10 ms·
Why the Great Divide Is Growing Between Affordable and Expensive U.S. Cities
- peatmoss 10y ago> Mr. Romem said ideally cities would relax regulations and build upward rather than outward. But, he said, promoting development on empty fields is more politically feasible than building apartment towers in single-family neighborhoods, and thus likely to ease affordability pressures more quickly. That's the key line for me. As an urban planner, I'm bought in on the idea of growth management--at least much of it. But every policy has its unintended consequences. As far as planning is concerned, I think it's pretty incontrovertible that more upward development is needed. Getting there politically is an unsolved problem.
- danielvf 10y agoI was surprised to see the city afforabilty/size chart tracks political parties so closely. Almost all the high growth, affordable cities are Republican leaning, while the high growth expensive cities are predominately Democrat. I wonder how close the correlation actualy is.
- HarryHirsch 10y agoFlatland vs the Zoned Zone, at first glance: http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2007/10/20/the-two-americas http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2007/10/20/the-two-americas The real question is why do the cities on the coast prosper, even in a recession, and those in Flatland shrink? Why wasn't the tech labour market in NYC and SF in 2003 and 2007 half as affected as the labour market in Dallas or Austin, even though rents in SF are astronomical?
- dexwiz 10y agoFlatland housing isn't cheap because of the houses. Its cheap because of the land. Since the land is cheap, more factories are built there. The recession hit factories particularly hard, combined with continuous outsourcing efforts, hit Flatland harder than the coasts. The impact of closing a factory isn't limited to the local area. It has a regional impact on support businesses.
- RestlessMind 10y agoI too noticed that. Cities with least price increases: Austin, Raleigh, Atlanta, Vegas, Charlotte, Phoenix...all of them in states leaning Republican. Cities with most price increases: San Jose, Boston, NYC, LA, Seattle, San Diego, DC... all of them in states leaning Democratic. Could it be because of the parties' philosophies about regulations? Conservatives would let you build without much hassle, thus letting supply meet demand. Liberals, on the other hand, would regulate and constrain the supply. Apart from political ideologies, what could be other possible reasons for such disparity?
- ethanjdiamond 10y agoCoastal vs. Noncoastal
- santaclaus 10y agoRaleigh and Charlotte are in a coastal state...
- danielvf 10y agoYeah, but not coastal cities. (We probably also need to specifiy coastal cites with restricted building area as well, since Houston is a major port.)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- graeme 10y agoAren't all the cities in the latter group already dense than the former group? I didn't check all of them, but these are the least dense cities in the second group, in people per sq mile: 1. San Jose: 5000 2. San Diego: 4000 LA is 8000. NYC is 28000. For the former, "build without hassle" group, here are the highest densities 1. Atlanta: 3360 2. Austin: 3358 3. Raleigh: 3158 4. Phoenix: 3025 Las Vegas is 1659, Charlotte is 2720. ------------- I pulled the numbers from Wikipedia. Here's an alternate theory: the cities in the second list are pretty full. So costs go up, despite the fact that the cities are unusually dense. Further, it's impossible to build NYC in modern America. Zoning laws now require more sprawl. The cities in the first list are mostly building low density housing. (Hint: even tall buildings neighborhoods can be low density if built wrong.)
- Aelinsaar 10y agoThe coasts tend to be more Democrat, and the coasts tend to be MUCH more densely populated.
- charlescearl 10y agoWhile the States that those high growth cities are located in may be Red, the cities themselves are blue bastions. Remember for example that it was Charlotte's progressive LGBT policies that resulted in backlash from NC. Politically the cities are very close in sensibility.
- eloisant 10y agoUrban/densely populated = Democrat. Country side / low density = Republican. You'll find this correlation pretty much everywhere in the world: big cities are progressive and the country side is conservative.
- noahmbarr 10y ago"expansive cities versus expensive cities"
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dexwiz 10y agoThere is some sort of cultural attraction in play also. All of the cities in red would be considered some sort of high profile cultural hub. I live in a very cheap city that's very close to the price baseline on that graph. Land here is cheap. My girlfriend lives on close to 1/3 acre, in the city, for less than 200k. The city is seeing a large influx of on new businesses looking to relocate cost centers here, ie lots of call centers. So there are jobs, there are houses, there are all the amenities of a normal city. But there are next to no cultural outlets. Nightlife is confined to 3 or 4 strips in the entire city. Most festivals boil down to parents and kids buying food from trucks and tents. There are no major music festivals. Craft beer is pretty much limited to IPAs. Natural attractions are woods or lakes. Any sometimes during sporting events in our city, broadcasters show the visiting team's skyline, because ours is so lackluster. I am looking to move cities, but after factoring in an astronomical rise in housing cost, and a price of living adjustment that does come close to matching, I am having second thoughts. Why move to a city to do stuff, if once I get there I cannot afford to do anything. Side note, the article is not particularly informative. Its pretty basic info: look at these cities that cost a lot, and the reason is because new builds are limited. Seems like an excuse for someone to make the infographic.
