3 ms·
You sound like a Sarah Palin speech. Instead of using meaningless buzzwords like "elite" maybe be specific about who exactly you are referring to. That aside I
by threeseed 10y ago
You sound like a Sarah Palin speech. Instead of using meaningless buzzwords like "elite" maybe be specific about who exactly you are referring to.
That aside I don't know where you get the idea that the Republican party would be for a universal basic income. Their current position (under Trump at least) is to abolish the minimum wage in order to encourage everyone to work. And they have always favoured individual responsibility and opposed government handouts.
- marcoperaza 10y agoI edited my comment to remove that bit but I'll clarify who I'm talking about: the people who see their project as bringing more and more of our lives under the direction of the state, because they know better than you and me how we should live our lives. They've convinced the rank and file that this is the best way to achieve across the board prosperity. The prospect of a hundred years of progress toward this slow takeover being wiped out by a basic income is the biggest threat to their project. Also, I'm pretty sure that Trump's and probably most Republicans' position on the minimum wage is that it's ideally set by the individual states in accordance with the realities of their economies. A $15 federal minimum wage would devastate vast swaths of America by effectively banning work. The economy in much of America simply can't sustain that. But yes, if we adopted a UBI we should most certainly eliminate the minimum wage, since it accomplishes the same goal much more comprehensively (i.e. for everyone as opposed to just those who have a job).
- threeseed 10y agoYou are making generalisations so broad that it is impossible to understand what you are even talking about. Rank and file means how many tens of millions of people exactly ? And since when did they all speak with one voice ?
- A_COMPUTER 10y agoThat didn't sound like a Sarah Palin speech, not even remotely. What it sounded to me like was Richard Nixon, who proposed a similar thing for similar reasons, but couldn't get the proposal past the Senate: http://www.alternet.org/economy/how-richard-nixon-almost-gave-america-basic-income-and-why-we-should-do-it-now http://www.alternet.org/economy/how-richard-nixon-almost-gav... Why didn't it happen, in the words of Canadian Professor Eveyln Forget (of the University of Manitoba, Canada) “The political right is afraid people will stop working and the left doesn't trust them to make their own choices.”