2 ms·
Going for the Gold: The Economics of the Olympics
- kogepathic 10y agoHow about a warning that this is a PDF?
- LeifCarrotson 10y agoThe good news is it's just a text document, which appears to have been generated in LaTeX, and it weighs in at 256 kB. That's less than most HTML pages! So if you clicked it on mobile, and your device didn't handle it gracefully for some reason (are there still some which don't?), you didn't waste much data.
- dmix 10y ago> Since that time, however, over half of all bids have come from this group, including applications by Istanbul, Bangkok, Havana, Doha, and Cape Town, as well as the successful bids from Beijing and Rio de Janiero Well, it's a good thing Istanbul didn't get it... that would have been a security disaster given recent events. > The true final cost of the 1998 Nagano Winter Olympics will never be known, because the host committee ordered a portion of the event’s financial records to be burned (Jordan and Sullivan 1999). What rational reason could there be to do this? Unless it's to hide something. > From 1968 to 2012, every single Olympic Games ended up costing more than originally estimated. The median Games were 150 percent over the original budget, with the worst offenders—Montreal 1976 and Sarajevo 1984—exceeding initial estimates by more than ten-fold (Flyvbjerg and Stewart 2012). I'm curious if estimates get adjusted for this reason (to be higher) that they still end up exceeding the new estimates. It might be best to low-ball the estimate but have good contingency plans that aren't made public. One thing I've learned from making more money over the years is that financial budgets have a way of becoming self-realizing, always growing to fill capacity. It takes quite a bit of constraint and learning to address this - something these Olympic host countries don't have the ability to do, as they are always hosting it for the first time. They have no local experience to draw from.
- Someone 10y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2002_Winter_Olympic_bid_scandal#Winning_bid https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2002_Winter_Olympic_bid_scan...: "A Salt Lake Olympic Bid Committee member complained about competing with the Japanese bid committee for the 1998 Olympic Winter Games: "We were giving out saltwater taffy and cowboy hats, and they were giving out computers. IOC members who came to inspect Nagano were put up in ritzy hotspring resorts, where they washed down expensive sushi with sake poured by kimono-clad geisha. They went home laden with souvenir gifts and expensive paintings." A senior member of the Japanese bid committee, Sumikazu Yamaguchi, ordered that accounting documents for the Nagano bid be burned because they "could cause unpleasantness to [IOC members]." The Melbourne bid committee for the 1996 Summer Olympics discovered the quid pro quo expectations of IOC delegates when they received requests from six African IOC delegates for new cars and sexual favors from local brothels. They denied the requests and the 1996 Summer Olympics went to Atlanta."
- benmmurphy 10y agoits seems a bit like an agency problem. there is a lot of benefits from being the person who 'wins' the olympics or having political power while construction and planning for the olympics is going on. so it is not surprising that lots of cities will aggressively bid for the olympics even if it is not necessarily in the general interest. and this intense competition makes it even worse for the winning city :( do you think cities bidding for the olympics understand winners curse?
- LeifCarrotson 10y agoThe article mentions both aspects. Boston's retracted bid was spearheaded by the construction and hospitality industries before being retracted after public outcry. Autocratic regimes are more likely to subvert the overall good and ignore or suppress this outcry for their own private good. And as far as the winner's curse goes: > it is possible to ascribe a portion of the economic failings of the Olympics to the “winner’s curse,” the result in auction theory that when parties are bidding on an asset of uncertain value (like rights to offshore oil leasing tracts), the winner will tend to be the bidder who is most prone to overestimating the value of the asset—which means that the winner is likely to be systematically disappointed (for an overview of the “winner’s curse,” see Thaler 1988). Or see Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winner%27s_curse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winner%27s_curse To state it differently, the winner of a contracting project which was awarded to the lowest quote, assuming equal labor costs, is the one who most underestimated its difficulty and scope creep. That helps me understand a few projects I have been involved in.
- pasbesoin 10y agoI've reduced this problem to one personal choice: Boycott. There's a bunch of cognitive overload I can now instead devote to something else. If they ever return from money to sportsmanship -- maybe also just parking the thing back in Greece, permanently -- maybe I'll give it another look. Sports are for doing. If you're watching, and spending, more than you're doing, you're doing it wrong. You've gone from entertainment, to distraction from and substitution for better things. IMHO.