12 ms·
Judges Rely on a Flawed $2 Drug Test That Puts Innocent People Behind Bars
- guard-of-terra 10y ago> The crumb from the floor > Albritton was charged with felony drug possession WTF guys, seriously? Possession of a crumb on a floor? It's not a drug test that's faulty here.
- rayiner 10y agoThank you, 1990s!
- dsugarman 10y ago"Suppose a drug test is 99% sensitive and 99% specific. That is, the test will produce 99% true positive results for drug users and 99% true negative results for non-drug users. Suppose that 0.5% of people are users of the drug. If a randomly selected individual tests positive, what is the probability that he is a user?"[0] 33.2% thanks to Bayes Theorem. If you have a test with 99% accuracy and 1 in 200 people use the drug, someone testing positive more likely than not is not using the drug. If the drug is less popular, that percentage drops further at a fast rate. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bayes%27_theorem#Drug_testing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bayes%27_theorem#Drug_testing
- phonon 10y agoExcept you are testing people who are specifically under suspicion, not the general population. The concern here is that it does not appear that these tests are anywhere near 99%/99%...maybe it should be good enough to arrest someone on the scene, but a lab test should be the immediate follow-up, EVERY TIME, not "well maybe we'll do it when we go to trial."
- runako 10y agoNB: In America, people are often under suspicion simply due to their ethnicity. QED this isn't good enough to arrest people in America.
- akiselev 10y agoBased on my experience with the police in Los Angeles and the article, it seems that they are basically just randomly testing the general population, except maybe with a little filter. The heuristics cops use for "suspicion" are often very biased and caught up in socioeconomics or racism. I wouldn't be surprised if their filters reduced the sample pool by a factor of 2 or 3 which I don't think is enough for probabilities that justify evidence "beyond the shadow of a doubt"
- bryondowd 10y agoThe legal standard is beyond reasonable doubt, not beyond the shadow of a doubt. It's intentionally left fuzzy to allow prosecution in cases where absolute certainty is impossible, but we as society still need to have a decent chance of prosecuting offenders. We try to minimize the number of innocents who are wrongfully convicted, but there's always going to be some, otherwise there would be entire classes of crimes that would be almost completely unenforceable, due to their nature. That said, this article made me sick. It's obvious that the system is failing here, probably due to a combination of factors, including a lack of understanding of the accuracy of these tests as well as the filtering used to select who and what gets tested. Even if your test was 99.99% accurate, if officers spend all day gathering crumbs from people's cars and submitting them, and you end up with hundreds of millions of innocent samples to thousands of actual drug samples, you wind up with tens of thousands of false positives. So what we really need is corroborating evidence to get a sample set more skewed toward actual positives. Or just give up and stop trying to enforce possession laws.
- sixothree 10y agoI don't consider it reasonable that 1 in 100, 1 in 10000 people would falsely end up in jail.
- Jtsummers 10y ago"Under suspicion"? A traffic stop is sufficient to garner suspicion. Not looking high, not acting high, just being stopped for any ordinary traffic violation is enough.
- michaelmrose 10y agoIf the effect of getting arrested can in and of itself be life destroying then perhaps its far more rational to keep the evidence for further testing and act if and only a real lab finds the evidence compelling. If the offender is from out of town and skips that is unfortunate but not as unfortunate as wrecking peoples lives.
- TheCoelacanth 10y agoExactly. Someone not well informed of probability will often assume that it is 99%[0] but the actual probability can be much lower than that when the actual incidence of drug use is low. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prosecutor%27s_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prosecutor%27s_fallacy
- mikeash 10y agoLooking at it the other way, even if you have a 99% chance that the positive result is correct, is a 1% rate of sending innocent people to jail really acceptable?
- LoSboccacc 10y agoOr with some context if you put the usa population under test you'd get 3 MILLION innocent convicts. small percentages adds up scary fast over continents
- justicezyx 10y agoOther factors should be considered. For example, it is not a random sampling. Polices target those who are statistically more likely to be positive, according to their empirical or historical statistics.
- mikeash 10y agoI think that's already accounted for in my hpothetical, as those are factors that might bring a 33.2% rate up to 99%.
- bryondowd 10y agoDepends how good of a filter the police are using. Even if they are only targeting people who are 10 times as likely to be users as the general population in the above example, that only brings the accuracy to about 84%. And I'd wager their filtering isn't that good. What exactly are they using to determine who is a likely user? Are those people really more likely at all, and if so, how much? I expect it would be highly optimistic to even assume a person targeted by police is even three times as likely as the general population to be in possession of drugs, which would only be about 60%
- analog31 10y agoIndeed, the person could be less likely. From what I've read, affluent whites have the highest rates of illegal drug use, but the police direct their enforcement efforts towards blacks.
- forrestthewoods 10y agoI wonder how statistically accurate USADA drug tests are. What are the odds of a false positive?
- nl 10y agoVery low. A second sample is kept and tested separately in the event of a positive. I'm not aware of any cases of false positives because of test errors, and there have been many very well funded challenges.
