5 ms·
That we aren't capable of experiments that distinguish between various forms of string theories doesn't negate the fact that string theories are already compati
by empath75 10y ago
That we aren't capable of experiments that distinguish between various forms of string theories doesn't negate the fact that string theories are already compatible with all the experiments we've already done and are likely to be done in the near future. This is no small achievement. There is no other framework that is even in contention right now.
Perhaps when we have some alternative theory that survives that basic hurdle, we can discuss whether we're wasting time pursuing string theory rather than some other idea.
- Xcelerate 10y ago> string theories are already compatible with all the experiments we've already done and are likely to be done in the near future Yeah, not enough people are aware of this in my opinion.
- vacri 10y ago> string theories are already compatible with all the experiments we've already done and are likely to be done in the near future So is the theory "A god did it".
- jcranmer 10y agoSupersymmetry is one (although it's not really a competitor to string theory, more an orthogonal theory). One of the complaints on string theory, as I understand it, is that it ends up being too general: it sort of implies that just about any phenomenon could be plausible, which makes it really hard to falsify. It's not so much that it's made predictions that turned out to be true, but rather that it can be accommodated to fit prior experiments. From a Bayesian perspective, we haven't received any evidence of its truth, only evidence of nontruth of other theories.
- auntienomen 10y agoThis is a complaint rooted in sociology. People thought back in the 80s & 90s that string theory might be so constrained that can only describe one universe (presumably ours). They were wrong. String theory's more constrained than quantum field theory, but it's still capable of describing a lot of different universes. Most of the people who study it at the moment study it because it's been a fruitful source of ideas about quantum field theory. These people don't give press interviews very often, though.
- empath75 10y agoIt's not that general-- Gravity falls out of string theory very naturally, which is why people keep coming back to it.
- nilkn 10y agoI'm not a theoretical physicist, but my understanding is that supersymmetry is in fact a prediction of many versions of string theory. So it's definitely not orthogonal at all. It's a fundamental part of superstring theory.
- iaw 10y agoIn my field we call this "overfitting." String theory and multiverse work are adherent to all experimental evidence by design and offer no predictive capabilities (correct me if I'm wrong, please). You can design arbitrary systems to fit observations without identifying the underlying mechanisms, especially if said arbitrary systems are complex (which symmetry arguments are). If these models are only predictive after the fact, then what good are they? The vindication for Einstein is that his various predictions are still being proven out a century later. Hawking found evidence that ran contrary to our theoretical understanding and has spent his life trying to explain the divergence. String theories aren't in contention outside of the fringes, they're interesting mathematical models but they are on a par with our study of the ether in the late 19th century, something that will be looked back upon as a diversion away from the truth of our universe.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- akvadrako 10y agoThis may be true of string theory but not unitary quantum mechanics, which predicts a multiverse. It makes quite specific predictions which are tightly constrained by experiments, for example the Born rule.
- iaw 10y agoI think you're making a leap when you say it "predicts a multiverse." (please correct me if you have field expertise) To refresh my memory I ran through this paper [1] briefly. My understanding is that multiverse arguments based on the Born rule are circular. One possible interpretation of the Born rule is the existence of a multiverse but it is not the only interpretation and it requires one to make some pretty big assumptions that the existing Quantum mechanics models being perfect representations of reality (which we know it is not). [1] http://www.math.ru.nl/~landsman/Born.pdf http://www.math.ru.nl/~landsman/Born.pdf
- akvadrako 10y ago