4 ms·
> Usually people are concerned about maximising prediction accuracy, and never stop to think about what correlations is the model finding down below, and the hu
by AnthonyMouse 10y ago
> Usually people are concerned about maximising prediction accuracy, and never stop to think about what correlations is the model finding down below, and the human biases present in the data annotations.
Because maximizing prediction accuracy is inherently unbiased. Bias is when the predictions made are inaccurate to the detriment of a group of people. If you had a prediction algorithm that functioned using time travel to tell you with 100.0% accuracy who would pay back their loans, there would be a racial disparity in the result, but the cause of it is not the fault of the algorithm.
And you can't fix it there because that's not where the problem is.
Suppose you have a group of 800 white middle managers, 100 white sales clerks and 100 black sales clerks. Clearly the algorithm is going to have a racial disparity in outcome if the middle managers are at 500% of the cutoff and the sales clerks are right on the line, because it will accept all of the middle managers and half of the sales clerks which means it will accept >94% of the white applicants and 50% of the black applicants.
But the source of the disparity is that black people are underrepresented as middle managers and overrepresented as sales clerks. The algorithm is just telling you that. It can't change it.
And inserting bias into the algorithm to "balance" the outcome doesn't actually do that, all you're doing is creating bias against white sales clerks who had previously been on the same footing as black sales clerks. The white middle managers will be unaffected because they're sufficiently far above the cutoff that the change doesn't affect them, even though that they're the source of the imbalance.
- throwawaysocks 10y ago> maximizing prediction accuracy is inherently unbiased This assumes that you're actually maximizing prediction accuracy, rather than taking the easiest route toward sufficiently high predictive power. Not-so-hypothetical: you can invest $N and create a profitable model that (unfairly and inaccurately) discriminates directly based upon race, or you can invest $N*M and create a profitable model that does not discriminate on race (regardless of whether its results are racially equitable). Given the choice, a lot of people will choose the $N approach.
- basseq 10y ago> regardless of whether its results are racially equitable Some would call this discrimination, if not outright racism. As others on this thread have pointed out, at some point the algorithm follows the underlying data, which may also be discriminatory (zip code, etc.).
- tombone12 10y agoYou entirely miss the point! The point is that in supervised learning for example, if you optimize prediction accuracy with respect to your human generated examples, you will get a model that exactly reproduces the racist judgment of the human that generated your training set.
- mcguire 10y agoYes, and you can get similar effects with unsupervised learning if the data set is biased.
- Houshalter 10y agoThats silly though. You should use ground truth of actual outcomes, not predict that useless humans would do. But even then I bet the algorithm would be less racist than the humans, if you don't give them race as a feature.
- hx87 10y agoThen the problem is in the racist human(s), not the algorithm.
- yoo1I 10y agoBut the algorithm enshrines and possibly amplifies it. Or as the old saying goes: > To err is human, to really foul things up requires a computer.
- Symmetry 10y agoHumans have much more potential for racism in making predictions about the future than in judging things that have already happened. So while I agree that racism through biased input data is a problem, I think that even with that problem machines should be substantially less racist in their judgement than the humans they're replacing even if they're not perfect.
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> The point is that in supervised learning for example, if you optimize prediction accuracy with respect to your human generated examples, you will get a model that exactly reproduces the racist judgment of the human that generated your training set. In which case you aren't optimizing prediction accuracy. Prediction accuracy is measured by whether the predictions are true. If you have bias in the predictions which doesn't exist in the actual outcomes then there is money to be made by eliminating it. It seems like the strangest place to put an objection where the profit motive is directly aligned with the desired behavior.