4 ms·
I don't understand. Why has educational attainment gone up and age at menarche gone down if there is selection pressure in the other direction?
by sp332 10y ago
I don't understand. Why has educational attainment gone up and age at menarche gone down if there is selection pressure in the other direction?
- danieltillett 10y agoBecause these have non-genetic factors working in the opposite direction.
- relyks 10y agoHow is educational attainment a genetic trait? Intelligence is partially hereditary, but isn't educational attainment a behavior?
- aab0 10y agoIntelligence is as much a behavior as education is. You observe it by what people do and how they perform. There is no physical or neurological correlate of intelligence like height or brain size or white matter integrity which measures intelligence as well as observing performance does. As for how education can be genetically mediated, there's many ways. Through intelligence (high genetic correlation/overlap), but also through personality traits, ADHD-proneness, and other mental and physical characteristics which are undoubtedly under genetic control.
- cSoze 10y agoStill doesn't make much sense to use a secondary trait like educational attainment (58% heritability at highest) over a primary one like IQ (>80% heritability). Most of these phenotypes strike me as pretty questionable. Maybe I missed something, but how well does BMI measured at age 45-50 correlate with BMI at reproductive age? Wouldn't a far simpler approach be to measure allelic frequency at regions near GWAS QTLs in multiple generations?
- aab0 10y ago> Still doesn't make much sense to use a secondary trait like educational attainment (58% heritability at highest) over a primary one like IQ (>80% heritability). Educational attainment is phenotyped much more often than is IQ, so it's both available in this dataset and available in the much larger datasets of the GWAS in question. Aside from being a phenotype of interest in its own right and a case of looking under the lamppost, EA also proxies for intelligence on both the genetic and phenotype level. (In some cohorts, like the UK Biobank, the cognitive performance test used has such low test-retest reliability that anyone who is looking for intelligence variants is going to want to use the education variable anyway!) > Maybe I missed something, but how well does BMI measured at age 45-50 correlate with BMI at reproductive age? I'm sure the correlation is <1. But as long as it's not an inverse correlation, it's fine. That is just measurement error which will bias down to 0 the estimate and lead to underestimate of selection. > Wouldn't a far simpler approach be to measure allelic frequency at regions near GWAS QTLs in multiple generations? How do you aggregate those QTLs? You can't examine them individually, that would be horrifically underpowered. If you wind up summing them, don't you get a polygenic score back and do what OP did?
- cSoze 10y agoConsidering that natural selection is generally considered to not operate on post-reproductive phenotype (prime case is antagonistic pleiotropy literature) I consider any conclusion based on these measures pretty suspect. Worse, specific heritability for these traits in this cohort, as far as I can tell, wasn't even estimated. Given that the supplemental says the mean in the literature is 40%, it could very well be sub 20%. I suspect that selecting only known high effect QTLs would actually not impact your power all that much as it limits the number of tests performed. If you can't see selection at high effect alleles I'm not sure you'll be able to detect them in aggregate either, especially with very noisy phenotype data. At the end of the day natural selection is a change in allele frequency driven by differences in phenotype. Sure, this maybe was an easy analysis to do given that the data was available, but I don't really see the value.
- aab0 10y ago
- pessimizer 10y agoPeople who are highly educated like to feel like they are members of a higher species.
- ggggtez 10y agoI'd argue that it's just as likely that our ability and desire to make teaching and learning more interesting (wider availability of college courses even without enrolling in a 4 year degree) could have had just as much impact on increasing the average EA.
- mirimir 10y agoThe author looks at the relationship between fitness, educational attainment, and age at menarche. He measures fitness by number of grandchildren. So what he reports is that people with higher educational attainment, and women with later menarche, had more grandchildren on average. That makes sense to me. It's pretty well established that educated people have fewer children. And early menarche might arguably be associated with long-term health problems.
- burfog 10y agoThe result of selection (lower education, etc.) will necessarily lag behind the selection pressure. Only the most extreme selection (immediate 100% death for non-selected variant) will show up immediately. Milder selection takes time. You can tell that it is happening if you look at millions of people, but it won't be easy to notice without some number crunching. Suppose the difference is that one group averages 1.7 kids per woman, with typical generation-to-generation time of 35 years, while the other group has 2.1 kids per woman, with typical generation-to-generation time of 20 years. You probably can't notice, especially if those averages are blurred by lots of random variation. It will take many generations to severely reduce the genetic predisposition toward learning. As it happens, it will be difficult to recognize. People learn less, but why? Many alternate explanations will be offered. There may in fact be multiple factors that each partially explain the result. Some of these factors may be taboo. We might explain away the situation by saying that the economy just doesn't support education, or that the culture has changed.