4 ms·
The concept of a vacuum tube dates back further. You can look up Evacuated Tube Transport (ETT), which is basically the core of the Hyperloop idea. There was o
by djsumdog 10y ago
The concept of a vacuum tube dates back further. You can look up Evacuated Tube Transport (ETT), which is basically the core of the Hyperloop idea.
There was one company that was proposing building an ETT between Chattanooga, TN and Atlanta, GA in the US; reducing the two and a half hour drive to less than twenty minutes. It never really got past the environmental planning phase (plus Chattanooga didn't want Atlanta commuters, because the South and anti-progress).
A successful tube transport system could be technologically ground breaking. Theoretically they'd be faster than airplanes and use a fraction of the fuel/energy (once they're constructed of course; not counting development costs).
But they have all the same design problems of monorails (the worst and least expandable form of public transportation). Difficult to switch lines and difficult to extend. Also you get the additional difficulty of turning, which apparently is very difficult in ETTs.
- protomyth 10y ago> But they have all the same design problems of monorails (the worst and least expandable form of public transportation). Difficult to switch lines and difficult to extend. Also you get the additional difficulty of turning, which apparently is very difficult in ETTs. I see the fan group for monorails has a response on the switches http://www.monorails.org/tMspages/switch.html http://www.monorails.org/tMspages/switch.html - what are they missing?
- jcranmer 10y agoMonorails operate at relatively low speeds. It's much easier to switch something running 20 mph than something at 200 mph, particularly because you start running into issues with the acceleration curves and thus having the two lines angle off appropriately.
- bubuga 10y ago> A successful tube transport system could be technologically ground breaking. Theoretically they'd be faster than airplanes and use a fraction of the fuel/energy (once they're constructed of course; not counting development costs). The track would also be far more expensive to operate and build than high-speed rail in pretty much any aspect of the project, the tolerances that need to be complied with for safety reasons are orders of magnitude smaller than the ones in high-speed rail, and it's impossible to ensure a human-tolerable ride. It appears that everyone is caught in the romantic vision of the future that the Hyperloop salespeople are dedicated to sell to the public, but rarely are the fundamental problems even mentioned. There are plenty of good reasons why maglev hasn't caught, and the concept being sold by Hyperloop's sales team is far more limiting and expensive to pull than the maglev concept.