3 ms·
> it's reasonable to assume that there are quantum machines in the works or already operating (to some extent) behind closed doors inside institutions that bene
by johncolanduoni 10y ago
> it's reasonable to assume that there are quantum machines in the works or already operating (to some extent) behind closed doors inside institutions that benefit from having everyone believe such a capability doesn't exist yet.
I would be very surprised. Somehow, the more clandestine parts of governments would have had to siphon off a whole ton of people working in quantum information (physicists, engineers, mathematicians), which is a relatively new and close-knit field, without anybody noticing. Or, people who work in collaboration with parts of the government (NIST and UMD's JQI) are all making up work that looks like they haven't cracked it yet, when they really did last year.
If all the NSA needed were mathematicians and electrical engineers that specialized in classical computing, then I could believe they had something going on. As it stands, most people in QI seem to land in industry, academia, or perhaps some national laboratories, not report to Fort Meade or fall of the face of the Earth.
This would be like doing the Manhattan project, but with the extra complication finding convincing body doubles for Feynman, Oppenheimer, etc.
- roblabla 10y agoThere's a good point in GP's post though. The thing is, one day quantum computers WILL BE available to the NSA or whatever. And they also have the means to record all encrypted transmissions (and they probably do). So one day, the NSA will be able to crack those transmissions that are using pre-quantum algorithms. Using post-quantum algorithms ASAP would at least make sure that from this point on, we're "safe" from quantum computers making a sudden appearance tomorrow.
- johncolanduoni 10y agoI don't contest that at all, I'm very much in the "let's have post-quantum redundancies here yesterday" camp. I just found it hard to believe (though I was quite entertained by the conjecture) that the people I know in QI are either NSA impostors or stupid enough to fall for NSA impostors of their colleagues.