7 ms·
>Gays and other queer people may breed out of the gene pool if their modern freedom reduces the fertility of their genes. By that logic gays shouldn't exist to
by noobermin 10y ago
>Gays and other queer people may breed out of the gene pool if their modern freedom reduces the fertility of their genes.
By that logic gays shouldn't exist today.
- Aelinsaar 10y agoFor most of history whatever your sexuality, you married and had children. Period. You also did whatever else you did, and maybe you had a terrible marriage, but that probably wasn't unusual for straight people for most of history either.
- noobermin 10y agoLet me expand my objection, homosexuality not only exists in humans but in many other animals, many of which do not have social stigma of homosexuality.
- Aelinsaar 10y agoIt may just be that in any system as complicated as sexual aim and expression, you will have variations like homosexuality.
- nikdaheratik 10y agoActually no, historically large percentages of the population (whatever their sexuality), especially the male population, did not marry as it was very expensive to start their own household. That's one reason why so many gifts were traditionally given for weddings. Though you do have a point WRT divorce being very uncommon.
- Aelinsaar 10y agoThat... seems wrong, but I don't know enough about this to dispute what you're saying. :|
- amargherio 10y agoHe's not saying that they shouldn't exist today, just that their genes will never make it back into the collective gene pool, stopping their traits and characteristics from ever propagating forward.
- cjslep 10y agoBut that's not how how genotypes and phenotypes work for recessive alleles. Homosexual genes will continue to live on and propagate in heterosexuals so long as they aren't eliminated by the gene therapy as seen in sci-fi horror/suspense Hollywood films. It doesn't require a homosexual parent to have a homosexual kid.
- toasterlovin 10y agoBut if the individuals who have the greatest expression or concentration of these genes are having children less frequently (because they are no longer pressured into having children by their relatives/community), then this will act as a siphon for those genes over many generations. That doesn't mean that they will completely disappear, but that these genes would become much less prevalent.
- gwern 10y ago'But that's not how how genotypes and phenotypes work for recessive alleles.' Recessive alleles aren't immune to natural selection. It's just harder to purge them because they get exposed as phenotypes less often. As they become rarer and rarer (it'll manifest as a phenotype as the square of its frequency), selection weakens. Homosexuality, however, is common enough and the fitness penalty large enough that any recessives are exposed to a lot of selection, so it should be disappearing fast, but it isn't, which raises a lot of questions of what exactly causes homosexuality.
- noobermin 10y agoExactly at the heart of the problem. IANAB (I am a physicist though) and from what I understand, it is a question currently being researched. I mean, great example is if it is so easy, why is there homosexuality in the animal kingdom where they don't have social push for heterosexual mating?
- toasterlovin 10y agoI think homophobia is the reason why non-straight genes are present in the gene pool. It is a strategy for parents and siblings to make sure that their non-straight relatives reproduce despite their natural inclinations. Just a disclaimer though: this is not at all a justification for homophobia, in the same way that the (mostly) male impulse to violence is not a justification for said violence.
- toasterlovin 10y agoI was raised to always double down on an unpopular idea if I think there's something to it, so here goes: From the point of view of genetic fitness, homosexuality is not adaptive. So you would think that the genes that contribute to homosexuality would be powerfully selected against, since the number of expected offspring from same sex intercourse is zero. Yet gay people make up a sizable portion of the population, which is not at all what you would expect. Unless there is some mechanism by which homosexuals have historically had children despite their natural inclinations. Given that some portion of anti-gay attitudes seem to be oriented toward getting them to "be more straight" (or whatever), it seems possible to me that homophobia (or at least a certain flavor of it) is an adaptation whose purpose is to get family members to pressure a gay person into having offspring, since they would have a genetic interest in those offspring. But that is an argument about why a certain behavior might exist in humanity. It is not an argument that homophobia is okay or justified. It is not okay.