4 ms·
Sorry, no. Giving people more options (as in, unrestricted money to spend) is the opposite of coercion. Even if it's not enough to live off by itself, everythin
by skybrian 10y ago
Sorry, no. Giving people more options (as in, unrestricted money to spend) is the opposite of coercion. Even if it's not enough to live off by itself, everything helps.
For example, like unemployment benefits, it gives breathing room to hold out for a better job. Or if they're in a union, it's something to live on during a strike. Or maybe they will take the casual job.
Who knows? How people choose to use their freedom can be hard to predict. That can be a little scary. But the point is it's their choice, not ours.
- brbsix 10y ago> Giving people more options (as in, unrestricted money to spend) is the opposite of coercion. The context is important. Are these "options" given willingly or taken by force? The distinction is pretty important. It's the difference between making love (a voluntary interaction) and rape (an involuntary one). If this "unrestricted money" is to be collected by force (or the threat of it), it is most certainly coercive.
- ubernostrum 10y agoYou should be aware that it's entirely possible to construct justification of tax-supported UBI or other social-welfare programs in a way that is just even by libertarian standards. Admittedly many variations involve recasting the tax as a sort of civil damages award, but it works.
- skybrian 10y agoYes, of course taxes are coercive. I was talking about the other side. The person getting unrestricted money to spend isn't being coerced. Compare with conditional transfers (you get the money but only if you meet certain requirements). That can be coercive in effect, if you need the money badly enough.