2 ms·
It's definitely hyperbole in a sense because Safari is certainly nowhere near the Enterprise monoculture that IE once had, but it's a fair comparison not in any
by WorldMaker 10y ago
It's definitely hyperbole in a sense because Safari is certainly nowhere near the Enterprise monoculture that IE once had, but it's a fair comparison not in any way to deride the work that Safari does, but to point out the things that Safari could do better to learn from past mistakes to help the web and web developers.
I think it's important to make the distinction between Safari and iOS Safari. It's iOS Safari that is the most comparable to the issues with IE in the past, particularly IE6:
- Updating it is tied to iOS releases, which in turn is tied to hardware model. Thus real world usage of iOS Safari drastically lags behind "Safari latest" as users stick to hardware that works and for various reasons cannot/ upgrade iOS.
- Safari on the iOS is as much as possible intended to be a monoculture on iOS devices.
- iOS still has enough marketshare and share of total browser users and to a lot of people the "smartphone" is still nearly synonymous with "iphone" and "tablet" with "ipad". (That's a lessening concern these days with Android doing well enough, but it was definitely a big problem in early "mobile website design".) So web developers need to develop with it in mind, sometimes from an "iOS first" mentality when their businesses have invested much into iOS hardware. (Some businesses do have an iOS mobile device monoculture and probably will for several years to come.)
That last issue is the one where the comparison to IE has been the scariest in the past and the one where Safari will likely leave its mark on the web "geological strata" in a similar way to classic versions of IE: there will be some things like notable -webkit prefixed CSS rules that will last a long, long time on the web and the other browsers have simply had to adopt checking for the -webkit version. (Edge and Firefox both have lists of -webkit CSS rules they follow.)
The reason to make the comparison is to especially remind web developers to test outside their personal monoculture bubble. To remember that there are mobile devices that aren't iOS out there and there are many users out there not using Safari (or Chrome or whatever the flavor of the month is among developers) as their daily drivers.
"Safari is the new IE" is hyperbole, but it's useful hyperbole.