3 ms·
I am always amazed by your trust in our injustice system. I am sure that all of the filed paperwork for the plea colloquy looks proper. There was the formulai
by btilly 10y ago
I am always amazed by your trust in our injustice system.
I am sure that all of the filed paperwork for the plea colloquy looks proper. There was the formulaic set of things to be asked and said, and all were asked and said. The defendant knew what she had to say to avoid years in jail, and said them. On an appeal, it would all be in order, and there would be little chance of the judge being embarrassed by the result.
As for the prosecutor, so few plea bargains are ever appealed that it is in their interest to plough people through the system as efficiently as they can. If efficiency gets you 10 more convictions, one of which gets overturned, you've got 9 more under your belt than you would otherwise. And less than 10% of these convictions ever get appealed, let alone won on appeal.
Everyone here is acting in accord with their incentives. The police made an arrest based on an honest belief from chemical evidence. The prosecutor made a conviction. The judge filed all the right paperwork. The defendant got out of jail in weeks rather than the threatened years. This is all business as usual.
The result was absolutely and entirely unjust. That is ALSO business as usual.
- rayiner 10y ago> I am always amazed by your trust in our injustice system. Our justice system gets a lot of things wrong. I'm pretty sure I've called the federal sentencing guidelines "quackery." I don't think plea bargaining is one of the things it gets wrong. At one point, it was part of my job to read plea colloquies, in a city that saw a lot of drug prosecutions. They looked nothing like what the article is describing. I'm skeptical of the article on the basis of observation and experience, not faith.[1] > I am sure that all of the filed paperwork for the plea colloquy looks proper. There was the formulaic set of things to be asked and said, and all were asked and said. What goes on file is the transcript of the oral hearing. If, as the article asserts, the defendant was too much in tears to say anything intelligible besides "guilty" the transcript would reflect that and you would not have a proper colloquy. [1] Relevant: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5203871 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5203871 ("Briefly stated, the Gell-Mann Amnesia effect is as follows. You open the newspaper to an article on some subject you know well. In Murray’s case, physics. In mine, show business. You read the article and see the journalist has absolutely no understanding of either the facts or the issues. Often, the article is so wrong it actually presents the story backward—reversing cause and effect. I call these the “wet streets cause rain” stories. Paper’s full of them. In any case, you read with exasperation or amusement the multiple errors in a story, and then turn the page to national or international affairs, and read as if the rest of the newspaper was somehow more accurate about Palestine than the baloney you just read. You turn the page, and forget what you know.")
- btilly 10y agoMy distrust of the plea bargain system was cemented by the case of Aaron Swartz. The insane difficulty of fighting a legal case, combined with the very large difference in penalties between plea bargaining and fighting create an extreme incentive for people to plea bargain. Whether or not they are guilty. When we provide that strong of an incentive against trying for justice, we have to expect unjust results. They won't look unjust from what the judge sees in the court room. They will be unjust because the person plea bargaining has been bullied into admitting to a lie. This is a fundamental problem that happens before you walk into the court room. Nothing you see in court will indicate how big the problem is. To get a handle on it you need to do an independent review of a randomly chosen fraction of plea bargains to see how different the results are from what a just result would be. I would be willing to bet a large sum that in a significant percentage of cases (ie over 10%), the result is unjust.
- tedunangst 10y agoStrange reply to a comment that called federal sentencing guidelines quackery.
- rayiner 10y agoMost plea bargains are like the Swartz case in an important sense: hard evidence exists to establish the facts. There was no dispute in the Swartz case as to what happened. It's not like there was a possibility that someone else was in that network closet. What was outrageous in that case was the charges and maximum sentence for what was a clear-cut case of physical and digital trespassing. Your 10% figure seems bogus to me. Almost all plea bargained cases are clear-cut. Security footage of the defendant walking out of the store with the TV. Cops called to a house as a husband is beating his wife. Stash of drugs found under the front seat at a traffic stop. That is the bread and butter of the justice system, not cases where facts or intent can be seriously disputed.