15 ms·
On 28 July, Mr Blair wrote to President Bush with an assurance that he would be with him “whatever” [...] At the end of January, Mr Blair accepted the US
by michaelt 10y ago
On 28 July, Mr Blair wrote to President Bush with an
assurance that he would be with him “whatever”
[...]
At the end of January, Mr Blair accepted the US timetable
for military action by mid-March.
[...]
As late as 17 March, Mr Blair was being advised by the
Chairman of the Joint Intelligence Committee that Iraq
possessed chemical and biological weapons, the means to
deliver them and the capacity to produce them.
Seems to me the lesson here is: If you decide to invade first, then later you invite your intelligence agencies to "get with the program, jump on the team and come on in for the big win" when it's clear what you want them to tell you, they'll tell you that.
Trying to shift blame to them after things went badly seems like scapegoating to me.
I mean, that's like going to a car dealership and asking the salesman if his cars are reliable. There's no point in even asking, because you already know he'll say yes regardless of the truth.
- krylon 10y agoI do not believe for a second that either Blair or Bush actually believed in those mythical weapons of mass destruction or Iraq's capability or intention to use them. I sometimes wonder if the WMD excuse was made up to convince the public to go along or to cover their butts later on. In Europe, as far as I remember, hardly anyone believed that excuse. Accept for Angela Merkel who travelled to Washington just to tell Bush that she would join the invasion without hesitation if she was chancellor.
- arethuza 10y agoThe truly scary thing about the likes of Blair is that they can choose what they earnestly believe in to suit what is politically expedient.
- lucozade 10y agoMy view prior to the report and from what I've seen so far in the Bush-Blair correspondence is the exact opposite. They and the intelligence services were so convinced about WMD that there was next to no questioning, at high levels, of the flimsy evidence for their continued existence. I believe that they thought they were justified and that finding WMDs would be vindication. It doesn't seem reasonable that such astute political operators would make WMDs the centre of their justification if they didn't think that they existed. The failing was that this blinded them to the possibility that the Iraqi regime was bluffing.
- sevenless 10y agoIt makes sense when you consider they believed the war would succeed, in terms of installing a peaceful and compliant regime in Iraq. After all, nobody holds inquiries into military victories. The success in shifting the justification for war from WMD to getting rid of Saddam, or even less plausibly, fighting terrorism, shows that marketing strategy partly succeeded. Blair still justifies the war in terms of having got rid of Saddam Hussein. In short: they didn't know, and didn't care. Remember under Bush there was also Wolfowitz and Feith's Office of Special Plans, which supplied Bush administration officials with cherry-picked, dodgy, raw intelligence, bypassing the CIA. WMD were never a credible excuse for war in the first place, rather (ironically) a legal argument. The mere existence of chemical weapons is not a reasonable premise to launch a war. Claiming a castrated Iraq was any kind of threat to the United States or Britain was ludicrous. Finally, there was no bluff going on - that's revisionist history. Saddam was complying with weapons inspectors right up to the time the invasion began.
- ams6110 10y agoI think another lesson is that you cannot conduct a "surgical" war. We have seen this in every failed military action since Vietnam. If you are going to go to war, the strategy should be total destruction of your enemy and his complete surrender. If you're not willing to do that, it's not worth even getting involved.
- themihai 10y agoI think it worked in Kosovo and Sierra Leone. That was one of the arguments made by Blair today.
- lucozade 10y ago> WMD were never a credible excuse for war in the first place I couldn't agree more. Neither the UK nor US were under an existential threat. Even if they had reason to believe that there was a direct threat to an ally i.e. Israel, that is no reason to wage pre-emptive war. > Finally, there was no bluff going on - that's revisionist history That's simply not true. The Iraqi government were deliberately dicking the IAEA inspectors around trying to maintain the fiction that they still had chemical weapons. They wanted the outside world to believe that they were a threat but gambled that there was no political will to do anything about it. They were right on the former and, until 9/11, right on the latter. What I find shocking is the gullibility of the intelligence services and the politicians. What I consider heinous is that they were willing to wage pre-emptive war regardless of the motive.
