8 ms·
Which is exactly why people still work on things like Bohmian Mechanics/Pilot Wave theory[0, 1]. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_Broglie%E2%80%93Bohm_theor
by dogma1138 10y ago
Which is exactly why people still work on things like Bohmian Mechanics/Pilot Wave theory[0, 1].
[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_Broglie%E2%80%93Bohm_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_Broglie%E2%80%93Bohm_theory
[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pilot_wave https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pilot_wave
There's a lot of really strange stuff going on with QM and ST, even tho Brian Greene works primarily on ST he did somewhat coined the concept of the "giant leap" that to some extent theoretical physics has run off way too far from anything that can be proven using experimentation.
>Physics has been stuck on this problem for almost a century now. Philosophy won't help.
Philosophy does help, infact it might be the only thing that would help in it's essence philosophy is about how you approach and solve problems, and more importantly how you think about them.
It might need be that we do need a major philosophical change in the world of theoretical physics and start thinking about QM and the universe in general in completely different matter.
There is a lot of natural bias that pushes your thinking into a very predictable path and this plagues theoretical physics just like any other field if not more.
The bleeding edge of theoretical physics, especially in the past 60-70 years has really shifted towards almost the metaphysical regardless of how much elegant math there is behind it.
- forgotpwtomain 10y ago> Philosophy does help, infact it might be the only thing that would help in it's essence philosophy is about how you approach and solve problems, and more importantly how you think about them. I'm genuinely curious to know how you think any post Frege philosophy helps. At best philosophy can help prevent research/effort being expended in plausible non-sense; but certainly not in the sense of providing a positive result or foundation for one (which is to my understanding what those doing ST are ultimately seeking). I'll also take the time here to gripe about post-wittgenstein philosophy which went willy-nilly with formal constructions and basically managed to ignore PI entirely (or otherwise remain mum about it) as well as the his remarks on the foundations of mathematics which set up a lot of problematic for the later.
- themgt 10y agoIf you really dig into what they're talking about, it presents potential avenues for "solutions" to issues from why physical laws are what they are to how consciousness and free will would be possible. It's a lot more than just angels-on-head-of-pin stuff, and goes far beyond Smolin's previous critiques of string theory.
- forgotpwtomain 10y agoIf a philosophy is making positive statements it's an obvious sham - the best you can do with a meta logic is define the limits of what can be expressed within a logic (postive and negative as related to this world) it cannot have anything to do with producing results.
- blueprint 10y agoPhilosophy is not correctly defined as the generation of logic. If the philosophy you learned is defined in connection with logic then it can be term deteriorated philosophy. The proof is that if we had learned philosophy correctly we also form our own eye of wisdom to see what is in the truth but no one can verify what is true through logic alone as you cannot verify your axioms without external referents. The reason is that truths can only be verified through problems. This all means we can't see the world through thinking, but through the problems.
- toufka 10y agoBut it can. Philosophy can clear the brush between two competing paths. If we take path A, that leads to X, Y, Z, whereas if we take path B, that leads to J, K, L. Philosophy has done nothing to say whether reality is more A-like, or more B-like, but in delineating and making clear the consequences of an A-like world vs a B-like world, it has done a significant service in producing physical results. When experimentalists show an inkling of a tiny sliver of 'K', we know can collapse with logical certainty around the B-like world. Trudging down those paths prior to experimental evidence is of very real value and is not disconnected from the physics itself.
- 10y ago
- blueprint 10y agoI'm curious to know your opinion. Suppose an individual appeared who said they knew the reality of gravity and how to design an apparatus to verify it. How would s/he be treated?
- labster 10y agoOutlandish but testable claims are treated well by the Physics community. Take the recent example of the EmDrive[1], which has gotten a few replication studies. Nothing conclusive yet, but it hasn't been dismissed out of hand by everyone. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EmDrive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EmDrive
- blueprint 10y agoYou say they're treated well, but the EmDrive was specifically sponsored by NASA, which means you're not answering the same question as what I asked, but changing it by presupposing that I asked how such a person would be treated if they were already institutionally sponsored.
