5 ms·
I'm not sure you didn't mean it as such, but don't all lives actually matter?
by DiabloD3 10y ago
I'm not sure you didn't mean it as such, but don't all lives actually matter?
- moo 10y agoThey don't matter equally. Should they matter equally? Yes. Saying all lives matter obfuscates that they don't matter equally.
- CWuestefeld 10y agoYou're assuming that they don't matter equally. That may be true, but it's dangerous to start off by simply assuming the validity of your thesis. Moreover, it assumes that the way in which they don't matter equally is based only on racial lines. I'm far from convinced that's completely true. It appears that's some of it, but the fact is that police kill lots of innocent whites, hispanics, and asians as well. That being the case, wouldn't it make more sense to look more broadly at where the disparities are, rather than simply assuming that it's all racial while refusing to entertain any other possibility?
- jamesroseman 10y agoOf course all lives matter. But if racial identities were homes, there are a few on fire in the United States and it doesn't make much sense to call the fire department for every house when a few urgently need the attention more. Is that fair?
- mhuffman 10y agoBlack people are not actively being targeted by anyone but other black people. Is that fair?
- bdcravens 10y agoI had no idea that Dylan Roof was African American. "..actively being targeted.." is a red herring. Active, or in response, we need to look at the effect. Black on black crime is bad, and is a crime, and should be punished accordingly. Police killing someone has a much more difficult time of being convicted as a crime. In theory, punishment would be a deterrent, but giving someone a license to kill is a much different level of fear.
- mhuffman 10y agoI am not pro-police. I believe they all need civilian oversight and review, and a thorough de-materialization. The problem is that with the above the "Black Lives Matter" not "All Lives Matter" is that it leaves an unmentioned part ... "Black Lives Matter, because White People Are Doing X (whatever X is that month". If black lives matters would have stuck to being a police revision group, most of the country could have got on board. As it stands, they are an anti-white hate-group, with not specific agenda other than "Whitey Sucks!"
- jamesroseman 10y ago> As it stands, they are an anti-white hate-group, with not specific agenda other than "Whitey Sucks!" I'm not sure there's much more to that statement than baseless opinion. If you're interested in what the BLM movement has accomlished, there are many resources at your disposal, but I'd start here [1]. [1] http://blacklivesmatter.com/11-major-misconceptions-about-the-black-lives-matter-movement/ http://blacklivesmatter.com/11-major-misconceptions-about-th...
- pixl97 10y agoLet's word this a different way. If 6 black people's homes were on fire, and 4 white people's homes were on fire, wouldn't it make more sense to send firefighters to all the houses? It should be recognised that having a violent interaction with police in America occurs more often than every other first world country regardless if your black or white.
- eropple 10y agoThey do, but "All Lives Matter" is a purposeful and pernicious misunderstanding of what "Black Lives Matter" means, which is something along the lines of (quoted from a law professor[1], and I think it could be a little better-turned but you'll get the idea): Because of the brutalizing and killing of black people at the hands of the police and the indifference of society in general and the criminal justice system in particular, it is important that we say that Black Lives Matter. This is, of course, too long to fit on a T-shirt. One might wish that they'd gone with "Black Lives Matter, Too", but that isn't as rhetorically strong and smacks of me-tooism, of begging to be treated like humans rather than asserting humanity. Either way, "All Lives Matter" is at its heart a racist dog-whistle precisely because it attempts to diminish the current, very active threat caused to black communities by the police and the justice systems that should exist to help them (instead of exist to maintain a profoundly racist status quo). If you are not on board with this, I would advise not using the phrase. [1] - http://imgur.com/a/YkDVQ http://imgur.com/a/YkDVQ
- milesokeefe 10y agoRe: the attached album - I'd like to write a followup letter to that professor concerning his/her use of Avante Garde as a body font.
- bdcravens 10y agoGrandparent comment was concerned because they have a black child. Generally speaking, I get pissed off at most SJW BS. These days, however, I genuinely fear for my black friends, while as a white male I've never had that fear (and yes I've had more police interaction than I should have, so no ivory tower here...) The use of "all lives" and "human" when addressing these very real concerns is usually a way of snidely disregarding these concerns; "black lives matter" isn't some racist grouping of words, but has a very specific meaning.