10 ms·
African wildlife officials appalled as EU opposes a total ban on ivory trade
- overcast 10y agoWhat the hell is wrong with these people? It's 2016, use your brains you savages.
- iteabagkevin2 10y ago"It's the current year" is not an argument.
- ced 10y agoDoes anyone have context for the EU opposition to the ban? Economic interests?
- iteabagkevin2 10y agoBecause black markets for these goods are much more devastating to the animal populations than a legal regulated marketplace.
- adamnemecek 10y agoThis is simply not true and this 'meme' is really harmful. A legal market would only encourage consumption and serve as a cover for the black market.
- kctess5 10y agoSource?
- duaneb 10y agoDo you have a source? I'm extremely skeptical and you didn't make an argument for it.
- adamnemecek 10y agoThe current poaching crisis is generally attributed to the lifting of CITES restrictions in 2008 which let some African countries sell their ivory stockpiles to China and Japan. As a result, the consumption has skyrocketed.
- SimonPStevens 10y agoI would like to see some evidence on either side of this argument. I can see that there is logic to both cases. Saying one side is "simply not true" doesn't make your case. Is there any firm evidence either way.
- adamnemecek 10y agoRead the comments in this thread. The current crisis is generally attributed to the 2008 lifting of CITES restrictions that has allowed African countries to sell their stockpiles to China and Japan.
- soyiuz 10y agoSome of the most convincing evidence comes from American prohibition of alcohol and the drug wars. Basic economic principles dictate that the supply will expand to meet demand. As the demand is difficult to modulate, the strategy of regulating supply has been historically more effective. The prohibition created a robust black market which all but disappeared when alcohol production came back into the light by legal means. The same logic should hold true for ivory through farming or artificial production (see several comments to this point above).
- chrischen 10y agoThe arguments I have heard for a legal market is that the rhino horns can be harvested without killing them, and that the black market trade encourages poachers to simply kill the rhinos to harvest. Your turn.
- zymhan 10y agoWhat do you do with a Rhino that has no horn? It can't survive in the wild, and it has no economic value to justify keeping it on a farm.
- chrischen 10y agoPeople can come see the Rhinos, like a zoo, while their horns grow back. http://www.bisbeesconservationfund.org/conservation/savetherhino/faq.aspx http://www.bisbeesconservationfund.org/conservation/savether...
- adamnemecek 10y agoThat doesn't stop poaching. It would only make rhinos extinct in the wild.
- chrischen 10y agoThe goal is to have farmed rhinos out price killing wild rhinos, and you continue making killing wild rhinos illegal.
- adamnemecek 10y agoHow do you outprice poachers when raising a rhino costs more than zero but poaching them costs effectively zero?
- akiselev 10y agoPoaching isn't effectively free, like many other illegal activities it carries risk of death or capture and imprisonment. By investing in enforcement you can drive up the risk and thus the price.
- justicezyx 10y agoBad is bad, no matter how small it is. Good is good, no mater how small it is. It is not about changing the world overnight, it is about moving 1 inch every time.
- mamon 10y agoOne more devastating thing is that whenever police make a ride on poachers and take over some ivory or rhino's horns they will burn them. Which decreases supply and increases black market price for them. The wisest thing to do would be to give it away for free to anyone interested. That would ruin black market.
- adamnemecek 10y agoIt would also condone use of ivory. It would also out the ivory back on the market.
- mc32 10y agoIf China can get on board, surely the EU can.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- yorwba 10y agothe article links to http://ec.europa.eu/transparency/regdoc/rep/1/2016/EN/1-2016-437-EN-F1-1-ANNEX-2.PDF http://ec.europa.eu/transparency/regdoc/rep/1/2016/EN/1-2016... which says on page 7 Clarification needs to be made as to the scope of the proposal - the call for a general closure of domestic ivory markets does not seem justified but the EU could show openness to initiatives aiming to restrict domestic ivory trade, provided that the measures are proportionate (for example call for closure of domestic market except for pre-Convention ivory or in cases where there have been evidences that domestic legal markets have been used as a cover for illegal ivory trade). and on page 13 Oppose the transfer to Appendix I of the populations of BW, NA, ZA, ZW. These four national populations have an increasing population trend (tbc for Zimbabwe) and do not meet the criteria for transfer to Appendix I. Recognizing the efforts made by Southern African countries to sustainably manage their elephant population and combat poaching, those countries should better be encouraged to pursue their efforts.
