5 ms·
Denmark’s Tougher Citizenship Test Stumps Even Its Natives
- jacquesm 10y agoWell, then the natives should lose their citizenship. We have the same bs here in nl, and I'm 100% certain that I would not pass, if only because I don't know enough about our 'Royal' family.
- internaut 10y agoIt is better understood as a ritual, specifically a hazing by way of bureaucracy.
- dalke 10y agoI understand it better as a way to appease nativists.
- internaut 10y agoAnd I that the conflict with nationalism and globalism is a red herring. The Net has enabled bi-directional communication for many to many for the first time in history. These feedback loops will produce effects familiar and unfamiliar. Of course we pick up first what we see, our bias is toward what we already understand. In truth it is weirder than than we may think and old-new forms of conflict are likely to emerge. For example; ISIS is based on an older interpretation of Islam, but could it exist without the Net? I'd say not. The implication of that could be that old conflicts thought to be irrelevant will rear their heads once more. You see something beginning here with feminism being abandoned, that was not in the script of the progressives. On the other side you have 'international meetings of anti-internationalists' and other such interesting paradoxes. There is something fractal-like going on with the evolution of ideas because of the Net.
- dalke 10y agoI didn't say nationalism, I said "nativism". Nor did I say "globalism". Because yes, that would certainly be a red herring. We've been a global economy since at least the 1830s, when the cotton mills of an English county was able to produce most of the world's cotton fabric, and collapse the economy of several Asian cities. Since no one mentioned them here, I find it odd that you felt necessary to raise that point. Every single communications form has enabled similar feedback loops for centuries; the printing press, cheaper paper to enable the penny-dreadfuls, Linotype to enable yellow journalism, radio, telegram, TV, telephone, record players, transoceanic cables, microwave and satellite repeaters, and now, yes, internet. You wrote "could [ISIS] exist without the Net? I'd say not." I see no meaning in that statement. If you define ISIS to include how it transmits messages over the internet, then you are surely right, but trivially so. Just like a 10 year old child in the US could not exist as-is without the internet. Regional uprisings, including those which are part of a religious movement, are not new, and don't require the internet to happen. The 1979 Iranian Revolution is one relatively recent example. The rest of what you wrote is a mixture of the obvious and the unsupported. Of course "old conflicts thought to be irrelevant will rear their heads once more"; history is full of examples where the powerful forget or trivialize a problem which was never fully forgotten among the oppressed, who eventually fight. As a feminist, I am flummoxed by the statement "with feminism being abandoned". It seems to be ever more mainstream, with, e.g., recent declarations by Barack Obama and Patrick Stewart of being feminists. The early feminist fought for the right to vote. Are you seriously saying that there's a general retreat from woman suffrage? If not, which of the many aspects of feminism do you refer? The seeming paradox of organized anarchism is one that has long been pointed out and discussed by anarchists. https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/common-cause-ottawa-organized-anarchism-in-the-anti-capitalist-struggle https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/common-cause-ottawa-... says: > The debate between organizationalists and anti organizationalists is not at all new. It has been ongoing in the anarchist community for at least a century. Finally there has always been "something fractal-like going on with the evolution of ideas", including, yet, long before the internet. There's a reason for the joke about the "People's Front of Judea" vs. "Judean People's Front", mocking perhaps Marxism factions, but otherwise little different than the joke with the punchline: > [Are you] Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region Council of 1879, or Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region Council of 1912?" He said, "Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region Council of 1912." I said, "Die, heretic!" And I pushed him over. Even the Germanic peoples, without a written language, still had "fractal-like" evolution of ideas, as seen in their laws, language, and religion/mythology. What you describe is a part of how human ideas develop, and not something special about the internet.