4 ms·
This article is so over the top that it borders on parody. Start with the title: "Everything we love to eat is a scam". I can provide lots of counter examples
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 10y ago
This article is so over the top that it borders on parody.
Start with the title: "Everything we love to eat is a scam". I can provide lots of counter examples to that statement.
Other statements with my comments
"After reading it you’ll want to be fed intravenously for the rest of your life." - Look up total intraparenteral nutrition and see if you would prefer that to eating.
"Escolar is so toxic that it’s been banned in Japan for 40 years, but not in the US, where the profit motive dominates public safety. In fact, escolar is secretly one of the top-selling fish in America.". - By toxic the author means causes diarrhea due to unabsorbed oils/waxes. Also when we you hear that a lot of people are eating a lot of very toxic food, the food either is not very toxic or else not widely consumed.
"These fake foods produce shallow, flat, one-dimensional tastes, while the real things are akin to discovering other galaxies, other universes — taste levels most of us have never experienced." - I can imagine Galileo realizing that discovering the moons of Jupiter pailed in comparison to eating real Parmigiano cheese.
"Imagine if half the time you pulled into a gas station, you were filling your tank with dirty water instead of gasoline,” Olmsted writes. “That’s the story with seafood.”" - Zero calorie seafood, I never knew?
"Perhaps most surprising of all: discount big-box stores such as Costco, Trader Joe’s, BJ’s Wholesale Club and Walmart are as stringent with their standards as Whole Foods." - In my opinion, the more "hipster" a food establishment is, the less likely that they are really taking care of the food basics. When was the last time you heard of a large-scale McDonalds food poisoning incident? How about Chipotle?
This is one of those genres where books try to convince people that the sky is falling. In reality, we have never had such abundant, safe food in the history of humanity. Other than the people who truly have food allergies, the vast majority of people are really unaffected by any of these "revelations". In addition, especially for seafood, the substitutions are probably more ecologically sustainable.
Relevant xkcd: https://xkcd.com/915/ https://xkcd.com/915/
- m_mueller 10y ago> By toxic the author means causes diarrhea due to unabsorbed oils/waxes. Oh, I see. No problem then, move along. > Zero calorie seafood, I never knew? Reading favourably before going into a rant is an important skill to have. If you try it, you'll see that the article has a good point with fake seafood, past the somewhat ridiculous comparison. > In reality, we have never had such abundant, safe food in the history of humanity. The US has also slipped to 27th place in life expectancy. So is everything good enough now? Should we never innovate again, because "look how bad people had it in the past"?
- savanaly 10y ago>So is everything good enough now? Should we never innovate again, because "look how bad people had it in the past"? I don't think the guy you're responding to said we should never innovate again, just that the level headed response to today's food situation in the United States is not to declare there is an apocalypse, which is what the article is doing.
- m_mueller 10y agoTbh. I'm a bit confused by this reaction. When we had the horse meat scandal in Europe, it was a huge, in the news for weeks. If this article is right, it seems like this sort of scam is almost the norm in the US, and people don't really seem to care. In the countries I'm most familiar with (Western Europe, Japan), if a restaurant turns out to be feeding you a cheap substitution for what they advertise, they are done for. Even big chains like Mac Donalds aren't safe, as they had to painfully recognise in July 2014 [1] following a meat scandal. Their sales went down a third for about a year, resulting in quite a substantial operative loss. If potentially dangerous fake olive oil or Tuna doesn't cause a huge media outcry in the US, what will? [1] http://www.wsj.com/articles/food-scandals-push-mcdonalds-japan-into-loss-1423121899 http://www.wsj.com/articles/food-scandals-push-mcdonalds-jap...
- soundwave106 10y agoEscolar is generally not a problem if you limit portion size, so calling the fish "toxic" is a little bit overblown. It is a very tasty fish, to be honest. The problem here is that the labeling is poor. It's too often called "white tuna" in American sushi restaurants (as the article implies), for I guess marketing reasons. And there's no warning about potential gastrointestinal difficulties. From what I can Google, sushi restaurants are incredibly bad about mislabeling fish. (We all know that "wasabi" is usually green dyed horseradish, too. :) )
- avree 10y agoDid you include Chipotle as a joke, or is it somehow more "hipster" to you than McDonald's...? I really don't understand this comment. I agreed with the first sentence and then proceeded to get more and more lost until I got to the bottom and found your 'relevant' xkcd that has nothing to do with the article at all.
- savanaly 10y agoThe Chipotle thing is a joke at the expense of Chipotle. They had a reputation as being greener, having real food, and being healthy, and then it turned out that a lot of people got food poisoning from food in their supply chain. As for the xkcd, here's a guide to how it's relevant, as I interpret it: cheap wine is to American food as good wine is to real food.