- ACow_Adonis 10y agoA common quality amongst many "leaders" in our society (and by "leaders", I mean a particular brand of relatively high functioning psychopath/narcissist that tends to thrive in such environments, be it politics or the boardroom/management/e-suite) is the ability to believe whatever they need to believe to paint themselves in the best possible light and achieve their ends at that particular time. If you do not have that little voice that whispers what you're doing is wrong, or that you're a fraud, or that you really shouldn't be doing that, or that its not fair or right... or even any internal concern with objective truth or fact, you will find it remarkably easy to climb in many hierarchical structures, because you don't have to pay the cognitive costs many of the the others need to pay to remain there. Now I, unsurprisingly, don't know Bush or Blair. Maybe they're actually people...who cynically make up facts, spread lies, and throw away lives for their own political agenda. Or maybe they're just ignorant fools who went into it all based on emotions and all the spineless yes men just set them up with a self-reinforcing circle jerk, like a government level facebook filter-bubble. That's probably the best/most flattering possible interpretation... But given I believe there are a disproportionate number of "reality-warpers" in leadership positions, I must at least concede its POSSIBLE they really did believe there were weapons of mass destruction. In reality, its probably some banal mixture of all the above...
- agumonkey 10y agoI tend to believe in similar structure. What amazes me is how this bubbling is so natural for societies. What is it that groups like in this kind of individual ? massive lack of doubt that appease flocks ?
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoPsychopaths are unusually charming and persuasive. Business, law, and politics are all about persuasion, not truth or honesty. So by default they're environments in which psychopaths can thrive. I think there's exactly one political problem - how to keep psychopaths away from money, power, and influence. Everything else that goes wrong in politics and business is a direct result of feedback loops that reward psychopathic traits instead of excluding them. The world would be an infinitely more pleasant and more effective place if this could be achieved.
- rhino369 10y agoJust think this through for a second. If they were bold enough to intentionally fabricate a lie to go to war, why didn't they fabricate some evidence of a WMD program? So either they told a lie that they knew would exposed within a couple months of an invasion OR they were wrong. The later is much more likely. Assuming malice actually turns us away from the real questions that should be asked. Why were they wrong? What did they do that led them down the wrong path? How can we make sure that doesn't happen again. But if you just assume they were being badguys you miss all that.
- grkvlt 10y agoyep. and of course, all the time saddam was playing a dangerous game of brinksmanship, pretending he had WMD in order to maintain iraq's position locally and globally, by refusing to allow inspections by the UN, and delaying and obfuscating facts when forced to comply. so it's no wonder the WMD line seemed plausible at the time.
- arethuza 10y agoMax Hastings makes the point in his book on intelligence in WW2 (The Secret War: Spies, Codes and Guerrillas 1939-1945) that intelligence agencies always tell their political masters what they want to hear - this happens in democracies and totalitarian regimes. It was presumably clear to those in MI6 that Blair had already decided to go to war, so what would have been in it for them to try and persuade him otherwise? Probably an early retirement at best.
- pjc50 10y agoIf this is unavoidable, why bother with the thing at all and just have a skeleton staff of actors to roleplay the yes-men? (A point I keep trying to make about the War on Terror is that trying to do it invisibly, with intelligence agencies, is tempting but ineffective. These agencies cannot be effectively reviewed, and produce intelligence which cannot be used in court or presented to the public. So we end up with a long series of unaccountable murders by drone feeding into whatever the next Arab civil war is. Whereas a policing approach would produce evidence for inspection in public, after which those convicted of terrorism could be imprisoned with our consciences clear.)
- emodendroket 10y ago> If this is unavoidable, why bother with the thing at all and just have a skeleton staff of actors to roleplay the yes-men? Arguably it is the responsibility of leaders not to tilt their hands before the intelligence is available.
- a3n 10y agoBut it's the inclination of leaders, and everyone else, to lean toward their desires and preconceptions.
- emodendroket 10y agoThere's a difference between an inclination and obviously not wanting to hear something different.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- cpncrunch 10y agoThe people I blame most are the MPs who voted for the war. It was pretty clear at the time that there was no evidence for the WMDs or for breaches of the UN resolution by Saddam. The MPs should have investigated the evidence and asked tough questions. Instead they just did what they were told by Tony Blair. So much for democracy.