4 ms·
You know the whole painting business is a scam when the name of the person who painted the painting matters way more than whether the painting is beautiful or n
by cm2187 10y ago
You know the whole painting business is a scam when the name of the person who painted the painting matters way more than whether the painting is beautiful or not...
First world disputes. Not enough gold and diamonds in this world for people to spend their money on something futile. They need to create new "rare commodities", more tulips. Little to do with art.
- Nadya 10y agoYou would be a huge fan of 'Onement VI' or 'The Voice of Fire' by Barnett Newman. I think the man is a genius. I think his paintings are...well...the paintings speak for themselves, like Mr. Newman says.
- cm2187 10y agoOr Klein's monochrome. Actually I am less appaled by modern art than by the exercise of using random painting as a form of commodity to store value. Like keeping some paintings in a safe like if it was a gold bar. In a way everyone likes going shopping. What people like is spending too much money, not so much that they ruin themselves but enough that it still hurts. That's why people who cannot afford luxury products will still buy something small in a luxury shop. But how do you get that satisfaction when you have a billion in your bank account? Comes Mr Artist, or often Mr Art Dealer (or both) who will create a new rare commodity for you. Art is good, you don't have to justify it. In fact any critic of art is an uneducated idiot who lacks imagination and sensitivity. So Mr Art Dealer will sell you a painting for a few dozen millions, just enough that it still hurts you and provides you with the satisfaction to do shopping. I am not a socialist but it does feel like there is too much money in the system...
- dredmorbius 10y agoThere are entire classes of goods which serve as assets or stores of wealth rather than as goods in their own right. These require some (though not necessarily all) of the features of money: utility/value, portability, indestructibility, homogeneity, divisibility, stability, cognizability. What fine arts offer is (relative) indestructabilty (they don't simply fall apart hanging on a wall), they have a high creation cost -- workfactor, and particularly if of a dead artist, cannot be created again, though that depends on being able to detect forgeries. Art lacks homogeneity and divisibility, but with auctions it is relatively liquid and can be recognized ("cognizability") as a thing having value. These aren't wealth themselves -- the value is imbued by the market. But they are vehicles for moving wealth. Say, like stock options or Bitcoin.
- cm2187 10y agoBut there is something intrinsic in gold. Because of its physical properties (it doesn't oxidise, it's sort of eternal), and it is rare. A painting is more like fiat money. The painter can pull more paintings out of his ass (and some litterally do). And if the painter is dead, we'll find another fashionable genius. Feels more like tulips than gold.
- Natanael_L 10y agoTrading cards, really. In particular limited editions. The two are very similar overall even if they're typically in very different price classes.
- dwaltrip 10y agoYou don't think people inherently value art & beauty? That would be the "intrinsic" value of the painting. Now, if we were really getting down to it, I would argue there is no "intrinsic" value for gold (or anything else). It's only worth what value different people may assign to it, which depends on entirely on the historical, cultural, and technological context in which we live, and varies greatly from person to person. Sure, there are some aspects or properties of objects for which there is relatively high amounts of agreement about the valuation, however that doesn't make those properties or their valuations "intrinsic". And of course, there will never be 100% agreement about anything.
- cm2187 10y agoWell, that's my point. If beauty was really the reason for it being worth that, I could understand, but it is not, it is only about who made the painting.
- dredmorbius 10y agoWhat, exactly, do you mean by "intrinsic value"? That's not (necessarily) a trick question. I've been digging at the matter, and there's considerable dispute. W.F. Lloyd, 1833, states that "all value is relative", with Smith and Jevons making similar statements in their own works. http://socserv2.socsci.mcmaster.ca/%7Eecon/ugcm/3ll3/lloyd/value http://socserv2.socsci.mcmaster.ca/%7Eecon/ugcm/3ll3/lloyd/v... There's also the question of whether we're talking about any of three attributes, and how comprehensively those are defined: 1. Cost using the definition that all costs are opportunity costs (Krugman, Economics, 2008). 2. Price, here meaning market exchange price or what Smith termed exchange value. 3. Value, which is to say, the utility, affinity, preference, or usefulness to the owner, which Smith termed use value. Market value (price) often bears only a very loose relationship to cost or value. See water/diamonds paradox, externalities, or environmental services and their value, cost, and price. https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/48rd02/cost_value_price_money_and_emergy_developing/ https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/48rd02/cost_va...
- megablast 10y agoSo not much different to cars, clothes, restaurants, almost anything.
- espadrine 10y agoCar purchases are about more than the product: durability, warranty and availability matter. The same goes for clothes. Restaurants are about the experience and health reputation. While I may purchase a lesser shirt from a known brand when a superior one was at the same price from a street shop, I may be justified in that choice because I cannot know in advance that the better shirt is as durable. I may even purchase an Arduino when a cheaper Chinese replica has the same specs, in order to contribute to their R&D. Of course, there will be some to knowingly spend on lesser products for fame's sake. But I'm not convinced this is the case here. Firstly, the owner may have been told he could make a fortune, and spent more than he could afford hoping to make that money back tenfold. Secondly, some markets act as implicit international currencies, such as gold, and tangible art. This is similar to owning a forged €500 bill.
- SixSigma 10y agoProvenance is highly valued in many real world objects. For instance The 10 most expensive guitars ever sold http://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2016/02/11/the-10-most-expensive-guitars-ever-sold-in-pictures/ http://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2016/02/11/the-10-most-e...