- conjectures 10y agoI read the first one as meaning: antiques. The second seems like they are taking a technical interpretation of some rules without looking at the bigger picture.
- deadowl 10y agoIn Vermont (US) it was the NRA that opposed it, and I imagine the situation was because big game hunting has long been romanticized by the rich and powerful, who basically tell their organizations to oppose it based on marginal cherry-picked issues like the keys on antique pianos.
- csn 10y agoWhat other interests should the EU have on this topic? Genuinely interested in people's views.
- Someone 10y agoThe PDF (http://ec.europa.eu/transparency/regdoc/rep/1/2016/EN/1-2016-437-EN-F1-1-ANNEX-2.PDF http://ec.europa.eu/transparency/regdoc/rep/1/2016/EN/1-2016...) says: "Oppose the transfer to Appendix I of the populations of BW, NA, ZA, ZW. These four national populations have an increasing population trend (tbc for Zimbabwe) and do not meet the criteria for transfer to Appendix I. Recognizing the efforts made by Southern African countries to sustainably manage their elephant population and combat poaching, those countries should better be encouraged to pursue their efforts" The PDF also says, for Namibia and Zimbabwe: "Given the continuous high levels of elephant poaching and illegal ivory trade, it is premature to agree on a resumption of trade. The efforts by Namibia for wildlife conservation and to combat poaching and illegal trade should nonetheless be recognised and further encouraged." So, as is often the case, a nuanced statement by the EU that gets misrepresented in the press. Moving elephants to appendix I would make it harder or even prohibit South Africa, Botswana, Namibia and Zimbabwe, countries where the elephant population grows, to shoot down elephants to keep their total number under control. What the EU says basically is that those countries should be allowed to shoot elephants (in theory, that would give them the freedom to kill all 'their' elephants, but they aren't that stupid, as it would kill tourism, too.) but that Botswana and Namibia shouldn't be allowed to sell the ivory to (partly) make up for the costs they make for protecting their wildlife. South Africa and Botswana apparently are deemed to have poaching under control. I guess this means there are ways to determine where an elephant lived from its teeth. That's not surprising, given that we can do that for humans, too.
- cmdrfred 10y agoI see why GB left. Is there any legitimate purpose for ivory besides aesthetic?
- TazeTSchnitzel 10y agoWhy do you assume the UK disagrees with this stance? They might have lobbied for it.
- jdimov10 10y agoJust a hint of what the EU is really made of.
- Xorlev 10y agoIs it better to surface the trade and regulate it, or push it underground?
- adamnemecek 10y agoThere isn't a black market for everything. E.g. how big is the black market for Kinder Surprise eggs in the US? How big is the market for leaded gasoline?
- Xorlev 10y agoPeople don't often decorate their homes and make other items out of leaded gasoline or kinder surprise eggs. Luxury items are created from ivory.
- adamnemecek 10y agoRight. There isn't that big of a market for luxury items.
- adamnemecek 10y agoYou guys should consider donating to the International Anti-Poaching Foundation[0][1] which fights these poachers. The founder, Damien Mander[2], is an Australian ex spec-ops sniper who is using his military experience to train the park rangers since they, unlike the poachers, tend to be poorly equipped and trained as well as understaffed. There is also the David Sheldrick Wildlife Trust[3][4] which takes care of elephant and rhino orphans (most of them are orphans due to poaching). For $50 a year, you can become a sponsor of a particular orphan and they'll send you photos and updates about how your sponsored animal is doing. You can for example sponsor this little fella [5][6]. It's a great gift. [0] http://www.iapf.org/ http://www.iapf.org/ [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Anti-Poaching_Fou.. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Anti-Poaching_Fou.... [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Damien_Mander http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Damien_Mander [3] http://www.sheldrickwildlifetrust.org http://www.sheldrickwildlifetrust.org [4] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Sheldrick_Wildlife_Trust http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Sheldrick_Wildlife_Trust [5] http://www.sheldrickwildlifetrust.org/asp/orphan_profile.asp?N=318 http://www.sheldrickwildlifetrust.org/asp/orphan_profile.asp... [6] http://instagram.com/p/sigT3IAUKb http://instagram.com/p/sigT3IAUKb P.S. You should subscribe to http://reddit.com/r/babyelephantgifs http://reddit.com/r/babyelephantgifs and http://reddit.com/r/babyrhinogifs http://reddit.com/r/babyrhinogifs for a daily dose of adorable pachyderm content.
