7 ms·
As someone in a country with a serious mugging problem and having lost an iPhone already, one of the biggest security flaws I see is being able to power it off
by Razengan 10y ago
As someone in a country with a serious mugging problem and having lost an iPhone already, one of the biggest security flaws I see is being able to power it off without providing any authentication.
What is even the point of Find my Phone and all that if anyone can just instantly switch off all the tracking?? You can't even ring your own number after that, and even law enforcement cannot look up the cell tower logs to see where it's been.
There should be an option to require a passcode for power-off, and another option to periodically send Find my Phone tracking even when "powered off," via any available network, until the battery dies.
EDIT: I agree they can just take out the SIM and we need to be able to force-power-off anyway.. but what can be done to increase the recoverability of these expensive items?
- pavel_lishin 10y agoWouldn't that be trivially defeated with a small packet of tin foil?
- Jtsummers 10y agoAnd removing the SIM card.
- rolodato 10y agoThe problem is that there has to be a way to forcefully power off the phone in case it freezes. If the OS depends on software to power off and the software is not reponsive, there's no way to shut it down without exhausting/removing the battery.
- gnashville 10y agoI think that's what sleep/wake+home button is for. Holding sleep/wake still requires 'slide to power off' (which i assume wouldn't respond when iOS locks up.) sleep/wake+home button restarts iOS but ultimately reconnects to the device to the web.
- wyager 10y agoIf the phone is locked, they can't do anything but part it out anyway. They might as well remove the battery.
- ericabiz 10y agoEven if Apple added that, it's trivially easy to pop the SIM. A phone without a network connection won't ping, so that won't help. You have to think about it from the attacker's point of view. Anyone they sell it to is going to power it on to test it. Once it's powered on, it'll ping back. Any black-market buyer knows to pop the SIM anyway before powering it on, and turn on the phone without any publicly-accessible Wifi access points available. But then they still have to restore it in order to see if it's iCloud locked, and the restore pings, too (it requires an Internet connection to Apple's servers to download a signed OS.) What it comes down to is that stolen iPhones just aren't worth that much, since there's no easy way to remove an iCloud lock and the parts themselves aren't worth a lot. The good news is that far fewer iPhones are stolen these days (source: http://www.cbsnews.com/news/iphone-thefts-down-thanks-to-apple-kill-switch/ http://www.cbsnews.com/news/iphone-thefts-down-thanks-to-app... ), and thieves are pretty quickly learning that.
- ivank 10y agoGoing by eBay, a lot of people are still managing to sell stolen iPhones for $100-$300: http://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_nkw=icl0ud%20locked&LH_Complete=1&LH_Sold=1 http://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_nkw=icl0ud%20locked&LH_Compl...
- MrMullen 10y agoWhat do you do with a iCould locked phone? It seems like a completely worthless device if it is locked.
- JosephBrown 10y agoThe ability to quickly turn off the phone is useful when you need to activate a long password so that you cannot be forced to use your fingerprint to unlock it.
- dogma1138 10y agoIf you are in a place where you can be forced to unlock it with your finger they'll force you to give out the password too, it would probably even be more painful. The only place where you would not want to use biometrics are western* countries which would allow the police to compel you to give out your fingerprints to unlock the phone. With the exception of the UK in which not giving out a password or decryption key in the course of an investigation even if you are not the suspect of a crime can land you 7 years in prison these days.
- ubuntuftw 10y ago>and even law enforcement cannot look up the cell tower logs to see where it's been. I'm not so sure about that... I worked at a TV news station in a major city where police told us they could track cell phones that were turned off. IIRC, it came up during an interview after they apprehended a suspect in a big rape/murder case. The suspect's phone was off, but they were able to track him. They told us they didn't really want the public to know they could do this, but it seems it's too late for that [1]. I'm not sure what the limitations are-- whether it'll work if the battery is removed (maybe there's amother battery?) or whether it only works with certain phones. [1] https://www.quora.com/Can-law-enforcement-track-someone-by-their-mobile-device-when-it-is-off https://www.quora.com/Can-law-enforcement-track-someone-by-t...
