3 ms·
That is evidence of the problem being difficult, not a rigorous "perpetual motion"-level impossibility proof. I could write something similar about a proposal t
by SilasX 10y ago
That is evidence of the problem being difficult, not a rigorous "perpetual motion"-level impossibility proof. I could write something similar about a proposal to have computers play chess, based on the absurd blowup in elementary operations (think 1940s) and logic gate resets needed to compute a good move.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> That is evidence of the problem being difficult, not a rigorous "perpetual motion"-level impossibility proof. That the uncertainty produced by the source chosen exceeds the acceptable variability in the results is an impossibility proof for a testing method relying exclusively on a single sample from that source having acceptable accuracy, since the accuracy of the test result cannot exceed the accuracy of the source used in representing the underlying measure.
- SilasX 10y agoOnly if you could know in advance that there was no way to filter the input to the point that there is a correlation between the the filtered input and the blood state, which is exactly the point under contention. For comparison, there is tremendous variation in the sound waves that humans recognize as the word "apple", but there are still systems that can filter out the relevant noise and identify the critical dimensions of variation.
- csallen 10y agoUnless their test involves technology that can lower the uncertainty to acceptable levels, e.g. being able to isolate the blood from certain vessels despite using a prick method. Simply saying that the source is messy is not a proof that it's impossible to work around that.
- TillE 10y agoThe source is not merely messy. It's a tiny sample of a fluid which is not absolutely consistent throughout. This is a fundamental problem. You might luck into roughly correct results most of the time, but the basic nature of statistics is against you.
- csallen 10y agoOh I don't disagree with you at all. But even based on what you said, it's not hard to imagine that it's possible to identify and test some previously unidentified component of said fluid that is consistent throughout. My point is only that there is no hard theory decrying this to be impossible in the same way that, say, computer scientists can prove that a problem is NP-complete.