5 ms·
Can you elaborate on the "anti-federation" stance of Signal's creator? I'm not familiar with this.
by bogomipz 10y ago
Can you elaborate on the "anti-federation" stance of Signal's creator? I'm not familiar with this.
- Arnt 10y agoYou can't run your own signal server. All accounts use phone numbers in the same namespace as ID, and all messages go from the phone to opensystems.org, further on to google, and from google to the destination phone (with lots of encryption being added and removed at various points). This has advantages (it's difficult for the Man distinguish a received signal message from other android notifications) but also disadvantage (moxie can do traffic analysis and you can't do anything about it).
- lorenzhs 10y agoYou can totally run your own server for yourself and your friends: https://github.com/WhisperSystems/TextSecure-Server https://github.com/WhisperSystems/TextSecure-Server (you'll have to change the server's URL in the client's source as well and compile it yourself, but that's really easy) What you won't be able to do is federate with the official servers. Oh, and there's also a WebSocket transport (used by the Desktop client) that doesn't involve Google. That just doesn't provide a pleasant experience on mobile.
- rvense 10y agoYeah, so instead of being in Whisper Systems' walled garden, I can set up my own and ask people to install Rvense's Magical Messenger App. Sit there in my treehouse with a bucket on my head and a NO DUMMIES sign or something.
- eropple 10y ago> you'll have to change the server's URL in the client's source as well and compile it yourself, but that's really easy I'm sorry, but is this a joke? "To not use a centralized server that you can neither audit nor trust, you have to recompile the client, but that's easy?" This smacks of "oh, PGP for email is fiiiiiine." To say nothing of the silliness of the inability to federate.
- AckSyn 10y agoNo, it's not a joke and you shouldn't treat it as such. Non-technical people really shouldn't be whining that their "free service" doesn't cater to a click-and-run crowd. The source is available to the public to create their own, and changing a URL in the code is a single regex command away. Don't casually disregard him because you or others can't understand basics of doing what it takes to alter and run a service in your own private space.
- eropple 10y agoI don't casually disregard him. I thoughtfully and with consideration disregard him, and you as well. The idea that there is a priestly-class of technical people and "non-technical people shouldn't whine" is silly. This is not for technical people. This is for non-technical people. I've been doing this stuff for twenty years. But me being able to do it doesn't do a damned thing to help the people who actually need help. I don't need Signal to communicate with knowledgeable people. We need something to communicate with everyone else.
- bobbyd3 10y ago^ this
- baudehlo 10y agoAnd yet the same argument has been made time and time again against SMTP. Let's stand back for a second and understand why SMTP has stood the test of time. Yes it has flaws that allow the "first contact" problem (ie spam). But the people working on SMTP at least understand the weaknesses and advantages of that.
- jamesgeck0 10y agoDistributing a modified client is non-trivial, especially if any of your friends use iOS.
- lorenzhs 10y agoYou can sideload apps without a developer subscription. It's annoying but works. But you have an unsolved update problem on both Android and iOS. You really shouldn't do this if you're not 100% sure of the implications.
- lorenzhs 10y agoI assume the GP is referring to https://whispersystems.org/blog/the-ecosystem-is-moving/ https://whispersystems.org/blog/the-ecosystem-is-moving/
- fapjacks 10y agoThat seems to be a very coherent, insightful post by a very highly-respected cypherpunk. I am pretty much 100% on board with what he is saying.
- rvense 10y agoMy response is that we just have to try harder. He's focusing only on encryption and ignoring the massive social problem of one company or a few companies having a monopoly on digital communication. Just like whether or not I'm spied on is irrelevant to whether or not I have the right to private (encrypted) communications, it doesn't matter who has monopoly or what they use it for. We should not be building infrastructure that encourages monopolies, and unfederated services are by definition monopolies.
- Arnt 10y agoGo on and try harder, and please post a Show HN when you have something to show.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]