- okreallywtf 10y agoThat first link 404's btw, removing /en/ seems to fix it.
- adamnemecek 10y agoFixed thanks.
- Ophiom 10y agoSimirarly for the fifth, did it get truncated? I think it is supposed to be: http://www.sheldrickwildlifetrust.org/asp/orphan_profile.asp?N=318 http://www.sheldrickwildlifetrust.org/asp/orphan_profile.asp...
- mbroshi 10y agoThe article mostly describes how elephants populations have been dwindling with the ban in place. I do not see any statistics supporting the view that elephant populations will dwindle any more quickly/slowly without a ban.
- pmontra 10y agoThere have been periods with and without bans. Elephant population decreased faster when there were no bans. http://www.iol.co.za/dailynews/opinion/controversial-call-for-unrestricted-commercial-exports-2043369 http://www.iol.co.za/dailynews/opinion/controversial-call-fo... "About half the continental population was lost in the decade before the Appendix I listing in 1989, and a dramatic spike occurred again after a “one-off” ivory sale in 2008 to China and Japan." "Cites [Appendix I] saved African elephants from certain extinction 27 years ago by listing them on Appendix I. It ended the poaching crisis and elephant populations began to recover, until their protection under Cites was weakened, causing poaching to escalate again."
- jbmorgado 10y agoThat piece fails to address that the reason is that the Western nations stopped financing so much the anti poaching enforcement in african countries. It was not exactly the lift of the ban, it was that Western nations decided that the problem was controlled, or that it was time that African nation started taking care of the poaching problem themselves and cut funding.
- jswny 10y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong but I can't imagine that the legitimate cases for the use of ivory/elephant products are economically significant at all to the EU. Because of this, I'm confused as to why they would be treading so lightly and avoiding a complete ban.
- jbmorgado 10y agoIt's not about that of course. It's that the EU feels like just banning without ivory trade without a support network behind in Africa will just lead to even more devastating black market ivory trade. We can see how bad the previous bans went and how the wild life suffers in those same African countries that already banned poaching... but where the elephants keep dying awfully because the local governments are corrupt and let the poaching continue gaining even higher margins after the ban. It's exactly that the EU wants to avoid.
- adamnemecek 10y ago> how the wild life suffers in those same African countries that already banned poaching Which specific countries are you talking about?
- jbob2000 10y agoJust to play devil's advocate; If there was a total ban, then it would go underground and nobody can really watch what's happening with the ivory trade. There is already A LOT of ivory out there, it's not like it goes bad or anything, so you'd be forcing estates to go underground or destroy it if it weren't regulated. I think it's a complex situation, not as simple as saying "elephants died, therefore bad".
- adamnemecek 10y agoThis is silly. By allowing trade, you are sustaining a market for it. Furthermore, a legal market would be a cover for the illegal market.
- duaneb 10y agoYes, the only reason why child pornography is still around is we haven't bothered to make it completely illegal yet.
- adamnemecek 10y agoI mean, yeah, you will never get completely rid of anything. Yet I think that child pornography is less common in society than illegal ivory (ever been to China town in SF and NYC?)
- duaneb 10y ago> Yet I think that child pornography is less common in society than illegal ivory This could just as easily be from social stigma than from laws. I can't think of anything more socially repulsive. The point is, restricting legality is not necessarily the best way to address a problem—it is just the easy way for people to throw money at a problem.
- wyldfire 10y agoBut the market sustains based primarily on demand, not legality.
- marcoperaza 10y agoIt seems that the Europeans are concerned about the black market. The same reason why the War on Drugs is so ineffective. Banning the market without effectively controlling supply is a disaster.
- modoc 10y agoThere's already a strong black market poaching and ivory trade. When Colorado legalized weed, it was grown legally in controlled environments. Legalized ivory trade doesn't magically make the killing of elephants disappear...
