3 ms·
It seems like you're suggesting that as an alternative, we use collective punishment. City dwellers should be putting up with an unpleasant urban environment un
by skybrian 10y ago
It seems like you're suggesting that as an alternative, we use collective punishment. City dwellers should be putting up with an unpleasant urban environment until someone fixes the homeless problem. Therefore any stopgap measures should be resisted.
It's not clear whether this works. On the one hand it does keep the homeless visible. On the other hand it also punishes people who can't practically participate in local politics (tourists for example). And in general, politically powerful people aren't waiting at bus stops all that much, so this strategy doesn't seem all that well-targetted.
It may also be counterproductive in that it makes people less rather than more willing to support measures that help the homeless and instead promote measures that punish them in return. That is, punishment may encourage more punishment in response.
But I'm just speculating here. It seems like this is unlikely to be settled without actual evidence.
- Kristine1975 10y ago> On the other hand it also punishes people who can't practically participate in local politics (tourists for example) Seeing homeless people is punishment?
- skybrian 10y agoIf homeless people are living in the park, other people aren't using it. (Edited)
- Mithaldu 10y agoSeeing homeless people can be worse than punishment?
- jerf 10y agoYou keep calling for people to see the homeless as human, but you're not doing it yourself. You seem to have some infantalized, romantic image of them where they are not capable of doing any wrong and anything that happens to them is the result of external forces out of their control. But they are human. They may be wonderful people down on their luck. They are also capable of being horrible people, committing crimes without any particular excuse, and making bad decisions that are every bit as much their responsibility as it is mine when I make bad decisions. That is irreducibly part of what it means to be human, and if you take that from a group, you have dehumanized them. And in the aggregate, a group of them will inevitably contain some of the latter. You can't address the problem by neglecting that fact. Many have tried, and as always happens when the solution doesn't match the real problem in the real world, those solutions failed. If berating people about homelessness was the solution, the problem would be solved already. That solution has been tried a lot.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoMaybe not 'every bit as much their responsibility'. People can be backed into a corner, and do things we cannot imagine sitting comfortably in our armchairs. See "Les Miserables" for an example.
- Mithaldu 10y agoYou're failing to see the point: It is anti-social to force everyone to fully take on the responsibility of all their actions, singularly and personally, forever and with no limits. You hurt only yourself by creating traps that not everyone can escape from, and then having to live with people who have to fight for a living by any means they can. As for solutions having been tried: Germany does a damn good job of dealing with unemployed and worse off as actual humans and has no homeless epidemic. As for your first point: Supposition and assumption. My sister is the very first example of a person who has done a LOT in her life wrong and is "paying" for her mistakes by having to live on government aid. I pay fairly high taxes, pretty much half of all i earn, but i do it happily knowing that so does everyone else, resulting in my sister and my nephew living in dignity, with my nephew having access to high quality primary and secondary education and a chance to be something better; without any single person having to sacrifice most of their life to enable this.
- biztos 10y agoThe point about Germany is absolutely true, and merits closer examination. The three main cities in my life are Berlin, Budapest and San Francisco. Budapest and San Francisco have very serious homeless problems; Berlin does not. It's easy to point at Budapest and say: it's much poorer than Berlin, in a much poorer country, with government not much interested in the poor, etc. But San Francisco is waaay richer than Berlin, and of the three has (in my experience) the worst homeless problem. (I realize you probably couldn't "solve" homelessness in SF without simultaneously "solving" it throughout the US, but that's kind of the point: this is not some force of nature we are doomed to live with in an advanced economy.)
- Mithaldu 10y agoYou complain against punishment, but you seem to be accepting of people already being punished for having been failed by their society in the first place.
- skybrian 10y agoI'm just pointing out some problems to consider. That doesn't say anything about what solutions I'll support.