3 ms·
While I agree with Smolin that much physics has moved away from experimental observation, especially string theory, I think the three numbered points in the art
by tim333 10y ago
While I agree with Smolin that much physics has moved away from experimental observation, especially string theory, I think the three numbered points in the article are wrong.
My take - the only way the universe could have got here from nothing as it were is if it's basically maths and seems real to us. I mean what does basic particle behavior look like - a bunch of maths and not much else, and what exist without needing creating - mathematical patterns and relations and nothing else. Hence from observation it's probably all maths.
Hence:
1) There is only one universe. - Nah probably all mathematically possible universes seem real to their occupants.
2) Time is real. - Sorta but more like how time exists in a DVD of a movie. Or as some guy wrote "...for us physicists believe the separation between past, present, and future is only an illusion, although a convincing one."
3) Mathematics is selectively real. - Nah it's real.