3 ms·
Why is a traffic violation even de facto probable cause [0] to search someone for completely orthogonal concerns? That has been a massive end-run around the fou
by mindslight 10y ago
Why is a traffic violation even de facto probable cause [0] to search someone for completely orthogonal concerns? That has been a massive end-run around the fourth amendment!
Creating a class of disarmed traffic officers could be a great way to help restore the concept of privacy - make them powerless to enforce or provide testimony on anything besides traffic laws. This would have similar effects to deillegalizing personal possession of substances, including the non-politically-favored ones.
Then, prevent the armed group from doing any traffic enforcement - they're solely reserved for already-escalated situations. Furthermore, this could reduce the perverse incentive of a highly paid position doing overtime traffic duty.
(And furthermore while we're exploring this fantasy of defascizing automobile transport, let's change license plates to e-ink with a privacy-preserving blinded number that changes every hour)
[0] By mandating that the person stop, open their window, etc, with any non-compliance escalating to legal probable cause.
- tptacek 10y agoTraffic violations aren't probable cause for searches. The police cannot search your car at a traffic stop simply because you've violated traffic law.
- mindslight 10y agoThat's the reason I said "de facto". Read my footnote. If I were to communicate with an officer by written messages shown through the glass (to avoid a search of my cabin air), do you think it would go well?
- tptacek 10y ago"Non-compliance" doesn't "escalate to probable cause". What you're probably trying to say is that arrest generates cause for search, under the rules for "search incident to arrest". But arrest is a big deal, far bigger than traffic stop or even roadside detention. As for trying to communicate with officers through glass: I'm not sure what you're trying to accomplish, but there are tens of videos of people rolling their windows down minimally to respond to traffic stops, so that police can't put their heads in the car. ACLU even publishes one of them.
- mindslight 10y agoArrest generating cause for search is only half of it - what is that arrest based on? Presumably it's often based on noncompliance with orders that constitute a de facto search, with the only original cause being a traffic violation. Do you dispute that it's a common occurrence for people to be pulled over for a civil traffic violation yet to end up arrested for possession of something? This phenomenon flies in the face of the fourth amendment, the courts' function of finding logical justifications for the status quo notwithstanding.
- tptacek 10y agoTo arrest someone, you have to have probable cause, and then you have to actually arrest them. People are routinely searched at traffic stops because they aren't taught their rights properly, and comments that say traffic stops provide "de facto" probable cause for searches don't help (the harm is obviously marginal, but still.)
- mindslight 10y agoYour comments imply that there is a legal flowchart that can be followed to definitely keep a traffic stop confined to just a traffic stop, and if not at least the case will be thrown out. I'd say this is a bit naive and more harmful than my slight discouragement of people investigating their assertable rights. I certainly support people who go through the effort of asserting their rights (and do some of this myself, but I also realize that game is more than just a legal one). If I were into divisive identity politics, I would say that perhaps the various legal chess moves just work most of the time for privileged people (the videos you referenced etc). But alas that's a losing race-to-the-bottom framework, and we're better off talking about rights. I like your original post. I'm expanding on it and pointing out how we could completely avoid all of these issues with separate roles - I don't think that parking critters are particularly concerned with searching one's possessions either. Can we agree that it would be better if maintaining one's own rights did not require a law degree and constant vigilance?
- 10y ago