5 ms·
The US needs more flexible labor markets
- superuser2 10y agoOther factors, possibly: - Signing a new lease costs a few thousand dollars (security deposit, possibly several months' rent, etc). Or transaction costs, if you're a home buyer. Americans across income levels are generally living paycheck-to-paycheck [0] and would need to scale down their standard of living for at least a few months to save enough money to move. It seems only elite jobs pay relocation expenses. - Two-earner households are more common than in the 1970s; it's harder to find two new jobs than just one. - People seem to be more concerned about school district quality, restricting the amount of housing supply seen as viable. (I made this one up, apologies if that's wrong). - Homes are bigger (by nearly 2x) and presumably have more stuff in them as well [1], which increases the logistical difficulty and expense of moving. [0] http://bigstory.ap.org/article/965e48ed609245539ed315f83e01b6a2 http://bigstory.ap.org/article/965e48ed609245539ed315f83e01b... [1]https://www.aei.org/publication/todays-new-homes-are-1000-square-feet-larger-than-in-1973-and-the-living-space-per-person-has-doubled-over-last-40-years/ https://www.aei.org/publication/todays-new-homes-are-1000-sq...
- mockturtle 10y agoLabor would be much more flexible if it weren't so tightly related to those human beings and all their pesky baggage.
- norikki 10y agoExactly. That's what globalist like Brookings want. To remove 'baggage' like community, family, heritage, and loyalty to one's fellow countrymen; and replace those things with their own ideology.
- mockturtle 10y agoTo somewhat contradict myself (or at least my snarky attitude), the suggestions in the article would benefit workers and businesses. But generally speaking, yes, Brookings drinks deeply from the neoliberal coolaid.
- afarrell 10y ago> Signing a new lease costs a few thousand dollars This depends on the location. Boston? Absolutely. Austin? Not in my experience.
- bmurphy1976 10y ago> People seem to be more concerned about school district quality, restricting the amount of housing supply seen as viable. (I made this one up, apologies if that's wrong). You are not wrong. We are in this exact position right now. We are likely going to be forced to do an add on to our house which is too small (and all the bs this entails). If we move, we lose the nice school district and location. If we buy new in the same neighborhood we are house poor. If we buy used we have a compromised house like we already own. If we tear down and rebuild, we are house poor again and taxes go through the roof. It sucks, there's no easy option and the school district is the most important consideration by far.
- tamana 10y agoGood school district is mostly a myth. A "good school" is mainly school whose students come from successful families. You could raise your kids anywhere reasonably safe and they'd do just as well as at a "good school" , as long your family and your kids' friends maintain an ethic for education
- matthewmcg 10y agoMaybe the causal relationship is a myth, but that's enough to create a self-reinforcing phenomenon of inter-related property values and perceived school quality.
- Swizec 10y agoImho it's a network effect. Peer pressure is real. Do you want your kids to be peer pressured into high paying careers or into minimum wage jobs?
- HarryHirsch 10y agoAlso, network effect amongst the teachers. Do you want to teach or do you want to pretend to teach?
- bmurphy1976 10y agoYeah I don't think so. I've got three kids to fund through college. It is extraordinary important that we get this right. I know we could send them to private school but there are tradeoffs just like with everything else. It's a huge ugly balancing act.
- analog31 10y agoPeople seem to be more concerned about school district quality, restricting the amount of housing supply seen as viable. (I made this one up, apologies if that's wrong). Not just school district quality, but if you have kids who are entrenched in specific activities, then there are other factors as well: * Are there enough educated parents in the school district to manage the schools effectively through involvement and activism? * Good private music teachers? * Healthy lifestyle, such as bike and pedestrian friendly? * Socially tolerant? Those are some things on my own punch list. Another family might have its own interests that are no easier to fulfill.
- kps 10y agoAdverse Outcomes to Early Middle Age Linked With Childhood Residential Mobility http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.amepre.2016.04.011 http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.amepre.2016.04.011
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoYeah. As it turns out, coupling real estate and schooling was a bad idea. Who knew?
- TulliusCicero 10y agoAnother issue is that the areas with the strongest job markets (e.g. the bay area) have exorbitant housing costs, constraining people (especially those with kids or pets) from moving there, even if they'd be able to find a good fit job-wise. Some of that is inherent; you're always going to have costlier housing in booming areas than ones that are economically depressed. But a lot of it, as has been discussed here before, is due to restrictive zoning laws that make it hard to match housing demand with housing supply.
- atemerev 10y agoOnce again — why everyone needs to be in Bay Area to work productively? From the SF employers' perspective, if on the one side is "hire locally and pay exorbitant salaries to cover exorbitant costs of rent and everything else", and on the other is "hire remotely and get the best of both worlds", why the first option is ever chosen?