- labster 10y agoFirst, I can't possibly answer the question you asked, because you asked for the opinion of someone else. Second, if you had read into the second paragraph of the link, you would see that the EmDrive is not institutionally sponsored nor developed by NASA. Third, offering analogous evidence is not the same thing as changing the question.
- blueprint 10y agoActually, it was institutionally sponsored, because the very work to peer review it was done by labs directly sponsored by NASA. If the initial work were not peer reviewed, you would not be holding it up as an example of something successful. Therefore, it's NASA's sponsorship of the peer review which is a necessary and direct cause of you calling it successful here. So my initial assessment of what you said stands. You're saying the physics community is receptive because NASA sponsored an attempts to verify it. That proves nothing about the receptivity of the physics community nor of even NASA. But I don't expect this to be something you can easily agree with. After all, you're proving my point.
- eli_gottlieb 10y ago>The bleeding edge of theoretical physics, especially in the past 60-70 years has really shifted towards almost the metaphysical regardless of how much elegant math there is behind it. Which is a major problem, given the truism that theory is under-determined by experimental evidence! If given any simple theory of physics I can construct a more complicated theory that makes the same predictions, then we desperately need to confine ourselves to theories that do make unique predictions, lest we be generating ever-more-complicated versions of theories we already had.
- jjoonathan 10y agoThat's like saying "we need to confine ourselves to business plans that make money." Everyone understands and agrees on the importance of this as an ultimate goal but nobody knows the path to get there -- the hard work is in trying and rejecting promising paths until you find one that works.
- mirimir 10y agoRight. So there's room for developing hypotheses that we don't yet know how to test. Because some branch might be testable, or some new technology might become available. Just as with business plans and profit. But at some point, someone should maybe call bullshit. Kuhn etc have explored criteria. One of them, as I recall, is asymptotically increasing complexity.
- naasking 10y agoThe focus hasn't been on developing more complicated theories, but instead on developing less complicated theories. This provides additional explanatory power, and provides a mental model in which we can ponder thought experiments that may yield further insights. For instance, many-worlds is actually conceptually and formally simpler than Copenhagen.
- neltnerb 10y agoWhat is this idea that making the math prettier or more elegant is not important? That's like saying a new algorithm isn't important; new math or models make problems potentially tractable that aren't now. All of our math is an attempt to represent things or ideas. The most important thing I learned in my physics education was how to read math as a metaphor for putting together things I understand into a picture of a thing I don't understand. But I don't think anyone serious thinks that their math is "true", such an assertion just makes no sense. The point of it is to find new ways to approach the evidence to see if it gives some different metaphor that wasn't obvious before. I don't know enough modern physics to have an opinion on whether this is the case for cosmology or string theory, but I do know that in recent history just formulating a problem slightly differently can suddenly make the solution fit in the same framework as a known simpler problem. Not unlike things I read all the time about algorithm research at all, right? Teaching and understanding models is predicated highly on metaphor, it's much easier to explain for instance that MRI works via a quantum effect that has the same math as a harmonic oscillator than it is to just... dive in. The model isn't the universe, but humans live by metaphor and so the model is important. Which is perhaps not the point you were trying to make; I don't know enough modern physics to know whether a critique of these new areas as purely fantastical is justified, but it's also pretty fantastical to think of a particle in a box as if it were like a weight on a spring. Who am I to say that something about this approach can't make a currently intractable, approximate, or computational impossible problem solvable with time?
- kensai 10y agoVery insightful comment, thanks for sharing!
- hyperbovine 10y agoThere are people whose job it is to make pretty math, they are called "mathematicians" ;-) So much of early physics, be it thermodynamics, electromagnetics, classical mechanics, is genuinely beautiful and elegant. I can see why quantum physicists would strive for that ideal as well. But at the end of the day I agree that physics should favor creating testable predictive models over developing untestable, elegant ones.
