3 ms·
> Offensive, but, given two PoC shot dead in 48 hours by police, certainly not unfounded. > Racism is deeply embedded in (US) police, and it deserves to be cal
by CydeWeys 10y ago
> Offensive, but, given two PoC shot dead in 48 hours by police, certainly not unfounded.
> Racism is deeply embedded in (US) police, and it deserves to be called out.
Ian Murdock is white. This isn't a "PoC" issue, and the colloquial slavery expressions are out of place and offensive. Yes, racism is an issue with US police, but it is unrelated to this occurrence and to this conversation.
And secondly, Ian was violently attempting to break into a neighbor's apartment by bashing down the front door. What exactly do you think should happen in such an instance? I'll tell you what I'd do -- I'd want the police to come as quickly as possible and deal with it, using whatever force is necessary to stop the in-progress home invasion, because if an intruder breaks through my door I have no choice but to shoot them until they're stopped, and I don't want that on my conscience. I don't have the skills or training to determine between mentally deranged people and killers, nor could I effectively or safely use non-lethal methods of self-defense.
I understand the points you're trying to make, but none of them are applicable to this specific situation, in which the police actions were entirely warranted. Put yourself in the shoes of the person whose home was being broken into, think about how scared that would make you especially if the attacker was a physically stronger person than you are. We need the police to stop violent crimes in progress, and they have to use violence in response. And hell, given that they didn't seriously injure him, it sounds like they used the right proportional amount of force as was necessary. Unlike possibly the two high profile fatal shootings in the news the past two days.
You've got to pick your battles. I don't think the Ian Murdock case is a good one.
- geggam 10y agothe Racism cops have isnt black or white... its blue and not blue.... only poor people run into this and rare is it you get to see them post to HN / other social media in a way they are deemed relevant
- angelo 10y ago> Ian was violently attempting to break into a neighbor's apartment by bashing down the front door. That is simply not correct.
- DanBC 10y ago> And secondly, Ian was violently attempting to break into a neighbor's apartment by bashing down the front door. What exactly do you think should happen in such an instance? I'll tell you what I'd do -- I'd want the police to come as quickly as possible and deal with it, using whatever force is necessary to stop the in-progress home invasion, because if an intruder breaks through my door I have no choice but to shoot them until they're stopped, and I don't want that on my conscience. I don't have the skills or training to determine between mentally deranged people and killers, nor could I effectively or safely use non-lethal methods of self-defense. Jesus fucking christ. Here's what I did when a burglar Climbed up scaffolding on the building next door, climbed onto my roof, kicked a roof-access hatch in and gained entrance to my loft space. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9871331 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9871331 No killing needed.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoMaybe different from a violent angry large man battering down your door just to get at you? Offers of tea are reputedly less effective in that case.
- DanBC 10y agoI didn't know it was different when I offered him a cup of tea. He'd already kicked in the roof hatch and was inside the house. I'd have done the same if he'd been kicking the door. > Offers of tea are reputedly less effective in that case. No, they're not less effective, and this might by why the US police kill hundreds of people each year, especially people with mental illness. You might want to read some of the de-escalation stuff coming from the English NHS at the moment. Lots of it comes from forensic settings (where people are there with a criminal justice involvement) or settings for people with behaviour seen as challenging -- exactly the kind of behaviour Ian Murdoch is described as exhibiting. Obviously "kill the patient" isn't an option. But people still talk about the need to reduce frequency of seclusion and length of each episode of seclusion; or about reducing the frequency of rapid tranquilisation and reducing unplanned injection into buttocks vs managed oral administration. Positive and Proactive Care: Reducing the need for restrictive interventions:https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/positive-and-proactive-care-reducing-restrictive-interventions https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/positive-and-proa... Physical Restraint in Crisis care: https://www.mind.org.uk/media/197120/physical_restraint_final_web_version.pdf https://www.mind.org.uk/media/197120/physical_restraint_fina... Violence and aggression, short term management in mental health, health, and community settings: https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng10 https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng10 None of this guidance says "escalate it".