- gaur 10y agoIt's amazing how often a simple Venn diagram or probability tree can cut through the fog and deliver a clear answer to a statistical question. This is slightly off topic, but I can never remember what "specificity" and "sensitivity" are supposed to mean in this context. I wish people (Wikipedia editors included) would stop using these opaque words, and instead just say in plain English what probabilities they're referring to. It's almost as bad as "type 1 error" and "type 2 error", which are terms that are actively hostile to building an understanding of statistical inference.
- coaxial 10y agoI find this website[1] pretty good for explaining maths and statistics concepts in a much more accessible way. [1] http://betterexplained.com/articles/an-intuitive-and-short-explanation-of-bayes-theorem/ http://betterexplained.com/articles/an-intuitive-and-short-e...
- k7wqcyfgmu 10y agoI find "sensitive" and "specific" to be very clear descriptors. If the test is not specific, it will detect things that are not specifically the drug. If the test is not sensitive enough, it might miss the drug.
- coaxial 10y agoThis is very interesting and important to understand. I'm wondering how often has this been successfully argued? Surely a lawyer would have heard about this effect and be able to get the evidence thrown away given the flawed accuracy premise? With this rationale, I suppose lawyers would also advise their clients to not enter a plea bargain agreement? Genuinely curious, hoping someone could shed light on this.
- bobwaycott 10y agoBut it says 99%! That means it must be true because there's only a 1% chance it's not true! /s
- fisherjeff 10y agoI don't understand why this wouldn't treated like a field sobriety test - if it's positive, just bring in the suspect and the sample. If, after subjecting it to a more accurate and rigorous test like the mass spectrometer mentioned in the article, it's negative, the suspect should be free to go. How something like this isn't happening long before a plea bargain or trial enters the picture is just beyond me.
- refurb 10y agoI was confused by that as well. Field tests are unlikely to hold up in court. Most labs will re-tested suspected drugs using some pretty reliable techniques (HPLC-MS, GC-MS, NMR). Otherwise, all a lawyer has to do is say "Yes it could be cocaine, but it could also be one of these 80 other compounds that produce positive results on the field test".
- tedunangst 10y agoField tests aren't admissible in court already.
- stuaxo 10y agoPlea bargaining needs to go, it's letting evidence that wouldn't stand up in court send people to prison.
- MichaelBurge 10y agoAlaska did this, and I don't believe their courts were too overburdened afterwards.
- hx87 10y agoProbably because plea bargaining encourages prosecutors to go after cases that otherwise wouldn't be winnable.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nommm-nommm 10y agoI believe plea bargaining has its place in the Justice system, however abuse of plea bargains has to go.
- tremon 10y agoMaybe simple suggestion: plea bargains shouldn't be put on a criminal record. If the prosecution doesn't care enough about your crime to lead you before a judge, you shouldn't have to carry that burden around either.
- maxerickson 10y agoA judge accepts the plea.
- 10y ago
- brett40324 10y ago"74 percent of the convicted didn’t possess any drugs at the time of their arrest" Whats the solution here? This is an embarassing failure of the justice system and all involved. Why is it so acceptable for them to do such a bad job?
- bryondowd 10y agoSounds to me like the simplest solution and biggest failure (aside from the whole concept of criminalization of possession in the first place) is in our public defender system, which seems to be a much wider-reaching problem. The fact seems to be that people who can't afford a proper attorney just aren't getting even marginally acceptable representation in many cases. We need public defenders with the time, resources, and incentives to actually provide a reasonable defense and legal advice to people who can't afford a lawyer. In this case, it seems like a decent lawyer would be able to hear out the woman's story, and say something like "Hey, the lab will confirm the substance, so if you're really innocent, you should hold on, because a felony charge will ruin your life a lot longer than sitting in jail awaiting trial would." Instead, I'm guessing the lawyer had ten minutes to spend on this case before he had to move on to the next one, so he can't really do more than push the plea deal and move along, and there's no significant incentive for him to do more anyway. In fact, he'd probably get canned if he stopped to take appropriate time with each client, because then he wouldn't have time to even get to all of them.
- brett40324 10y agoI agree. The responsibility should be that of the defender, prosecuter, and judge to verify additional chemical tests prior to a plea or trial. The state prosecution should be required to back up any substance tests in order to press charges. This way, the police can still do their job (although a certifiable training should be required and regulated for the field tests), while having an AGILE turnaround on immediate test verification analysis - which should be done by a court laboratory technician within days of initial arrest.
- rayiner 10y agoThe field drug tests are indeed a scam, but parts of this article don't pass the smell test. E.g. > Albritton was escorted to a dark wood-paneled courtroom. A guilty plea requires the defendant to make a series of statements that serve as a confession and to waive multiple constitutional rights. The judge, Vanessa Velasquez, walked her through the recitation, Albritton recalls, but never asked why she couldn’t stop crying long enough to speak in sentences. She had managed to say the one word that mattered: “guilty.” This is called a "plea colloquy." An example is here: http://www.vawd.uscourts.gov/media/1966/guiltypleacolloquy.pdf http://www.vawd.uscourts.gov/media/1966/guiltypleacolloquy.p.... As you can see, it's a conversation in which the judge must assure herself that the defendant understands the charges against her, understands the consequences, and that the prosecution has facts it is prepared to prove at trial (see question 31). At least in federal courts, these are very detailed and take quite some time. I don't know how things are done in Harris County, but an insufficient plea colloquy is grounds for having the guilty plea set aside later, so judges have strong incentives to ensure their colloquies are adequate. So not only is it true that "guilty" is the "only word that mattered," the article's implication that the judge is only interested in hearing the word "guilty" is totally at odds with not only the judge's incentives, but the prosecutor's. What "tough on crime" prosecutor looking to rack up convictions would leave the door open for a conviction to be vacated just because the defendant couldn't get through the colloquy?
