5 ms·
If Venezuela defaulted on foreign debts, it will be very difficult (and/or expensive) to borrow again in the future. Venezuela is essentially hedging their sit
by Alupis 10y ago
If Venezuela defaulted on foreign debts, it will be very difficult (and/or expensive) to borrow again in the future.
Venezuela is essentially hedging their situation is temporary (however temporary, temporary is), and having a good economic standing in the future may depend heavily on foreign investments (particularly since Venezuela is a petroleum based economy).
Burning those bridges now could cripple Venezuela permanently.
The same question could be posed of any nation with impoverished citizens and foreign debts. We could even examine the USA, which has never defaulted, even during the height of the Great Depression.
Choosing to default on those debts and instead send temporary (and likely insignificant, once the bureaucracy runs it's course) aid to some citizens jeopardizes the entire nation. Simply put, the trade-off is not worth it.
- brianlweiner 10y agoBut Venezuela has already seized and nationalized foreign-owned assets. Surely that burnt plenty of bridges? I'm more likely to believe that influential Venezuelans are exposed to the current bond market and are seeking to delay the reckoning.
- Alupis 10y ago> But Venezuela has already seized and nationalized foreign-owned assets. Surely that burnt plenty of bridges? They seized/nationalized Exxon's assets, which certainly burnt that bridge (Exxon promptly filed for arbitration). But Exxon is only one foreign company. Perhaps Venezuela sees a future of no foreign petroleum companies, but rather use foreign investments/loans to build their own internal petroleum operations. This seems likely after nationalizing the existing plants.
- saryant 10y agoAfter nationalization Venezuela told all PDVSA workers that they either had to be loyal to Chavez or quit. Many of the best left, knowing they could take positions with the supermajors or service contractors in other countries. PDVSA was left with a hodgepodge of lackeys and hacks who don't know what they're doing. That problem is compounded by the fact that Venezuelan crude is a pain in the ass to deal with. Some of the nastiest on earth. Extremely heavy and sour (which is also why Venezuelan crude trades at a discount to the benchmarks).
- Alupis 10y agoI believe you are making my point. Venezuela's future will depend on and require foreign investments and expertise. Burning that bridge (or not burning it) is a calculated risk.
- woodandsteel 10y ago>Venezuela's future will depend on and require foreign investments and expertise. Well yes, but you seem to be assuming Maduro is rational on economic matters. But if that was so, the Venezuelan economy would not be in such a terrible mess.
- ptaipale 10y agoAlas, it looks like the Chavez and Maduro governments are not really capable of calculating risks, or even understanding rational processes. They are completely ideological short-term opportunists.
- hiou 10y agoExactly. And this is why defaulting is so dangerous. To lose access to that foreign investment in the future would be disastrous for that plan.
- abpavel 10y ago> Exxon is only one foreign company It's starting to sound like you're one of the bond holders or securities tied to the bonds. Exxon is consistently in the top 10 on F500, and was an absolutely critical part of bloodline. Nationalization of Exxon was the an act of desperation, the last gasp, not "just one company". Having visited Venezuela, it is obvious there are huge problems with the state of affairs that no foreign investments are going to solve. (Edit:identation)
- woodandsteel 10y agoFrom what I understand, Chavez was a marxist-socialist-nationalist who wanted to keep foreign investment out, and instituted policies that did this quite effectively, and Maduro has the same intentions.
- knowaveragejoe 10y agoDo you have any more information on this? I'm pretty out of the loop on the Venezuela situation and would like to know more, but don't even know where to begin.
- g_delgado14 10y agoWithin the article theres a QuickTake explainer [0] on Vzlas economy [0] - http://www.bloomberg.com/quicktake/venezuela-price-revolution http://www.bloomberg.com/quicktake/venezuela-price-revolutio...
- rmsaksida 10y agoThis article is very informative: https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/global-opinions/hugo-chavezs-long-con/2016/07/01/26e8b690-3f8c-11e6-80bc-d06711fd2125_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/global-opinions/hugo...
- dublinben 10y agoArgentina had a record-setting default in 2001, and was able to reach a settlement to issue new bonds this year. There is no such thing as "permanent" in the international debt markets. Someone will eventually be willing to lend you money, at the right price.