- marcoperaza 10y agoBanning it doesn't either. And the worst situation is where the poaching happens anyway due to lack of enforcement in Africa, and the trade is also in the hands of criminals elsewhere.
- UnoriginalGuy 10y ago> ITT: People who understand why the War on Drugs is ineffective but can't fathom why pushing all ivory trade into the black market could have similar results. With all due respect, "ITT:" (In This Thread) is hardly constructive. First off you cannot generalise all of the replies already made, and secondly you cannot know the direction of future replies or how the conversation will evolve. If you want to make a point comparing the ivory trade to the war on drugs, that's great, it might generate some thoughtful discussion. But this "ITT" nonsense from Reddit is just that, nonsense.
- marcoperaza 10y agoYeah, you're totally right. Edited.
- detaro 10y agoLegalizing drugs would not reduce the amount of drug plants killed (=harvested). Which is the goal of ivory market control. If it is easy to legally create as much material as is needed, legal trade works. If you can't meet demand legally, there will be a black market.
- atomicbeanie 10y agoSo very frustrating. We've done the same thing in this country when Europe had it together. Can't Africa get a break from our first world bureaucracy's?
- lumberjack 10y agoIn other news, the EC is trying all kinds of soaps to wash the grease off their hands.
- zbjornson 10y agoI fully support anti-poaching measures, but what this article doesn't discuss is the effect of a total ban on trade of existing ivory products. Old musical instruments (pipe organs, old pianos, some wind instruments) with any ivory in them (e.g. decorative inlays or the key slips on a 1000+ kg organ) cannot have their ivory parts repaired and the instrument cannot be sold under a complete trade ban, which is a shame and a waste. This came up with the US Forestry and Wildlife Service recently when they also proposed a complete ban. There are a handful of folks who recover ivory from art/antiques exactly for restoring other products without resulting in new poaching. Edit: see this article, which was just updated today, about the effect of ivory bans on musicians and instruments http://americanorchestras.org/advocacy-government/travel-with-instruments/endangered-species-material/ivory-ban-impact-on-orchestras.html http://americanorchestras.org/advocacy-government/travel-wit...
- uptown 10y agoThey can be repaired. They just cannot be repaired with ivory.
- ticviking 10y agomeaning they cannot be restored
- zymhan 10y agoWell, okay, that's a trade off we as a society have decided to make. Many orphaned elephants send their condolences for your piano.
- kafkaesq 10y agoMeaning we have to choose our priorities. As if there's any contest, in this case.
- wavefunction 10y agoit does mean that, yes.
- 10y ago
- jpollock 10y agoWhat's stopping ivory farms from being opened in countries with local demand for ivory?
- dpark 10y agoExpense. Raising elephants/rhinos is probably extremely expensive, especially when you consider how little ivory you get from an elephant raised for, say, 10 years. Poaching is only lucrative because the poachers don't bear the cost of raising the livestock. Also if you tried to establish a farm where you raised elephants for ivory, the moral outrage would almost certainly get you shut down, with an new law if no existing ones covered it. The "countries with local demand for ivory" are in general countries that have made ivory trade largely illegal already, because most of the population agrees it's pretty repugnant.
- giarc 10y agoNot to mention that creating a farm for elephants would make a great target for poachers. No one would take on that risk of raising an elephant for 25 years, only to have a poacher kill it and take the ivory (and all the elephants value).
- kentosi 10y agoWhat's so good about ivory? Why can't other non-animal-based materials be used? I don't see the appeal to go to such great lengths to kill an animal for its horn/tusks.
- soyiuz 10y agoIt is a cultural thing. In some countries the horn is ground up and used for (pseudo)medical purposes.
- Qantourisc 10y agoSimple solution: if you can't hammer out the details of what you really want in time, extend the current one.
- Millennium 10y agoI'm coming to the conclusion that a better long-term solution might be more along the lines of what Pembient[1] is doing: devise methods to produce ivory and related materials in the lab, ensure that it is indistinguishable from the "organic" stuff, and then flood the market into oblivion. Anti-poaching methods are obviously needed to fill in the gaps while technology catches up, and should be continued or perhaps even escalated. But the most effective weapon against poachers could prove to be the very markets that draw people to poaching in the first place. Remove poaching's feasibility as a lucrative profession, and the profession dies. [1]: http://pembient.com http://pembient.com