- dogma1138 10y agoWhen the phone is off it is off. Same goes with flight mode. The NSA* or any other similar actor can load malware to your phone that would prevent it from being completely turned off, the police most likely cannot. The police does have a vested interest in making the public think that turning the phone off is pointless. *on older phones like late 90's very early 2000's there was enough power leaking from from the antenna into the modem part that you could ping turned off phones remotely even if the battery was removed I've seen this in action. This doesn't or shouldn't work on new phones which require considerably more power and have very complicated hardware.
- Johnny555 10y agoon older phones like late 90's very early 2000's there was enough power leaking from from the antenna into the modem part that you could ping turned off phones remotely even if the battery was removed I've seen this in action I don't see how that could work - even if power through the antenna did cause the phone to transmit something, more than the radio would have to be powered up to get the phone to return any kind of identifier. But I'm skeptical that any transmitter could be powered through the antenna like that. I could believe that if you transmit enough power that some sort of oscillation would occur in the phone to return a signal that can be detected, but I don't see how you could determine what phone returned that signal.
- duaneb 10y ago> but what can be done to increase the recoverability of these expensive items? Move to a place with thieves who know not to steal a really hard to move phone.
- rdtsc 10y ago> but what can be done to increase the recoverability of these expensive items? Don't buy or walk with expensive items around? Sounds like I am being snarky, but I am serious. In some cities or areas, it is not possible to have nice stuff around. Couldn't have a nice car in my old neighborhood. The old beater I had was scratched, hit and broken into multiple times. I didn't care too much, as it was already scratched and beat up anyway. If it was a nice new car, I would have been upset, but I would have never gotten a nicer car living in that part of town. As for phone, I broke my old flip phone some years ago, by sitting on it. And I was upset about it obviously, it was a nice model then. I was student, bought it by saving for a while. Didn't have insurance and so on. And since then realized that it didn't make any sense for me to buy these expensive toys if they can easily be lost, stolen, broken _if_ it causes me so much anguish when happens. So since then I've bought used, or lower end smart phones (last one is a Moto G for $170 from 3-4 years ago) so that if it gets, broken, stolen, lost I wouldn't be too upset about it, just inconvinienced some, and would just go and buy another one. Kind of like buying another pair of pants or socks. I one day if I win the lottery, maybe I'll be able to buy $500-$600 iPhones like that too. But today If I had one, and cracked or lost, I would be quite upset. I am saying this because I've seen people sign contracts to buy these phones (which is basically getting a loan), buying insurance for them and so on, and all I am think "it sounds like you can't afford it". Can't obviously tell them that in person, but's that the idea.
- TeMPOraL 10y ago> And since then realized that it didn't make any sense for me to buy these expensive toys if they can easily be lost, stolen, broken _if_ it causes me so much anguish when happens. So since then I've bought used, or lower end smart phones (last one is a Moto G for $170 from 3-4 years ago) so that if it gets, broken, stolen, lost I wouldn't be too upset about it, just inconvinienced some, and would just go and buy another one. Kind of like buying another pair of pants or socks. Interesting. Different ways of managing expected frustration. Personally, I stick to highest-end phones I can afford, for the simple reason - I was once stuck for 3 years with a phone that was so crappy that it could barely lift its own OS - fire up any app, homescreen gets killed to save memory. Somebody calls you? 25% chance that you won't be able to pick it up, because the phone will hang. Try and turn on Internet on it? If you didn't turn off sync, you'll have to powercycle the phone by removing its battery to get it working again. I don't break or lose phones often (in the last 3 years, I managed to crack the screen of my S4 two times; got the glass replaced both times for relatively little cost). But I use them quite a lot, every day. Minor frustrations like apps crashing, hanging, or taking 30 seconds to load tend to add up into quite a bit of frustration daily. So I prefer to save up and buy a phone that I know will work flawlessly for the next 3 years or so (and, like with S4, then I happily give it away to someone when I buy a new one; they can probably squeeze 3 more years off it too).
- cm2187 10y agoFrance?