3 ms·
Every article about Theranos seems to end in criticism of Holmes, but if the apparent situation is true – that the technology just doesn't really work – it seem
by danpalmer 10y ago
Every article about Theranos seems to end in criticism of Holmes, but if the apparent situation is true – that the technology just doesn't really work – it seems her actions are pretty much to be expected. Most of what she has done would be to buy more time to try and figure out the technology (which makes sense), and to try to save some face, which is understandable.
- chmaynard 10y agoTheranos needs to show the scientific community that blood oozing from an open wound (a finger prick), contaminated by tissues and surface bacteria, is clinically comparable to blood extracted directly from a vein. They also need to prove that analyzing a diluted, contaminated blood sample with the Siemens instrument produces an accurate result. Perhaps Theranos hasn't published any research on the scientific foundations of their technology because they have nothing of value to show us.
- madgar 10y agoThis is the dirty secret that nobody here wants to admit: the entire startup system that so many here benefit from incentivizes digging yourself deeper. Folks want to blame Elizabeth Holmes for taking seriously all the startup mantras. "Shoot for the moon" and "Fake it until you make it" and "Startups are about people, not ____" and "Use your resources". Sure, startups are supposed to "fail fast" too, but whenever a startup actually voluntarily returns money to investors early it's the talk of the town. Nobody ever expected that from a startup with as much capital as Theranos got.