- TulliusCicero 10y agoThere are logistical issues to distributed teams. It can definitely work, but I think it's context dependent. It's not a panacea to high housing/labor costs; if it was, you'd already see the big tech giants like Google/Facebook/etc. predominately hiring in cheaper places, which they're not doing.
- atemerev 10y agoThis is what I am asking. Why they are not doing it? And if there is a compelling reason for FB/Google, is it valid for everyone else?
- tamana 10y agoThrowing your life away to work for these companies is a show of commitment that you don't get from someone who sacrifice to get a job.
- TulliusCicero 10y ago
- lifeisstillgood 10y agoOh for heavens sake. Why is it every time recession bites it's the poor bloody workers that need to get their rights curtailed, their notice periods chopped, their families spread over thousands of miles just to keep profits up. Why can't the companies start flexing ! Why can't we have we have more most jobs as remote work, office jobs that don't demand 9-5. why can't they pay me more money for my "flexibility" - according to the article it's going to cost billions if I am not flexible, so give me some of that. And non-compete clauses - yeah don't make me laugh. Don't want me to compete with you. Pay me then! Really almost all of these problems go away if the companies fork out gobs more cash for their workers, or start getting realistic with how the social contract has been ripped up so that the implied promise of cash in all the years to come has to be paid now. Learn to do NPV calculations for the salary in twenty years time you aren't going to pay me. Workers need to move across country to get a job. Most people on HN could do their job from a different continent. Companies in the Bay Area would stop competing for the brightest SF residents and have to compete with companies the world over. I think that is the point - the labour market is the one market that has not (yes, not) been globalised yet. Almost all companies hire within thirty miles of the office doing the hiring. Imagine if you could only get food, goods and services within a thirty mile radius. Globalisation seems to be working for other things - roll on the globalised labour market. Cough up boys. Edit: added extra rant at no extra charge.
- kaonashi 10y ago"Flexible labor markets" is just a euphemism for worker insecurity. Real class war stuff here. You can't have an underclass without oppression.
- chrischen 10y agoThey do. It's called Uber and Lyft. And special interests are trying to get them to categorize their workers as employees.
- Gibbon1 10y ago> Oh for heavens sake. Why is it every time recession bites it's the poor bloody workers that need to get their rights curtailed, their notice periods chopped, their families spread over thousands of miles just to keep profits up. When I saw (brookings.edu) I knew I was going to read the above in the FA.
- euroclydon 10y agoThey left out home ownership. People own large houses, full of crap, with large mortgages, and since sellers must compete with new inventory, they have to stage their house, usually while living in them. With painting, upgrading materials and flooring, you can easily be looking at having to put $10K - $15K into a home to get top dollar back out. It's a daunting prospect, if you're working, have kids, and especially if you've done it once before.
- thaumasiotes 10y ago> It's a daunting prospect, if you're working, have kids, and especially if you've done it once before. I don't understand that third one. Usually, having done something once before makes it less daunting the second time?
- weaksauce 10y agoThe first time you do it you probably underestimate the actual amount of work it is. Second time you are probably weary from past experience.
- alatkins 10y agoI've relocated overseas before (and returned). Never again, now I know the impact to health and finances.
- yardie 10y agoFirst time you don't underestimate, you simply don't have a choice. Our first place that we bought we had a budget. The banks approved us for a loan based on our income. And even with that we were looking for fixer uppers in specific areas because that is all we could afford. Now we are older, have a bit of equity, more liquidity, and overall more savvy. A fixer-upper is no longer in the cards. But it was an experience.
- Merad 10y agoIt's practically impossible to have a pleasant moving experience. Even in college when you don't really have any possessions except a bed, sofa and some clothes it's unpleasant. As you gain possessions (and family members) it only gets exponentially worse. My last relocation was from a 1BR apartment to a house ~100 miles away. Even with a moving company doing most of the packing and heavy lifting, it was still a week long exhausting process to get moved and probably a month after that before everything was really unpacked and semi orderly. I really dread next time.
- Shivetya 10y agoOccupational licensing is the biggest job killer and one of the reasons why the poor stay poor. It can cost more to become a hair dresser than an EMT all because of licensing and schooling. Worse many licensed jobs explicitly exclude felons which means many cannot even get a job on the outside that they would otherwise qualify for. Call the indirect tax of mega proportions. Entire industries are supported by this licensing and it really is more pervasive than you would suspect. For something closer to home go look at the issues Uber, Lyft, and such have had. All because heavily regulated industries protect businesses established but not workers.
- dmix 10y agoNailed it, working class people are heavily affected by this. And regulation/agencies only seem to grow in scope and power rather than adapt to change or responding to the measurement of the positive/negative results of their work.