- Joof 10y agoAustin has culture and affordability as a counterexample.
- Animats 10y agoIt's the WSJ. Of course regulation has to be the problem. But usually, it's geography. Manhattan and SF have water borders. There's sprawl outside them, but the good stuff is near the center. If you don't have geographic obstacles, cities can get insanely huge. Mexico City. Beijing. Shanghai. Tokyo. The US has the New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ-PA Metropolitan Statistical Area, with about 20 million people, the world's second largest city area. That's what happens when expansion jumps the geographic obstacles.
- vlozko 10y agoDid you not read the article? "Many of the more expensive cities are prevented from growing outward by natural barriers, such as oceans or mountains. Those cities are unlikely to grow significantly upward or outward in the next couple of decades, he said, and thus the price divide is likely to continue to widen."
- Animats 10y ago"On the one side are cities such as San Francisco, Boston, New York and Miami that have slowed their pace of expansion dramatically since the 1970s, in part as they have added layer upon layer of building regulations." That's pure WSJ editorializing.
- Retra 10y agoIs that claim untrue?
- swampthinker 10y agoI mean, do you have any idea what kind of regulations there are on building in Boston? Southie is booming right now, but it sure as hell isn't for cheap housing. The headaches of dealing with Boston zoning are now far outweighed by the benefits of building in the Seaport.
- Chinjut 10y agoI suppose it depends on how you define a "city area", but there are a great many with more than the NYC area's mere 20 million people. For example, Shanghai, Karachi, and Beijing each exceed that within city limits alone! (See also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_metropolitan_areas_by_population https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_metropolitan_areas_by_..., though some of the data on that page is out of date)
- davidf18 10y agoEconomics Nobelist Paul Krugmann, Harvard economist Edward Glaeser, and Financial Times Columnist (with masters in Economics) Tim Harford and others have been writing about this. It has to do with "rent-seeking" using politics to create artificial scarcity, in this case scarcity of housing though zoning density restrictions and overuse of historic landmark status. The rent-seeking creates microeconomic market inefficiencies. Ultimately, I believe there will have to be federal laws to break up the "rent-seeking" in cities. Another example of "rent-seeking" was the artificial limit of 13,000 taxi medallions. The market value of a single medallion rose to $1.2 million until Uber/Lyft came along and increased the supply of taxi-like vehicles. Now the market value is <$700K. See: Build Big Bill by Glaeser: http://www.nydailynews.com/opinion/build-big-bill-article-1.1913739 http://www.nydailynews.com/opinion/build-big-bill-article-1.... Tim Harford: The Undercover Economist https://www.amazon.com/dp/0199926514 https://www.amazon.com/dp/0199926514
- Girlang 10y agoIf these cities weren't "affordable", wouldn't there be a lot of empty houses because people couldn't afford them? Clearly they are affordable.
- jxramos 10y agoThis is exactly what Sowell spoke about several years ago, nice to see it with hard data though. Thomas Sowell: Oh, because Dallas wasn't part of the boom and it wasn't part of the bust. Peter Robinson: How come? Thomas Sowell: Because in Dallas they don't have the restrictions on building houses that we have in Coastal California. Houston was--is very similar. Houston doesn't even have zoning laws. And so therefore if people wanted more houses in Dallas or Houston, the villages built more houses and the prices didn't rise. Peter Robinson: Supply is able to adjust to demand. Thomas Sowell: That's it. Peter Robinson: Much more easily, much more easily in these markets. Thomas Sowell: Yes. http://media.hoover.org/sites/default/files/documents/uk-sowell-7-09.pdf http://media.hoover.org/sites/default/files/documents/uk-sow...
- bsder 10y agoI note that the areas that are marked "affordable" are some of the ones who had the worst housing crashes. IIRC, Las Vegas, Phoenix, Atlanta, and Raleigh all had housing markets that were hugely outpacing the local salaries until everything crashed.
- actaeon169 10y agoSo, a small supply combined with a large demand creates higher prices? This new finding could revolutionize our understand of economics... we should study this further.