4 ms·
What's ironic about this metaphor is that Agile's roots can be found in building construction. We all know the story of Toyota, but where did Toyota come up wit
by pcmaffey 10y ago
What's ironic about this metaphor is that Agile's roots can be found in building construction. We all know the story of Toyota, but where did Toyota come up with the idea? From Japanese stone masons.
The nature of building with stone is such that you never truly know what resources you have to work with. The shape, color, texture of stone is all variable. This means too that the way each component fits together is unpredictable.
For the eye of a master builder, who constructs edifices with each relationship perfectly balanced, each component placed intentionally, who can see every step of the process and what each choice means for the integrity of the whole, such a craftsman understands that every day brings with it a whole new set of variable inputs, which can never be planned for, spec'ed out, or tasked to laborers who do not see the whole.
Modern construction cares nothing for such craft. It will be the domain of robots. Software development too will follow this path, as we humans are suckers for predictability. But such a road will be littered with people suffering in jobs that make them feel like robots, projects that fall flat, and endless repeating boxes of sameness.
- dschiptsov 10y agoConstruction, it seems, is a "waterfall" by definition, and, it is, probably, from architecture the model took its roots. Agile came from business and finance, where everything is uncertain and even not well understood.
- ethbro 10y agoAs someone who studied the field, construction in abstract seems a waterfall model. Construction in practice requires something very similar to agile: too many uncontrolled real world variables, interdependent timelines, and sheer laws of physics. If everything goes right, yes waterfall. Everything never goes right.
- mixmastamyk 10y agoIn rare circumstances everything must go right beforehand, e.g. the New Horizons probe to Pluto.
- spenczar5 10y agoThis is really intriguing. Do you have a book or other source you can recommend where I can learn more?
- mc32 10y agoI thought Toyota got some of their ideas of continuous improvement from Deming, who failed to find a receptive audience who'd implement hid ideas in the US.