5 ms·
Far more annoying and productivity-impeding for the users to have to put up with it.
by Analemma_ 10y ago
Far more annoying and productivity-impeding for the users to have to put up with it.
- acdha 10y agoIs that really a given? Most users put up with incredibly locked-down corporate IT systems – would requiring those IT departments to publish whitelists really change that experience much?
- epistasis 10y agoBy "white-list" I mean to include code-signing, which has been shown not to impede much of anything, honestly. OS X's half-white-list mode of refusing to run unsigned code unless you invoke it from the right-click menu seems to be incredibly effective. Between code-signing and sand-boxing, I see virus scanners as failed legacies of the past. They have stopped little, and cost everyone greatly.
- iancarroll 10y agoUnfortunately there are literally websites that will sign any file you upload using certificates they stole. It's not a great approach.
- epistasis 10y agoAnd presumably those certificates are revoked, or will be revoked soon. Nothing is 100% accurate in security. But code-signing is still far more protective than virus scanners. Given evading a virus scanner and evading code-signing, one of these is far easier than the other.
- iancarroll 10y ago> And presumably those certificates are revoked, or will be revoked soon. The way code signing works means this doesn't matter. So long as the certificate wasn't revoked when the file was signed, the signature will be indefinitely valid. Ignoring the fact good AVs are difficult to evade because of things like behavior blocking and heuristics, you also won't be able to protect yourself against adware, because they are borderline legal and are almost always signed.
- epistasis 10y agoOf course code signing could allow revocation, not sure what you mean by it not being done currently. Antivirus doesn't stop adware either, does it? If you're going to start disallowing certain software it's going to be far easier to do it based on certificates than it will be on heuristics.
- iancarroll 10y agoDoing revocation checks on every executable whenever it's launched would introduce non-trivial latency with starting applications and a _lot_ of load on revocation servers. It probably wouldn't be feasible. And yes, AVs stop adware ("potentially unwanted programs") unless you tell them not to.
- epistasis 10y agoNot sure why you'd check revocation servers on every launch... Check when launched the first time, and then the system checks for new revocations periodically; let's say as frequently as AV software checks for definition updates. As for adware, if AV can stop it, code-signing methods can do it more efficiently and cheaper.
- dredmorbius 10y agoCryptographic solutions aren't Majickal Pixyie Duste. They can however, within a social and adminstrative context, help tremendously in assuring proper results. An independent authority (or authorities) of trusted (and untrusted) signing certificates. In a word: reputation.
- datguacdoh 10y agohttps://github.com/google/santa https://github.com/google/santa seems like it takes this approach. Gives an enterprise the ability to decide which signed certs it wants to trust and then block everything else unless it gets vetted.
- rasz_pl 10y agoeverything is annoying and productivity-impeding compared to tiger-repellent rock
- ploxiln 10y agoMany already do - it's called iOS. When the iPad first came out, a few executives publicly said "this is so awesome, I can do all my work on my iPad!" Sounds good to me, leave the power tools to the grown-ups who can resist punching the monkey, and can install security updates every couple of days (without being forced to reboot at the whim of the OS).
- loup-vaillant 10y agoThe price for stuff like iOS is to high. I want to own my computer.
- zepto 10y agoIt's too high but only for a tiny minority of people.
- loup-vaillant 10y agoThe known price is okay for nearly everyone. The actual price is nearly always much higher than that. Over centralization and breaches of privacy have insidious downsides that are hard to assess. Plus, they create systemic risks we fail to take into account because Tragedy of the Commons.
- zepto 10y agoSeriously that's exactly equal to FUD. In any case I am not saying that everyone should use iOS.
- loup-vaillant 10y agoFUD, you say? Well, you should be afraid. You should be afraid of having the social graph of half of the Western world on Facebook. You should be afraid of storing most people's email unencrypted, in only a handful of data-centres. Then there is the progressive lockdown of the whole internet, where it becomes increasingly difficult to speak your mind, simply because it's harder and harder to get your own blog. I mean your blog, on your domain, hosted by yourself (or at the very least a virtual hosting provider). These days, it's Facebook, Medium… places where an overseer has the right to block whatever you write. A good thing in most cases, but at least we should be able to speak elsewhere.