3 ms·
Some of the comments here are pointing out the questions about data quality etc. that affect a study like this. And those are real concerns, and obviously analy
by snowwrestler 10y ago
Some of the comments here are pointing out the questions about data quality etc. that affect a study like this. And those are real concerns, and obviously analytical studies could only be improved if they had better data to work with.
But let's not make the mistake of looking at this study only in isolation. It is a recent addition to a large collection of observations and evidence that support a theory that personal racial bias affects American policing.
The evidence includes other studies, criminal investigations, criminal cases, federal investigations and reform agreements with police departments like Cleveland and Seattle, videos and photos of violent police encounters, and of course decades of stories and statements from minority communities about how the police treats them.
The last one is important because it gets at trust, which is the heart of the issue. Minority communities, many of them, do not trust the police to protect them in the same way they protect whiter/richer communities, and they have stories that explain why not.
If you are depending solely on data-driven studies to inform your opinion on racial bias in policing, then you're implicitly saying that you distrust or reject what minority people and communities say. Why is that? It's worth thinking about IMO.
Which brings us back to the data. Why is it so lacking? You can't answer that question without coming back around to bias, because until recently, it was the police forces themselves who supplied the data, or not, or only part of the data. So discounting the bias reported in this study because of data problems is getting toward begging the question, logically speaking.
The essential question, when it comes to whether you agree that racial bias affects policing, is: what level of evidence will convince you?
- specialist 10y agoThe value of studies like this, for future, is the ability to determine if mitigation, correctional measures are working. "what level of evidence will convince you?" We need to learn to ask this more frequently, upfront. Persuasion doesn't work. Finding your tribe and organizing does.
- millermp12 10y ago"Finding your tribe and organizing does" Sounds racist. Unless you're not white.