- Alupis 10y ago> Argentina had a record-setting default in 2001, and was able to reach a settlement to issue new bonds this year 15 years later (and arguably not in a much better condition than before). We shouldn't pretend a nation-state default has few/zero negative ramifications. > Someone will eventually be willing to lend you money, at the right price. You are right... but money gets a lot more expensive. It could very well be more expensive than riding out the temporary slump (which is largely tied to the petroleum markets from my understanding).
- dublinben 10y agoThe government of Argentina voluntarily took the position that they would not settle with the outstanding debt holders. They could have settled 15 years ago and regained access to international debt markets right away.
- Alupis 10y agoDoing so would not have made the situation much better. To an outside investor, Argentina is a lot more risky now that they've proven they're willing to default when things get rough. That kind of risk isn't impossible to overcome, but it's very expensive. For a struggling nation without a strong economy, foreign investments can be lifeblood.
- roymurdock 10y agoOr a noose. Debt is a double-edged sword - it all depends on if it's structured in a reasonable fashion, and if it used in a productive manner that can pay down promised future payments.
- redstripe 10y agoCan you give some examples of where a country defaulted and was worse off? I think most recently Iceland defaulted and they seem to be doing alright - but maybe given it's size it doesn't really count.
- venomsnake 10y agoIceland didn't default. They let their commercial banks die without intervention from the government. Also known as what the US Treasury should have done in 2008. If something is too big to fail - it must be killed immediately.
- krapp 10y agoNo offense to Iceland, but the world economy is far less affected by the loss of Icleandic financial institutions than American ones.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoBut you're moving the goalposts on this discussion. The question wasn't the impact on the global economy; it was the impact on the national one. So the Iceland example is directly relevant.
- krapp 10y agoPart of this discussion seems to be whether or not the Treasury should have done what Iceland did, and I'm just trying to point out that they had valid reasons to do anything but that.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoClarification: Do you mean the US Treasury? If so, yes, I agree with you. And yes, that has been part of the discussion.
- 10y ago
- Analemma_ 10y ago> Burning those bridges now could cripple Venezuela permanently. There's not a lot of evidence for this. It's not like no country has ever defaulted before, it happens all the time, and they were able to borrow again once they got themselves functional. Defaulting is bad but certainly not a death sentence. It's especially weird when, as the article points out, bondholders are practically expecting default - and charging interest to match! At a time when it has very little cash, Venezuela is paying extra to avoid a situation that bondholders have already resigned themselves to. > Simply put, the trade-off is not worth it. That's not a sure thing. It could be worth it, depending on how they use the newfound money. It doesn't just have to be buying food, as important as that is. What if they use it to get some functional power plants? The massive brownouts right now are hobbling the economy; there would be much better growth prospects if people had reliable power.
- Alupis 10y ago> What if they use it to get some functional power plants? The massive brownouts right now are hobbling the economy; there would be much better growth prospects if people had reliable power. Very good point. However, it's likely in order to build and maintain such infrastructure, Venezuela would need foreign investment and expertise... If they burn all the bridges, this may not be possible to accomplish. Perhaps they could find someone willing to take on the risk, but it may cost them even more than just continuing to pay the debts and ride-out the petroleum slump.
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> If they burn all the bridges, this may not be possible to accomplish The bridges were burnt more thoroughly by Chavez's expropriation as well as his and Maduro's price-control and rationing policies. I would put a dollar in Greece or Puerto Rico before Venezuela, despite the formers having defaulted and the latter not.
- hiou 10y agoNot sure what part of this is warrants down voting? There are valid points even if they might be a a little off the mark Venezuela is very dependent on financing for its oil exploration and infrastructure. The reality is that they simply need to hold the fort until oil rebounds in a year or two. Otherwise a huge portion of their future oil extraction will go to financing as opposed to Venezuela. It is certainly a risk but to say the opposite is not a huge risk with serious consequences is pretty naive.
- wahern 10y agoYou're basically saying that Venezuelan officials understand good market and monetary policy. And yet their domestic price controls, which are the _direct_ cause of the country's current dire straits (and not the price of oil) suggests that they don't understand or accept the most basic of economic rules which even market skeptics (like Malaysia's Mahathir Mohamad, credited rightly or wrongly for Malaysia avoiding the worst of the 1997 Asian financial crisis) grudgingly accept. So it's really quite a puzzle. I tend to think all the explanations play a part: 1) maintaining kickbacks and cash flow to powerful players, 2) keeping face wrt Chavism, and 3) ensuring that the national oil company remains (at least in their eyes) a global player.