3 ms·
No offense to Iceland, but the world economy is far less affected by the loss of Icleandic financial institutions than American ones.
by krapp 10y ago
No offense to Iceland, but the world economy is far less affected by the loss of Icleandic financial institutions than American ones.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoBut you're moving the goalposts on this discussion. The question wasn't the impact on the global economy; it was the impact on the national one. So the Iceland example is directly relevant.
- krapp 10y agoPart of this discussion seems to be whether or not the Treasury should have done what Iceland did, and I'm just trying to point out that they had valid reasons to do anything but that.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoClarification: Do you mean the US Treasury? If so, yes, I agree with you. And yes, that has been part of the discussion.
- krapp 10y agoSorry, yes I meant the US Treasury.
- rhino369 10y agoThe reason is that the global financial institutions are arguably more important than national ones. If Icelandic banking institutions fail, their economy can still be serviced by global banking institutions. Technically that is true for America too. American economy could be serviced by foreign banks. However, the American banking industry is big enough to knock out the entire global financial system. Iceland's isn't. Just one bank, Lehman Brother, almost caused the whole house of cards to come down.
- SilasX 10y agoWell, yes, American banks were able to threaten a lot more mutually-assured destruction so as to intimidate the government into continuation of their too-big-to-fail status. Not sure how that's an argument in favor of paying the Danegeld though.
- krapp 10y ago>Not sure how that's an argument in favor of paying the Danegeld though. Because not paying it would likely have tipped an already precarious global economy further towards depression, and that's not acceptable. So you pay the Danes off until you can actually kill them without killing yourself in the process.
- venomsnake 10y agoEight years later and the Danes are thriving. We already paid the social costs of total economic meltdown. But we have nothing to show for it.
- SilasX 10y agoJust so we're on the same page, do you understand the logic behind not paying extortionists? The "later" doesn't come, and the payment only makes them better at extorting you, and draws in more people to try the same. You typically won't get a better opportunity. If you come up with a rationalization for how you absolutely must defer the reckoning today, why won't you come up with one tomorrow as well?
- krapp 10y agoThe US government could have done something about the banks after having bailed them out without wreaking havoc, but they didn't. Not because the government didn't have the power to, but because it apparently didn't have the will. Simply letting the US banking industry collapse and take the country with it as a power play of refusal to give in to "extortion" would have been insane.
- 10y ago