3 ms·
More generally, poor people “could easily save more without getting less nutrition by spending less on alcohol, tobacco, and food items such as sugar, spice, an
by Mz 17y ago
More generally, poor people “could easily save more without getting less nutrition by spending less on alcohol, tobacco, and food items such as sugar, spice, and tea,” Banerjee and Duflo conclude. For example, the typical poor household in Udaipur could spend up to 30 percent more on food if it did not spend money on alcohol, tobacco, and festivals.
Consuming alcohol and tobacco not only takes money away from a family’s nutrition, but also sets off a cascade of other problems that poor people more frequently encounter. Alcohol abuse, for instance, reduces work performance while increasing accidents, domestic violence, and illness. Because many indigent people earn their livelihoods through physical labor, falling ill means not earning money.
A small problem with their theory: Every last item they list has medicinal purposes. It's possible (and in my opinion very likely) that alcohol, tobacco, spices and tea are being used by "the poor" to self-medicate. For example, alcohol kills germs and poor people often live in filth. How do we know that their situation wouldn't be worse without it? If you want them to stop drinking, you would need to resolve the underlying reasons motivating them to drink -- which may well be rooted in "poverty" but it isn't necessarily rooted in lack of money per se.
Financial problems grow out of real problems. Resolve the underlying real problems and the financial problems tend to clear up on their own, or at least improve. Articles like this focus too much on money per se and too little on the real problems -- the problems which would still be harming these people and lowering their quality of life even if we lived in a Star Trek universe where money no longer existed.
- roundsquare 17y agoIts true that we should look into the root causes of each of these so called "sins" but I don't think what you are saying is particularly likely. I'll search around for studies, but I would bet its far more likely that these goods are being consumed to take the edge off life (as this article suggests). Indeed, a recent field study in Sri Lanka reveals that more than 10 percent of poor male respondents regularly spend their entire incomes on alcohol. Certainly the medicinal argument can't be made here. Even though alcohol kills germs, consuming it in large amounts produce a net harm on your health. If 10% of males are spending their entire income on alcohol, then its likely that a large portion of them are spending a large portion of their income on alcohol, so much that they are doing more harm to their bodies than good. In addition, the fact that they spend money on festivals argues that they are doing things to take the edge off life and not doing this for medicinal purposes. In part, I imagine this article is a reaction to a lot of people discussing how innovative the poor are and saying "if we could just give them a chance, they'll pull themselves out of poverty." This, really, is the basis of the microfinance industry. To some degree, its true. Poor villagers in India often are often engaged in a large number of (informal) financial transaction at any time. They have various loans with various money lenders, things they borrowed from neighbors, self help groups, etc... all of which they keep track of without a pen and paper (much less a computer). In addition, there are many instances of well-intentioned people getting things wrong. (One example is that many MFIs required that their loans be used on profit-making activities, and not refinancing loans to money lenders. This is foolish because the loans to money lenders are often at a higher rate and just refinancing that loan would help them immensely as well as almost guaranteeing the repayment of the micro loan). However, its not clear to me that this translates to the ability to quickly jump into the formal economy without protection. This projection is necessary and thats what the article is arguing for. In the end though, I do agree with something you are saying. Its critical that the entire problem be approached, not just the lack of money. This approach is hard to sell because it is slower and doesn't produce a magic bullet/catch phrase to sell, but its probably the only way to make a proper dent in the problem. This is why government intervention is critical. Even if this is a profitable exercise, it would be a very long term investment with uncertain returns, something that a profit driven enterprise is unlikely to take on and something that NGOs aren't big or coordinated enough to solve[1]. [1] Since this website attracts a lot of entrepreneurs, I suggest that there is a startup idea hidden here. I don't know how this would work, but if anyone has ideas, I say we discuss them.
- Mz 17y agoMy viewpoint is undoubtedly not "defensible" in terms of citing studies and such. It is rooted in my first-hand experience with getting myself well when doctors claim it cannot be done. Given my overwhelming success in that regard, I am confident that my view is closer to the truth about health than the conventional view. But given that this discussion is essentially "dead" on HN, I see no reason to belabor the point. Peace.