4 ms·
I really dislike comments like these. First, because of the reification of a "class" as a villainous force which--we might imagine--can be defeated. This is a v
by cynicalkane 10y ago
I really dislike comments like these. First, because of the reification of a "class" as a villainous force which--we might imagine--can be defeated. This is a very dangerous reification, because the ordinary dynamics of a supply+demand economy become recast as a war of Good vs Evil.
But when your boss wants you to move, this (usually) isn't under direction of a Global Capitalist Conspiracy, and when you decline for a local opportunity, this isn't a victory for the Forces of Good. If we pretend that it is, we completely lose the ability to 1) look at what really is happening; 2) ask who it is good for and what the trade-offs are, and 3) fix it if there's something wrong with 2).
For instance, the licensing issue brought up in TFA is a very real barrier for poor workers who can't afford the training and licensing costs for career advancement. Often those licenses are nearly meaningless. This is a valid concern and one where labor market flexibility clearly favors the most disadvantaged workers. In addition, site- or business-granular licensing clearly favors capitalists as well. More generally, a lot of anti-worker situations fall under the category of poor labor flexibility.
The second reason I dislike comments like the above is that they snarkily express a popular emotion, and get the upvotes, but add nothing to the conversation.
- dtornabene 10y agoI personally dislike comments like yours as well? Is this fun? Class politics is a very real thing, for better or worse. And smearing/confusing the parent with cutesy Capital Letter Disdain seems fairly hypocritical, given your protestation of "this adds nothing to the conversation". One can argue this or that about macro policy, and I for one am not in a rush to brand "academics" as a "class", but to rule out class as a dirty word seems a bit bizarre in a post-piketty world (choosing the least likely to offend theorist of generational wealth inequality).
- gdwatson 10y agoIt's not just class politics. Different social classes have (broadly speaking) different values. If you consider yourself a cosmopolitan and a citizen of the world, the losses to local community that accompany increased mobility may not even occur to you.