y agoPokemon Go is magnitudes larger than Ingress, their previous project, even though it's been plagued with more issues than Ingress and is arguably not as fully featured. The difference? Pokemon, which Nintendo owns. If I was an investor, I'd view the potential for licensing the Nintendo IP (something Nintendo has been extremely reluctant to do in the past) as a huge potential growth vector for a struggling market segment (consoles, specifically Nintendo-made ones.)
- donkeyd 10y agoTrue. Nintendo, of course, has a lot more IP than just Pokemon that they could license for all kinds of stuff. And the people who grew up with their games are now earning money, so they can actually buy the licensed material. Good point.
- hockley 10y agoThey could be like Marvel. Tons of characters and story lines to license for film and games.
- distantsounds 10y agoMarvel licensed their IP out to Marvel Puzzle Quest (which was somewhat of a Bejeweled clone) and was quite successful with it. They didn't have a huge studio behind it either.
- tuna-piano 10y agoI considered buying the stock, for the reason that maybe this means (1) Nintendo has quietly shifted their strategy to include mobile and other platforms or (2) seeing this mobile money will finally convince Nintends that they can make a ton more with additional mobile titles. Either way, I expect Nintendo will finall be releasing more mobile games. I suspect investors think the same thing, leading to the $7b increase.
- revertts 10y ago"Quietly shifting their strategy" - they've been very public about a partnership with DeNA since at least March of last year. Given their success with micropayments in 3DS and similar titles, I've got high hopes for Miitomo/Go/etc.
- xiaoma 10y agoNintendo has never been about the tech. Not the NES, not when Sega released the Genesis while they pushed SMB3 for their "wimpy" 8-bit system, not when they crushed both Sony ans MS with the underpowered original Wii and not now. Sony will live or die based on their ability to make great tech. Nintendo is different.
- exclusiv 10y agoI wouldn't say they crushed Sony and MS. They sold a lot of Wiis but not a lot of games per console.
- kalleboo 10y agoThat's true. (for those who don't know, Niantic is the Google spinoff also responsible for Ingress).
- nightpool 10y agoI believe the app is a collaboration between Niantic and TPC, rather then just a straight licensing. Niantic has the AR-game expertise and has very clearly learned a lot of good lessons from running Ingress for three (4?) years now, while the Pokemon Company obviously knows a lot about making a good Pokemon game and probably had a lot of creative input.
- 27182818284 10y agoNintendo became an investor in Niantic in October of 2015