3 ms·
If you've got an iPhone? Probably a fair amount. But consider that the battery argument holds for every battery-powered device. Laptops, the iPad / iPhone, a
by Groxx 17y ago
If you've got an iPhone? Probably a fair amount.
But consider that the battery argument holds for every battery-powered device. Laptops, the iPad / iPhone, and even (to get nitpicky) your electrical bill. It likely also will extend to future gaming handhelds, likely to have a hardware decoder (and why not use h.264? high quality and small size) and run on batteries. The market that is effected is (if not now, likely to be soon) in the hundreds of millions of people, with many many hours each.
I'll be incredibly conservative, and say "a billion hours". Might that be worth reducing power use?
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoH.264 is not more power efficient than Theora. It compresses better so that it's got higher quality per bit, but it achieves that by using more computing power on both the encode and decode end. Consider gzip vs bzip for a very rough analogy, more "cleverness" means smaller files but also more computation time. Or think of the CABAC feature that makes your H.264 file 10% smaller but unable to play on iPhones or other low power devices (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CABAC http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CABAC). H.264 does have "hardware" assisted decode on iPhones but that's a choice made by Apple not a universal law. Despite the constant repetition of the "fact" that H.264 decode is done in custom silicon, it's simply not true. The same DSP or generic video decode units are used for other codecs (inc VC-1, MPEG-2, MPEG-4 part 2, RealVideo). There's no reason Theora can't be accelerated in the same way and it already has been for the OMAP3 chips (as used in N900s, Palm Pre and the Droid). Here's a link to a company selling software that decodes High Profile H.264 (amongst many other codecs) on OMAP3 SoCs. How would that be remotely possible if H.264 implementations were entirely custom silicon, unchangeable and non-upgradeable?: http://www.ittiam.com/pages/news/pres-rel-20100215-omap3-720p.htm http://www.ittiam.com/pages/news/pres-rel-20100215-omap3-720...
- KirinDave 17y agoWho said that H.264 encoding is entirely custom silicon? And why can't there be custom silicon if other less "hardware" (why do you keep putting it in quotes?) acceleration strategies exist? You've been pushing this hardware angle hard, and the point is well taken. Yes, you can accelerate Theora if you write some new software. Not every mobile producer has the luxury of letting a third party do that (or putting the resources to do it themselves). But yes, it is possible. So now all we're left with is that Theora is an inferior codec: worse quality, worse encoding options, more investment required to make it power efficient on mobile. The industry has decided—with or without Mozilla—long before this question was ever asked. When Youtube started converting everything to H.264, the biggest player moved over. Now you see other smaller players moving to H.264 as well. All MozillaCo's refusal is doing is ensuring that Flash continues to exist as a video solution for Firefox, playing H.264 and not giving HTML5 video support. The decision has already been made by the big sites!
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoFirst post in this thread: "Dedicated mobile hardware is a necessity". The post I replied to, by a different poster, had taken this one step further and decided that Theora's lack of "a hardware decoder" was going to melt the ice caps. Who knows exactly what these people meant by "hardware" or "dedicated mobile hardware" but the generally accepted meaning isn't something that can be created by writing software. Writing software for already deployed hardware is considered one of the strengths of Free and Open Source software developers. Creating fabs to build silicon chips with 3 year lead times and magically placing them in devices that have already been sold isn't, and I have repeatedly seen this factoid cited as the reason why Theora is hopeless, regardless of all other considerations. Here's a quote from the latest Daring Fireball piece: "There are no hardware decoding chips for Ogg Theora. If you want to send video to mobile devices, H.264 is the only practical encoding for the near future." If this point is now made and widely accepted and the discussion has moved on to "Theora is an inferior codec: worse quality, worse encoding options etc." then that's great. Inferior is pejorative, and I find "worse quality" to be highly misleading, as if every Theora video will look like something on Youtube, but I'd happily admit to "lower quality per bit" (in fact I do in the post you replied to) which is okay because it has other advantages and room to grow.
- Groxx 17y agogoing to melt the ice caps. An exaggeration built on an exaggeration is doomed to fall over. I implied nothing of the sort, and my main goal was just to point out that a hardware decoder is a big deal in terms of battery life, though I admit it didn't come through clearly. Though I will claim that hardware decoding is typically more power efficient than software, and has much more room to improve. I'm glad to see Theora getting hardware acceleration, especially as I hadn't heard about it, though I'd be curious to see if it'll work on more computers / devices than h.264 is likely to appear on. As to MPEG-2 and other formats where there are more prevalent hardware decoders, do some comparative runs. h.264 does significantly better per bit from my subjective experiments. It's more future-capable because of that and it's ability to do ridiculously high quality encoding, which combined with a business to hold accountable for problems will likely mean other businesses will choose it over Theora.
- jrockway 17y agoWhy not just move back into caves? That would save even more energy.