3 ms·
> “the body is made of things, and things don’t have thoughts.” Ha! I could say the opposite. The body is not made of magical stuff, just plain matter. And it
by visarga 10y ago
> “the body is made of things, and things don’t have thoughts.”
Ha! I could say the opposite. The body is not made of magical stuff, just plain matter. And it has consciousness, it feels like something to be alive. So, consciousness cannot be but the result of matter arranged in space.
Let's make an analogy. Say you have a car on the road. It is free to move. Then come many more cars. Suddenly, the road is gridlocked. Is "being gridlocked" a property of the single car? Is it a property that only appears when multiple cars are in a certain relationship? Where does "being gridlocked" reside, in the car, in the road, in the other cars? http://biser3a.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/12/gridlock.jpg http://biser3a.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/12/gridlock.jpg
I believe that emergent properties can and do occur. The new properties emerge from the complex structure of causal relations that exists between simpler elements. This complex web is "stuff" that adds to, and changes, the simple elements of which the system is formed. In other words, the emergent system is made of its constituent parts plus the internal structure, and this internal structure is a property of space and time. Similarly, matter itself might be insentient, but matter arranged in special patterns in space and time is conscious, thus consciousness comes from the properties of space-time, not just from the constituent matter of the body. The space-time arrangement is the software, the atoms of the body are the hardware. They work together to generate consciousness.
- majewsky 10y agoOf course "being gridlocked" is a property residing in the individual cars. It just becomes measurable only when you pile up a lot of them in one place. ;)