- dmoy 10y agoI'm not sure, they might if they don't think it's likely that random poor people they pick up are going to try for appeal. If we accept the premise here, these are already innocent people being coerced into pleading guilty.
- runako 10y ago> her court-appointed defense attorney Poor defendants don't often get convictions vacated. The judge knew there was very little risk that the proceedings would go beyond the plea. If she had a private attorney, this charge might have been dismissed.
- rayiner 10y ago
- mslate 10y agoWhy is the price of the test relevant?
- tedunangst 10y agoThere's a roundabout implication that perhaps there is a $5 test that's not flawed, but the government is too stingy to pay for it.
- gaur 10y agoOr even worse, government officials like the false positives because more people can then be funneled into the prison system. The fact that the test is cheap is just a bonus.
- 24gttghh 10y agoOr if we were to follow Hanlon's Razor, they're just inept. However, the article talks about Justice Department seminars where: >In its curriculum, the technology center states that field tests help authorities by “removing the need for extensive laboratory analysis,” because “the field test may factor into obtaining an immediate plea agreement.”
- dredmorbius 10y agoThe fact that the test is cheap is a key feature. 33% positive rate, $5 a pop. After six tests (stop'n'frisk'n'test), you've got 90% chance of convictable evidence on any given party.
- dredmorbius 10y agoFor five bucks the government buys an ironclad "we can toss at least 1/3 of those tested into the clink long-long time". Per round. Someone tests free, test 'em again for another $5. $30 (six rounds of tests) buys you a 90% chance of convictable evidence. That's a pretty sweet deal, no?
- pmarreck 10y agoI can't see this sort of thing without plugging http://www.innocenceproject.org/ http://www.innocenceproject.org/ (disclaimer: I donate every month). Here's their Twitter: https://twitter.com/innocence https://twitter.com/innocence
- exolymph 10y agoThank you for the reminder to add them to my monthly donation roster.
- dewster 10y agoDrilling down, past the entire war on drugs nonsense, past the perverse incentives of plea bargaining, the base problem is our old testament focus on meting out punishment rather than on rehabilitation. If I kill someone there's probably something wrong with me, and it's in everyone's best interests to repair me. If I know that someone I care about is going to kill someone, I should be able to turn them over to the authorities without having to worry that they will almost certainly be abused and returned in worse shape. Having the term "fuck you in the ass prison" in the common vocabulary and used semi-humorously or as a reference to the normal functioning of the criminal justice system is exceedingly troubling.
- kefka 10y ago> Having the term "fuck you in the ass prison" in the common vocabulary and used semi-humorously or as a reference to the normal functioning of the criminal justice system is exceedingly troubling. Its a rape joke. And that's just as disgusting as making fun of the lady who was raped behind a dumpster. Except, these are usually men who are raped. And they "deserved" it, by whatever crime the were found guilty of.
- bdcravens 10y ago> I should be able to turn them over to the authorities without having to worry that they will almost certainly be abused and returned in worse shape Problem being that most people live in a fantasy world where those bad people would never return.
- busyant 10y agoI agree with everything you said, but I feel that a large part of the population enjoys judging and punishing people. It's a large and dark part of human nature. There is a secondary problem as well: true rehabilitation seems incredibly difficult. I think we should strive for rehabilitation, but the combination of human nature and the difficulty of making people better gets us where we are.
- rev_bird 10y ago>incredibly difficult Not to mention very expensive. People hate the idea of spending $50,000 a year making a rapist into a better person when the government won't pay for their kids' college instead.
- Justin_K 10y agoBetween this kind of stuff and civil asset forfeiture, I'm really disgusted at what our legal system has become. Let's even throw in red light tickets as a bonus. All of this crap comes down building a money machine for the governments that are here to serve us. When will we have a leader with the ability to end the madness?
- habosa 10y ago"It is better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer" [0] This could not be less true in today's America. I encourage everyone here to read The New Jim Crow (and books like it). Then you'll see how deep the mass incarceration problem is. 0 -https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_formulation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_formulation
- andrewfong 10y ago"Interestingly, we also found that Albritton had pleaded guilty to a 2008 misdemeanor, a D.U.I. conviction in Louisiana, despite breathalyzer results showing her blood-alcohol level at 0.0. When we asked her about this, she said that she had caused a collision by pulling onto the wrong side of a two-lane highway, and because she was guilty of that, she did not protest the other charges; she’s still unable to explain why she confessed to a crime there was no evidence she committed." --- This. We place too much trust in confessions.