3 ms·
The problem isn't the number of neurons and their connections, but the complexity and diversity of them. There are hundreds of signalling molecules and recepto
by biofox 10y ago
The problem isn't the number of neurons and their connections, but the complexity and diversity of them.
There are hundreds of signalling molecules and receptors that haven't been characterised. Some molecules diffuse over long distances, others are taken up and recycled depending on the local environment. Surrounding non-neuronal cells alter the ionic and metabolic states of networks, and can physically block (or sometimes actively transport) neurotransmitters.
Each neuron type has its own response characteristics (activation function) that can completely change depending on the context. Even different locations on the same neuron have different receptors and transmitters, and can alternate between inhibitory or excitatory functions.
To give an example of the difficulty, we've had a complete map of the neural connectivity of C. elegans for 30 years, which consists of only 302 neurons, and we still don't know how many of the cells and circuits function.
I think the only solution will be high-throughput phenotyping. Test cell types and mutants under different circumstances until we have a deep-enough understand of these systems and their interactions to model them.
It takes humans far too long to do experiments. We need more lab automation.
- intrasight 10y agoGood point about the automation. Perhaps then in my lifetime.
- whamlastxmas 10y agoI wonder if lab automation would be a good topic for the YC Research efforts.
- biofox 10y agoI think it would. As things are at the moment, biologists spend most of their time doing repetitive manual labour. One of the most promising things I've seen is the Emerald Cloud Lab, but it's still a long way off from what's needed: http://emeraldcloudlab.com/ http://emeraldcloudlab.com/
- Kliment 10y agoHey, I'd like to talk with you about automating some of that stuff, but there's no contact info in your profile. My email and IRC contact are in mine if you'd be willing to get in touch.