4 ms·
Welcome to the CRISPR Zoo
- entee 10y agoThis is precisely an area where CRISPR can have a huge impact in a fairly short timeline. With animal/crop genetics we often have more understanding for what genetics are important for what feature and how to introduce the CRISPR machinery into cells, combined with room for error. Remember that with CRISPR you usually need a whole bunch of cells/embryos etc. because the recombination step after cutting the DNA (CRISPR just cuts) may not always succeed as expected. Hard to do that (and unethical) with human embryos, much easier with chickens. That said, we also need to get over the GMO thing. The science is pretty clear that GMOs are not toxic and no worse for the environment than normal crops (in some cases less harmful actually). We should continue to be careful and ethical as we explore this technology, but let's not get distracted by pseudo-scientific fear-mongering on GMO foods.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> The science is pretty clear that GMOs are not toxic Perhaps more precisely, the science is pretty clear that GMO as a method of introducing traits is completely orthogonal to toxicity, environmental harm, and everything else that "GMOs" are blamed for. Particular GMOs may have some of those harms, either inherently or in the agricultural methods and business practices they support (because of the actual regulatory environment, toxicity of the GMO itself is pretty low probability, though), but that's no more true than it is of any other technique of developing new crop traits.
- Zigurd 10y ago> That said, we also need to get over the GMO thing. That, of course, is incontrovertible in that anything that's been domesticated has been genetically manipulated, often to the extent that it can't survive in the wild. It's just a matter of how fast and how precise the manipulation gets with induced mutations, recombinant methods, and CRISPR Cas-9. But to be fair to the anti-GMO people, what they're really complaining about is bad outcomes that are not proximate to GM technology, but are enabled by it, like having herbicide residue on their herbicide-resistant crops, or that are part of commercializing GM technology, like overreaching IP laws.
- thaumasiotes 10y ago> But to be fair to the anti-GMO people, what they're really complaining about is bad outcomes that are not proximate to GM technology, but are enabled by it, like having herbicide residue on their herbicide-resistant crops, or that are part of commercializing GM technology, like overreaching IP laws. No, people with that kind of complaint are a vanishingly small presence among anti-GMO people. What they're really complaining about is that a part-fish part-tomato is contrary to the order of the universe.
- kbenson 10y agoI think the progression was something like this: 1. Advocate: "GMO crops altered to be resistant to herbicides have problems and some people are getting sick!" 2. Advocate: Hmm, that's a mouthful, we'll just say GMO and people will understand. We can also foment fear in GMO in general, which won't hurt us. "GMO crops are making people sick!" 3. Consumer: Woah, this is GMO? But I keep hearing GMO is bad! This became clear to me after the wife of a friend who is a nature educator at a state park posted something about stopping GMO crops. I was confused about what was so bad about GMO crops, so asked. She explained that "GMO crops" refers to GMO engineered crops that are herbicide resistant, and that's what causes the problems. There was a war over terminology at some point, and the side of accuracy lost. This is the outcome. Our educators use terminology that imply a lot of unfounded negative connotations because that's the common parlance, and the public doesn't know how to disambiguate. This is not a new problem. Politicians use this to their benefit on a regular basis. In the meantime, we're all slightly worse off.
- pilom 10y agoCRISPR really does make me believe that someone who lives to be 200+ is alive today. The potential and speed of improvement is so astronomical I can't wait to see the future.
- Dowwie 10y agoThere was a discussion about the culture of secrecy among CRISPR scientists on NPR's On The Media. The show host interviewed a scientist from MIT Media Lab, Kevin Esvelt. Kevin is taking an ethical stand in his field, demanding that the scientific community conduct itself in a transparent, inclusive way. It's one of the reasons why he interviewed. "I want people who ideologically object to the very notion of altering nature in any way-- I would love for those people to take a close look at exactly what my group is working on and proposing to do and try to find anything they can think of that might go wrong. And if they succeed, if they find something we can't invent a way around, and we can't make it safe, then the project has to halt -- and that's as it should be. Right now, scientists do not tell anyone what they are currently doing and planning to do in the laboratory. I think the system would be better if all research was done in the open. Gene drive is the place where we must start. Everyone should have an opportunity to share their concerns and criticism when it comes to technologies that will impact all of us, and we would be foolish to dismiss concerns simply because someone doesn't have a degree." http://www.wnyc.org/story/editing-culture-science-crispr http://www.wnyc.org/story/editing-culture-science-crispr
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- carapace 10y agoI don't have time today to write a fresh response to this so I'm going to just scream for a few minutes and then quote myself from somewhere else: """ I firmly believe that all genetic engineering applications, except for human health-related medical interventions, should be delayed for at least several hundred years. Research, yes, but applications are out of the question for centuries. Anything less stringent is open-ended experimentation on the only biosphere in the known Universe. It is hubris of the rankest sort. Further I believe that this is a scientific view. We know our ignorance is far too vast. The only reasons to use GMOs are hubris and greed. That is it. Either you are a scientific ego-tripper who can't or won't understand that real people have serious reservations about participating in your open-ended genetic experiment, or you just want to make a buck and don't care. If it could be shown that, for some given application of GE, there is absolutely no other alternative to save lives, then that's something. However, I believe we can feed ourselves without GMOs by means of "applied ecology" ("Permaculture" etc.) so there is no call to use GMOs. These doubtless well-meaning scientists are using the reduction of "Vitamin-A deficiencies causing blindness and death in children in the developing world" to insist on a highly controversial technology. It's kind of just as ugly and self-serving as they paint Greenpeace to be. The report from the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine is quoted in the article as saying, "such crops are relatively new and that it is premature to make broad generalizations, positive or negative, about their safety." We know we don't know enough. I don't want to eat your faith. """
- marcoperaza 10y agoI see a lot of fear mongering but zero evidence in your position. What exactly could go wrong? How are those risks different or greater than normal risks that we accept, like certain levels of air pollution or medication whose side effects haven't been studied across multiple generations of progeny?