- EGreg 10y agoI personally think pilot-wave theory is about to make a serious comeback in this coming decade. It certainly explains the exact same phenomena but it doesn't resort to any spooky stuff except action-at-a-distance. I'd rather embrace nonlocality than the crazy many-worlds stuff. We are just used to locality, why does it have to be an axiom? Seems like it could just as well be a result of the law of large numbers, same as any other macro effects in QM. That is, there is just a very high correlation that results in locality. Same as not being able to pass through a wall, or schrodinger's cat not appearing in the macro world.
- LoSboccacc 10y agoYeah that and pilot wave has some elegancy to it that finds simmetry at so many other scales. So in other words as long as them will all be interchangeable and unverified, I'll fanboi for pilot wave.
- dghf 10y ago> I'd rather embrace nonlocality than the crazy many-worlds stuff. Why do you describe many-worlds as 'crazy'? Edit: to whoever down-voted me, this was a serious question.
- Natanael_L 10y agoWhat does it mean if particular probability for x vs y is an irrational number? Can you really have a number of universe forks counted in something that isn't integers? If you don't really have independent universe forks but something physically continous, what mechanism makes us seem to only observe a single independent branch at all times? Given the assumption of quantum foam (from the uncertainty principle) at the Planck length + relativity (the Planck length isn't constant like the speed of light, every observer measures it differently relative to others), how many universe branches are really created every picosecond in every Planck length (volume) across the visible universe?
- dghf 10y agoIANA physicist, but my layman's understanding was that under many-worlds the universe doesn't actually fork. Rather, the superposition of states observed in things like the double-slit experiment applies to all particles all the time, including the ones in our brains. When we observe a system undergo an apparent collapse of the wave-function, what's actually happening is that we/our brains have become entangled with that system, so each of our brains' states becomes correlated to one of the system's states. To a consciousness generated by one of those brain states, it appears that the system under observation has undergone a collapse; however, the result of that collapse appears different to each such brain state. At least, that's what I took away from this: http://www.askamathematician.com/2010/10/q-copenhagen-or-many-worlds/ http://www.askamathematician.com/2010/10/q-copenhagen-or-man... and this: http://www.askamathematician.com/2011/11/q-according-to-the-many-worlds-interpretation-every-event-creates-new-universes-where-does-the-energy-and-matter-for-the-new-universes-come-from/ http://www.askamathematician.com/2011/11/q-according-to-the-...
- akuma73 10y agoBohmian mechanics is fundamentally incompatible with quantum field theory. QFT is the best theory we have today (standard model).
- jostylr 10y agoWhy do you say that? There are adaptations that have creation and annihilation of particles in Bohmian mechanics: http://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/0303156 http://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/0303156 The main issue is that QFT does not generate a mathematically well-defined evolution of the wave function, but there are promising directions on that front as well: http://arxiv.org/abs/1506.00497 http://arxiv.org/abs/1506.00497 Basically, they treat the Hamiltonian as a whole instead of a perturbation and use a domain for it that has the probabilities flowing from one area to another appropriately to the different particle sectors. There is also work on dealing with relativity which is a separate issue. While there are solutions, mainly centering on finding a natural foliation, the tension with relativity has not really been resolved, a tension which exists regardless of interpretation.
- naasking 10y ago> While there are solutions, mainly centering on finding a natural foliation, the tension with relativity has not really been resolved, a tension which exists regardless of interpretation. Exactly, John Bell had it right 50 years ago: non-locality is the problem of QM that needs to be solved, and other interpretations let you simply gloss over the problem without really addressing it. The recent work for finding a natural foliation present in any formalism with a wave function, including Bohmian mechanics, proves every QM shares this problem (or if you think one doesn't, then none of them do for the exact same reasons).