- im3w1l 10y agoYet I have heard taxi drivers complain that uber and lyft drives down wages? It's almost as if an artificially restricted supply of workers increases wages.
- jernfrost 10y agoObviously that depends on whether training and schooling is easily and cheaply available or not. In the US this might surely create a problem for the poor, but in e.g. Nordic countries (I am from Norway) there is usually massive economic support available for retraining, school, university etc, so this isn't really an issue. As long as getting into a school isn't a high barrier, licensing could be positive in that it keeps a certain quality in a profession. Quite to the contrary I think many problems in American society is caused by too lax standards. E.g. Prison guards and police in Norway receive years of training compared to weeks or months in the US. A lot of that is about deescalating situations, understanding mental illnesses, negotiating etc. E.g. a Norwegian prison guard is more like a social worker than a gorilla with a big stick. A lot of issues are connected and can't be solved in isolation. E.g. why are health care so expensive in the US? One factor is that many health care professionals have a high wage. Why do they have such a high wage in the US compare to many other countries? A common tradeoff is that higher risks require higher rewards. You don't buy high risk stocks with low potential for return. Nobody will risk getting into massive debt for medical school in the US without the potential for a big reward. Thus the lack of cheap/free college education in the US also helps drive up health care costs. So when it comes to poor people, licensing, education, you have to look at the whole "ecosystem".
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- carsongross 10y agoThe US needs families, er, the labor pool to uproot out of communities[1], er, be more flexible for the whims of global capital. Why aren't you doing this, labor pool? Sincerely, The Managerial & Academic Classes [1] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y3ttxGMQOrY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y3ttxGMQOrY
- cynicalkane 10y agoI really dislike comments like these. First, because of the reification of a "class" as a villainous force which--we might imagine--can be defeated. This is a very dangerous reification, because the ordinary dynamics of a supply+demand economy become recast as a war of Good vs Evil. But when your boss wants you to move, this (usually) isn't under direction of a Global Capitalist Conspiracy, and when you decline for a local opportunity, this isn't a victory for the Forces of Good. If we pretend that it is, we completely lose the ability to 1) look at what really is happening; 2) ask who it is good for and what the trade-offs are, and 3) fix it if there's something wrong with 2). For instance, the licensing issue brought up in TFA is a very real barrier for poor workers who can't afford the training and licensing costs for career advancement. Often those licenses are nearly meaningless. This is a valid concern and one where labor market flexibility clearly favors the most disadvantaged workers. In addition, site- or business-granular licensing clearly favors capitalists as well. More generally, a lot of anti-worker situations fall under the category of poor labor flexibility. The second reason I dislike comments like the above is that they snarkily express a popular emotion, and get the upvotes, but add nothing to the conversation.
- dtornabene 10y agoI personally dislike comments like yours as well? Is this fun? Class politics is a very real thing, for better or worse. And smearing/confusing the parent with cutesy Capital Letter Disdain seems fairly hypocritical, given your protestation of "this adds nothing to the conversation". One can argue this or that about macro policy, and I for one am not in a rush to brand "academics" as a "class", but to rule out class as a dirty word seems a bit bizarre in a post-piketty world (choosing the least likely to offend theorist of generational wealth inequality).
- vacri 10y agoThe US has plenty of flexibility in the labour market. When I hear about people moving city to get a job, Americans seem a lot more casual about it (maybe not 'casual', maybe 'accepting') - there's a lot of mid-sized cities there, and the local culture is fairly uniform in a given region. Moving to the next city across is normal. When I hear Europeans or antipodeans talk about moving city for a job, it's usually either extremely lucrative or as a last resort. Anecdata, impressions only, etc.
- jernfrost 10y agoI would think a restriction in the US compared to e.g. Europe is that many people in the US hold on to a particular job due to the health insurance they have at that particular job. A second issue is mortgages. While that is a problem in many European countries as well, some countries like Germany have a much higher portion of the population renting. Moving is thus much less of an economic risk, as you don't have the potential problem of moving from an area with economic depression where you can't sell your house without a big loss.
- ourmandave 10y agoSo it's non-compete contracts and licensing that's stopping all those workers in Indiana from moving to Mexico to continue working at Carrier? O_o http://www.npr.org/2016/03/14/470418449/moving-air-conditioning-jobs-to-mexico-becomes-hot-campaign-issue http://www.npr.org/2016/03/14/470418449/moving-air-condition...
- sunstone 10y agoIf by flexible you mean more union jobs then yes you're right. http://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21650086-salaries-rich-countries-are-stagnating-even-growth-returns-and-politicians-are-paying http://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21650086-salaries-ric...